The more tentacles OHSAA's proposed playoff solution grows, the more I'm convinced this is a problem that never will be solved.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- As a fisherman, I know to keep the lid on my worms. When I don't, it's chaos in wormville.
Welcome to wormville.
While I applaud the Ohio High School Athletic Association for a creative approach to an impossible-to-please-everyone dilemma, the more tentacles its proposed playoff solution grows, the more I'm convinced this is a problem that never will be solved.
The solution itself has more snags than the issue. A recently proposed referendum -- to be voted on by principals in May -- would reset divisions according to a series of mathematical factors that take into account tradition, economics and mostly how schools admit students, whether private or public with open enrollment.
It is a complicated, but not convoluted, proposal. Each factor was developed with sound reasoning and good intentions. The goal is to level the playing field in high school sports, where private and some non-boundaried public schools have a huge advantage when it comes to accumulating talent.
The proposal has major flaws and the cumulative effect will be negligible on the balance of power. Also, it unfairly dumps some of the problem onto the laps of Division I schools, which also have the unresolved burden of an enormous disparity between the smallest and largest Division I schools.
The Westlakes and North Olmsteds still will run into St. Ignatius and Magnificat, and under the proposed changes, private school powers such as Lake Catholic and Hathaway Brown might be added to the Division I mix.
While making Division I more difficult, consider what could occur in football divisions II, III, IV and V. Division VI might rid itself of Delphos St. John, which beat Shadyside in the state final, 77-6. But St. John could move up to Division V, which might kick superpower Youngstown Ursuline to Division IV, and so on. Same problem. Different uniforms.
As unfair as it may seem, the best solution might be to just leave the lid on the worms. Let the best play the best regardless of how they get their students. Yes it's hard, but not everyone deserves a trophy. The disadvantage can be overcome.
Olmsted Falls volleyball, Wadsworth wrestling, Maple Heights football and Independence boys cross country are recent examples of public school state champions defying the odds. The real solution is build a better program.