WFNY takes a look back at the Browns-Jets trades of 2009.
Mark Duncan/Associated PressHindsight 20/20: Was the Braylon Edwards trade a good idea?
As you know by now, Eric Mangini is gone as Browns coach. But a year before his release, Eric Mangini, talent evaluator/roster guru, was relieved of his duties with the hiring of Tom Heckert.
As we see now, it was a move forced on him in order to keep his Head Coach title in Cleveland for a second year, turning out to be a stay of execution. Anyone who watched Browns football can easily admit that Eric Mangini as Head Coach was much better than Eric Mangini as Manager of all things Browns Football.
Mangini wasn't ready for it, but that didn't stop Aston Villa Cleveland Browns Owner Randy Lerner from handing The Manginius the keys to his Bentley. This started with the 2009 NFL Draft, where the Browns held the fifth-overall pick thanks to their horrific 2008 season where they faced reality (in the form of a regular, non-Charmin-soft schedule) and finished 4-12.
At the time, the Browns were thought to be one of the teams looking to draft a franchise quarterback, as the jury was clearly still out on Derek Anderson and Brady Quinn. Apparently, in Mangini's evaluation, he could get by with the duo for at least one more year. After the player most thought the Browns sought - LB Aaron Curry - was scooped up by Seattle in the fourth spot, Mangini and his hand-picked GM (with no authority), George Kokinis, were on the clock.
When identifying his pre-draft roster plan, Mangini did his best Bill Belichick impersonation. He made a deal with his old team, the New York Jets, who desperately wanted a face of their franchise with a new stadium on the horizon and a Grand Canyon-sized hole at QB with the "retirement" of Brett Favre.
Doing what he clearly thought was best, Mangini dealt the fifth pick to New York and received what he viewed as a king's ransom - three players and two draft picks. The players were all "Mangini guys" - safety Abe Elam, defensive end Kenyon Coleman, and quarterback Brett Ratliff. The picks were the Jets first-rounder (#17) and their second-rounder (#52).
"Okay," we all thought. Its a win-win for both franchises. The Jets got their quarterback; a good-looking, charismatic kid from USC, perfect for the big city. The Browns needed picks and depth everywhere, and to be able to snag two players who would most likely play right away (Elam and Coleman) as well as an additional second-round pick? Seemed like a good move. Second round picks are like gold in the NFL these days because of the expected instant impact and relatively inexpensive contracts.
Except that you MUST hit with that additional second-rounder if you are a team like the Browns, so devoid of talent seemingly everywhere. And what did the Browns do?
The 52nd pick was the last of their three second-rounders. The first two were both wide receivers - Brian Robiske (#35) and Mohammad Massaquoi (#50 - the pick they received from Tampa Bay for TE Kellen Winslow). Two picks after Massaquoi, Mangini decided to go after a little known defensive end from Hawaii in David Veikune. The hope was that Veikune would be able to transform himself into a 3-4 pass-rushing outside linebacker.
Two seasons later, we sit here just a few days from the AFC title game. How did those deals work out for the involved teams?
For the Jets, it's been everything they could have asked for. From day one, Sanchez took over as the starting QB and has not only steadily improved his play, he has become best known for his late-game heroics, including pulling an all-time rabbit-out-of-his-hat move in Cleveland as the Jets won in overtime, 26-20. This Sunday, "The Sanchize" will lead his team into its second consecutive appearance in the AFC Championship game. He has won four road playoff games over the likes of San Diego, Indianapolis and New England. No quarterback has ever won five playoff games on the road.
Meanwhile, the Browns didn't exactly enjoy the riches of this deal.
Previous WFNY Browns coverage
More From WFNY
The PlayersThe three players they received are non-descript at best. Elam has been a two-year starter, but hasn't had near the impact that was expected of him. Coleman is a serviceable D-line rotation kind of guy, but nothing needle-moving. Ratliff spent 2009 as the third QB and never saw the field. In 2010, he was the odd man out once the Browns signed Jake Delhomme, traded for Seneca Wallace and drafted Colt McCoy. Thanks to the high ankle sprain parade, Ratliff came back for a few weeks as McCoy's backup, but was later released.
The PicksThe Browns took the Jets first rounder and spun it down two slots to get an additional sixth round pick from Tampa Bay. The Bucs took their franchise QB with that pick, Josh Freeman, who is viewed around the league as a real gamer and led Tampa to 10 wins in his first full season as the starter. Mangini again chose to move down in the first round, a third time, two spots again. Trading with Philadelphia, he again gained an additional sixth-rounder.
Finally, at pick #21, the Browns had their guy. Like he had done two years earlier in New York with former Buckeye Nick Mangold, Mangini drafted a center to anchor the middle of his line for the next decade plus. This time, it was Alex Mack from Cal, a "good, solid, safe pick" seemed to be the consensus from analysts.
Mack has turned out to be head and shoulders above anyone else who came along in this trade. He is highly regarded as one of the best in the game and hasn't missed a snap in his two seasons. A solid pick, absolutely, until you consider that the Browns were in dire need of a pass rushing outside linebacker and there was one right there for the taking. They decided Mack was the better value pick here. The kid they passed over?
Clay Matthews, who the Packers took four picks later.
