In Berea, It's always been difficult to distinguish between change for the better and change for the sake of it, sports columnist Bud Shaw writes in his Spin column.
John Kuntz / The Plain DealerAdding talented young players such as Joe Haden (deflecting a pass to Miami's Marlon Moore last month) would seem to be more essential in improving the Browns' defense than shifting from the 3-4 to the 4-3, says Bud Shaw. CLEVELAND, Ohio -- There is change for the better and change for the sake of it. In Berea it's always been hard to tell them apart...
What we're seeing in Berea is not a start-over. The Browns have a structure in place (just empty rooms where assistant coaches should be sitting).
The change from whatever it was the Browns were running a year ago to the Mike Holmgren West Coast Offense leased to new head coach Pat Shurmur is one thing. It's the expected switch from the 3-4 to the 4-3 that promises to be a an episode of "Extreme Makeover."
It's hard to argue against a more sophisticated passing offense as the right approach to winning in the NFL in 2011. Colt McCoy looked more and more suited to the shorter, ball-control West Coast offense as the cold and wind arrived to the lakefront.
There's heavier lifting to be done in switching systems defensively. So much talk about the West Coast Offense. So little about why the 4-3 -- and the personnel adjustments -- that come with it is even necessary.
Proponents of the 3-4 believe it's better suited to dealing with the multiple receiver sets prevalent around the league these days. It's designed to pressure the quarterback and more easily disguise the pass rush. Greater flexibility is the idea.
So how'd that work for the Browns? Right. But look around the league, or just the division where Pittsburgh's 3-4 seems to work well enough. Rob Ryan and the 3-4 wasn't the problem last season.
GM Tom Heckert says age would've forced roster changes anyway. But the 4-3 will require a more dynamic pass rush from the defensive line at a time when the linebacker spot needs an overhaul, a time when the future at cornerback amounts to not much more than Joe Haden (unless you're counting on Eric Wright).
Changing defensive coordinators and switching to the 4-3 is a such a major undertaking the payoff doesn't seem worth it.
SPINOFFS
Gail Burton / Associated PressIt turns out that Mike Tomlin (and almost all football coaches) is shocked -- shocked! -- that a reporter might ... actually ... report (in the mildest way possible) on the Steelers' game-day plans during the playoffs. Somehow, national security was not compromised. The NFL is selling $200 tickets to the Super Bowl in Dallas. Fans will have to sit on the grass on the east side of the stadium and watch on huge TV screens. Would a league that can sell $200 tickets to not watch the Super Bowl live really be dumb enough to blow itself up in a labor dispute?
Oh, and the seats must be purchased in blocks of four. While a parking pass is included, no word on whether you have to pay for the dunce cap...
ESPN's Bob Holtzman reported Saturday two Steelers told him they had a trick play ready for Baltimore. This was more than four hours before the game and -- according to USA Today -- angered head coach Mike Tomlin. So when Holtzman asked Tomlin Wednesday how much time he'd need to prepare for the Jets' defense, the wind chill took a sharp downturn. Said Tomlin, "It depends on whether or not you give him my plays"...
Byron Scott is threatening to bench players who fail to carry out their more simplified defensive assignments. Given the NBDL outposts where some of these guys toiled, can a bench in the NBA really feel like Siberia and act as a deterrent? ...
Miami head coach Tony Sparano hired former Browns' offensive coordinator Brian Daboll because he didn't believe Daboll got a fair shot in 2010 due to injured quarterbacks, a general lack of talent, and other constraints (Eric Mangini). He also liked the game plan the Browns used to beat the Dolphins this season.
This seems like a good time to say that the criticism of coordinator Dan Henning in Miami centered around playing for field goals and abandoning the Wildcat too easily. So ... good luck with the new man...
ESPN would not comment on when Daboll's one-hour special will air...
Good guy Mike Hargrove is joining the Indians. As with good guys Sandy Alomar and Charlie Nagy joining in previous seasons, big crowds are expected at Progressive Field.
As long as it's Fireworks Night...
The University of Texas announced a 20-year, $300 million deal with ESPN for a round-the-clock TV network broadcasting Longhorn sports, including minor, non-revenue sports. How long before the field hockey players see the money they're bringing in and sell their skorts for tattoos? ...
Bill Belichick benched receiver Wes Welker after Welker's comments indirectly poking fun at Jets head coach Rex Ryan's foot fetish videos. Welker missed only one offensive series. Why bother? Only Jim Tressel would consider that harsh...
HE SAID IT
Hillary Jones-Mixon / Oakland TribuneCome to think about it, some mutant powers might be necessary to help these two guys with the Oakland Raiders. "The fire in [him] will set a flame that will burn for a long time in the hearts and minds of the Raider football team and the Raider Nation." -- owner Al Davis on the long-ago hiring of John Madden ... wait, no... Jon Gruden ...hold on, I'm being told that's not correct either ... Hue Jackson?
Just checking, but Davis doesn't think he just hired Wolverine from X-Men, does he?
SEPARATED AT BIRTH
Dave Wannstedt and Doc Severinsen -- Steve Miller
Herman Edwards and Seinfeld character Jackie Childs. They even talk alike. -- Gary, Brecksville
DaJuan Wagner and Mo Williams. (Same number as well) -- Bob
WKYC's Chris Tye and Family Guy's Quagmire? -- Mark Dahler
YOU SAID IT
(The Winning-Never-Ends Midweek Edition)
Hey Bud:
"Shurmur Time
"And the Winning is easy.
"Colt is passin,
"and Robiskie jumps high.
"Our Randy's rich
"and Holmgren is cookin'.
"So Hush Little Browns Fan
"don't you cry." -- Pat.
Pat? Pat Shurmur, is that you?
"Bud:
"Trying the new South Beach Diet ... read about LeBron James ... throw up ... repeat ad nauseum." -- Bob Futey, Cortland, Ohio
First-time "You Said It" winners receive a T-shirt from the Mental Floss collection.
"Bud:
"After hiring Pat Shurmur, Mike Holmgren said, 'This is the first head coach that I've hired, and I trust it will be my last.' Where's Holmgren going?" -- Chas K, Cleveland Heights
Repeat winners receive a walking boot autographed by Holmgren.
"Bud:
"Don't you think it's fortunate Austin Kearns didn't play well enough that the Indians couldn't afford to re-sign him?" -- Jim O, Chardon
Repeat winners also receive a day on the 40-man roster.
"Bud:
"I can't seem to shed the image of our owner 'across the pond' the day his hand-picked coach is led to slaughter against our hated rivals. I get that soccer is his true passion. And maybe I'm just the red-headed stepchild searching for approval, but aren't we kind of like a soccer team? We rarely score and drunken fisticuffs are a post-game ritual. So why doesn't he love us? Why?" -- Steve Miller, Cleveland
And a bicycle kick in the stomach.