The Indians' recent 11-game losing streak crushed them in the standings and pinched them in the wallet, but they have bigger problems as this season draws to a close.
OAKLAND, Calif. -- The Indians' 11-game losing streak ruined their season in the standings, taking them from contenders to Palookaville in one big punch. Yet what did it cost them in the wallet?
One person in the know figures the Indians lost about 100,000 in attendance over the last 29 home games because of the streak. That includes the homestand earlier this month against the Twins and Red Sox when the streak ended.
Total cost? Probably about $2.4 million based on the average ticket price of $24, including concessions and parking costs, at Progressive Field. So we're talking about the salary of a utility infielder. A drop in the bucket. The four-game series against the Red Sox, always a popular foe in Cleveland, drew 102,767 fans, an average of almost 26,000. Those were almost all pre-sale tickets.
If the Indians had been hot, if they'd been within 31/2 games of first place in the AL Central as they were before the losing streak started, walk up crowds may have increased by 4,000 or 5,000 per game to see the Red Sox.
The Indians have drawn 1,219,954 fans for 59 home games. Among MLB's 30 teams, they rank 29th in total home attendance. Tampa Bay is the only team which has drawn fewer -- 1,213,768. In average home attendance, the Indians rank 28th at 20,677. Tampa Bay at 20,572 and Oakland at 20,539 are 29th and 30th, respectively. The Rays and Oakland are still very much involved in the race for the postseason.
The Indians have 22 home games left when this West Coast swing ends Wednesday in Seattle. The most attractive series will be the Yankees' three-game visit starting Friday. After that it will pretty much be the voice of play-by-play man Tom Hamilton echoing throughout the empty corridors and seats at Progressive Field.
September visits by AL Central foes Detroit and Chicago have lost their edge with the Indians tumbling out of the race. The Indians will probably reach 1.7 million in attendance. That's down from 1.84 million in 2011, but still a jump from 2010, when the team drew a Progressive Field low of 1.4 million.
It would seem the losing streak is the least of the franchise's problems. This team, which spent 40 days in first place earlier this season, never really captured Cleveland's imagination. Young players such as Michael Brantley and Vinnie Pestano have performed well, but no one has had a breakout, Mike Trout-type of year. Carlos Santana brought excitement in 2011 by hitting 27 homers, a club record for switch-hitters. This year his power has been negated.
Justin Masterson and Josh Tomlin each won 12 games in 2011, but Masterson has struggled this year and Tomlin is on the disabled list with a sore right elbow. Closer Chris Perez saved 36 games in 2011, his first big year. This year he's become the face of the franchise for not only saving games, but criticizing fans for not coming to the ballpark. As a marketing tool, he is a double-edged sword at best.
Among the veterans, Asdrubal Cabrera had a career season in 2011 with 25 homers and 91 RBI. This year he's been OK. Derek Lowe had a great start, but faded badly and was released. Johnny Damon never got started and was released. Travis Hafner is hurt again. Grady Sizemore still hasn't played a game and the best that can be said about Casey Kotchman is that he can defensively play the heck out of first base.
There are some who say fans ignored the Indians this year because they have a trust issue with the Dolan ownership. The issue is ownership won't pay to keep quality players -- CC Sabathia, Victor Martinez, Cliff Lee, etc. -- and won't pay to sign quality players from the outside. Perhaps there's some truth there, but does a trust issue really keep a person away from Progressive Field on a Friday night in July if they want to see big-league baseball?
The simple solution to some is fire everybody, starting with manager Manny Acta all the way up to President Mark Shapiro. Don't look for that to happen. The Dolans don't operate that way.
What is clear is that the present plan, whatever that might be, is not working. Something needs to change.
This week in baseball
Baseball is a game of threes. Three strikes and you're out and three outs in each half of an inning. Here are two more sets of threes to consider from last week in baseball. All stats are through Friday.
Three up
1. Miguel Cabrera because the third Tiger to drive in 100 or more runs for five straight seasons on Tuesday. Overall, he has nine straight 100-RBI seasons.
2. Arizona's Jason Kubel has 53 RBI since June 5, second only to Miguel Cabrera.
3. Philadelphia's Cole Hamels has thrown two shutouts in his last two starts and hasn't allowed a run in 22 straight innings (14 hits, one walk and 15 strikeouts).
Three down
1. In the first five innings of the Indians' 14-1 loss to Boston on Aug. 12, Red Sox hitters batted .481 (13-for-27).
2. Dodgers reliever Brandon League, acquired from Seattle last month, has allowed six runs on nine hits in five innings (12.80 ERA) since the trade.
3. The Rays, including Wednesday's perfecto by Seattle's Felix Hernandez, have had a perfect game thrown against them three times in the last four seasons.
Tribe talk
"I'm a work in progress," Ubaldo Jimenez, after giving up eight runs in four innings Tuesday in a 9-6 loss to the Angels.
Stat-o-matic
Four in one: Toronto's Steve Delabar became the first pitcher in history Monday to strike out four batters in one inning during extra innings. He struck out four White Sox in the 10th inning after Tyler Flowers struck out, but reached first when the pitch bounced away from catcher Jeff Mathis.
Front man: Josh Hamilton has driven in Elvis Andrus 31 times this year for the Rangers, accounting for 31 percent of Hamilton's 101 RBI.
Big pop: Chicago's A.J. Pierzynski leads all catchers with a career-high 23 homers. Hall of Famer Carlton Fisk holds the club record with 37 in 1985.