In a year that the Browns were desperate for some good PR, wouldn't drafting Matthews, the son of one the the team's most beloved ex-players, and putting him in his father's #57 been a master stroke? Its bad enough he has become perhaps the most feared pass rusher in the game. He was there for the taking, the son of a Browns legend, and they passed.
Did I mention that Tom Heckert and the Eagles drafted WR Jeremy Maclin in the Browns' spot? He's been a two-year starter in Philadelphia and exactly what the Browns hope Massaquoi could be.
But that's another story for another day.
Then there's Veikune.
The former Hawaii standout never could make any sort of impact with the Browns. Mangini and his staff tried their best to convert this undersized DE into a 3-4 OLB, but it just wasn't happening. When the pick was made, it had "bust" written all over it. As I stated above, those second-round picks are like gold, and when you are a team like the Browns, you just cannot afford to swing and miss as badly as this. Veikune couldn't make the team out of camp during his second season in Cleveland.
Want some more salt in the wound?
Tom Heckert and the Eagles took RB LeSean McCoy with the pick following Veikune.
So what about those extra sixth-round picks Mangini got for moving down twice? The first was cornerback Coye Francies from San Jose State. He seemed to have made a name for himself during training camp in 2009, except he found himself in Mangini's doghouse and never found his way out thanks to his bad temper. Francies was released and brought back this season, but only managed to see the field over the last two games as an extra corner.
The other sixth-round pick was running back James Davis from Clemson. Davis, like Francies, looked like a keeper, winning the Bassett Award for the best rookie in camp. He was thought to have a role in the offense as the change of pace back with Jamal Lewis except that preseason football and regular season football are two completely different things.
Davis got four carries in the opener, gaining just five yards. Two games later, he had five carries for 10 yards, and was never seen again. He was placed on injured reserve with a shoulder injury that happened during the Browns post-practice "opportunity period." Davis made the team out of camp this year, but again, rarely was active. Strangely, he became the odd man out when the team actually needed him, and was released in October.
So to recap:
- The Jets got Sanchez and are now entering their second consecutive AFC Championship game.
- The Buccaneers got Freeman who in his first full year as a starter, won 10 games.
- The Eagles got Maclin, a speedy outside threat who has been perfect for their West Coast offense. He caught 70 balls for for 964 yards and 10 TDs this past season.
- The Browns received two serviceable, yet unspectacular veteran players (Elam and Coleman), a third string QB who was released (Ratliff), a rookie center who was a hit (Mack) and three extra draft picks (Veikune, Davis, and Francies), none of whom made it through two full seasons with the team.
Is their any question of who got the short end of this series of deals?
But wait, there's more.
In October of 2009, Mangini had enough of big-mouthed, stone-handed wide receiver Braylon Edwards. After his brush with a LeBron James posse member outside of Cleveland nightclub ended in an arrest, Mangini rightfully
shipped Edwards out of town. Once again, he dealt with his former club, the Jets.
This time, The Browns received two players and two picks. Wide receiver Chansi Stuckey and linebaker Jason Trusnik - two more "Mangini guys" - came over and played right away. The picks were a bonus - 2010 third- and fifth-rounders.
At the time of the trade, you could have given me a bag of footballs for Braylon and I'd have been thrilled as he was a cancer to his team and to the city. I've never seen a player despised so severely by his own fan base as Edwards was here. But as we know, he did it to himself. He was as thrilled to leave Cleveland as we were to have him leave. He took plenty of shots out the door which just reinforced Browns fans hatred of him.
Fast forward a year and a half and what do both teams have?
Edwards, while still dropping the occasional pass and committing at least one dumb penalty a game, has been the deep threat the Jets sorely lacked. He and fellow AFC North cast-off Santonio Holmes command respect on the outside and open up things for the Jets power running game.
The PlayersThe Browns sit with a slot receiver in Stuckey, who will most likely be remembered in Cleveland as the guy who fumbled the ball away in overtime in the season turning loss to his old team, the Jets. Trusnik is a special teams standout who got more playing time on defense than expected. He is a classic Mangini kind of guy - a hard working, total over-achiever who can play special teams. If he neither guy is on the roster next year, nobody will be surprised.
The PicksThe extra third-round pick the Browns received was used on guard Shawn Lauvao. The Arizona State product was expected to challenge for a starting job in training camp. Safety Larry Asante, a big hitter from Nebraska, was drafted with the fifth-round pick the Browns received from the Jets. Lauvao battled injuries all year and when he was used with the first unit, looked over-matched at times. He will be back next year and will once again challenge for a starting job somewhere on the line. Asante didn't make the team out of camp, but spent time on the Practice Squad. Later in the season, the Browns lost Asante when Tampa Bay signed him to their 53-man roster.
Again, the Jets came out of this trade as a winner. but in reality, the Browns won as well just because they were able to jettison Edwards out of Cleveland for something in return. Rumors swirled at the time that the Browns may even release him. His time in Cleveland was over. He knew, and we all knew it. There were no losers in this deal.
The bottom line in this league is wins and losses. We stand here on January 19th with the Jets playing in the AFC title game for the second straight time. The Browns, in the meantime, first stripped Mangini of his personnel duties, and then fired him after a second 5-11 season.
Where would you rather be?