Hey Hoynsie! Paul Hoynes answers your Indians questions.
Hey, Hoynsie:
How in the world are the Reds drafting and developing players based in a small market? Where are the Indians cutting corners in the process? -- Marcus Gross, ColumbusHey, Marcus: Draft or no draft, big-league baseball is about winning games and making the postseason. In the last 18 years, the Indians have had nine winning seasons and been to the postseason seven times. That includes two trips to the World Series.
Over the same period, the Reds have been to the postseason twice and had four winning seasons.
So who is cutting corners?
Hey, Hoynsie:
If Lonnie Chisenhall continues to struggle at third (three errors in six games at Columbus), shouldn't the Indians have him play some left field, since we are lacking outfielders with pop? Martin Prado of the Braves has played left and third and it did not hurt him. In a couple of years, we may have Francisco Lindor at short and Asdrubal Cabrera at third, so why not have Chisenhall play some left in addition to third? -- Joe Eversole, Pelham, Ala.Hey, Joe: Not a bad thought, but if Chisenhall keeps hitting like he's doing in Columbus, I think the Indians would be willing to live with his errors at third base.
Hey, Hoynsie: The Indians obviously have a need for an impact bat, preferably in the outfield. If they are open and willing to use the trade market, as they said they are, wouldn't Chris Perez be the most likely trading chip? They traded away their top pitching prospects for Ubaldo Jimenez, and short of Lonnie Chisenhall (who doesn't make sense in a deal for offense anyway), they don't have any big-league ready young players to offer. They have depth in the bullpen and Perez would probably stir up the market. If they don't use Perez in a deal, I'm not sure the Indians would have enough to offer in exchange for a bat that would even matter. -- Leslie Marchak, Sagamore Hills
Hey, Leslie: As I'm sure you've noticed, a lot of teams are struggling with their closers in the first couple of weeks of the season. I know the Indians need a hitter, but I'd really have to think hard before trading Perez.
Hey, Hoynsie: I'm hoping for some clarification. Jose Lopez hit the pole and was awarded a home run. Everybody has always called it a "foul pole." If you hit a foul pole, that means the ball should be foul, right? Shouldn't it therefore be called a fair pole to correspond with the way the ball is judged? -- Bob Carpenter, Glen Allen, Va.
Hey, Bob: You're asking a question that has baffled people for ages. There have been books written about it. The foul pole is an extension of the foul lines. If a ball hits one of those lines, it's fair. If the ball hits the foul pole, it's fair. That's as far as I dare venture into this tangled web.
Hey, Hoynsie: Didn't the Dolans say they were going to put together a team that would be competitive for five years? Maybe the fans have a different definition when it comes to the word "competing." -- Harry Drennan, Strongsville
Hey, Harry: Don't remember the Dolans saying that. Do remember them indicating that they'd put together a team that would be competitive every three to five years.
Big difference, right?
Hey, Hoynsie: I'm assuming you at least have a moderate interest in the other pro teams in this town. Given that, where would you rank the Indians' ownership/management in relation to the others? -- Frank Mazzella, Parma
Hey, Frank: I'd rank the Indians first, the Cavs second and the Browns third. The Indians are at a distinct disadvantage because MLB does not have a salary cap, while the NBA and NFL do. But I give them high points on stability and ingenuity.
Hey, Hoynsie: I'm a little concerned about how long it is going to take to rebuild the team into a consistent winner with apparently no one particularly good in the farm system. How much longer do you think it will take? -- Scott Mercer, Cleveland
Hey, Scott: Talk about a straight line. Haven't you heard? The rebuilding is over. This team is a contender right now.
How long is it going to take to rebuild the Indians? It depends how old you are. If you're pushing 70, I'd say start watching another team. If you're a freshman in high school, you've got a chance to see it happen.
-- Hoynsie