The White Sox have Fausto Carmona's number ... and it's 20.25.
That was just ugly.The White Sox were teeing off on Fausto Carmona as if Kevin "Crash Davis" Costner were the catcher and telling 'em what pitch was coming.
Carmona is a decent enough pitcher, and we're not quite ready to toss him aside yet. But he's been wildly inconsistent, not just this year but throughout his career. It's kind of like he has Good Carmona on one shoulder and Bad Carmona on the other, and you never know which one's gonna toe the rubber.
Every pitcher has a player who seems to have his number. For Carmona, it seems like that player is anyone who wears a Chicago uniform. This year, he's sporting a 4.76 ERA. How big a factor do you think the 20.25 ERA he has against the White Sox is? In only eight innings total pitched against the Pale Hose, Carmona has allowed 18 hits and 18 earned runs in just two starts.
Unfortunately, he's not much better against the other team favored to contend for the AL Central in preseason polls: Minnesota. Carmona has a 10.80 ERA vs. the Twins.
You can use statistics to prove or disprove anything, no matter how nonsensical: 100 percent of the people whose biological parents didn't have children will themselves not have children, etc.
But to return to the subject at hand, the stats definitely are not in Carmona's favor anytime he has to face the White Sox. They just eat him alive. So, now we ask: Do you shuffle your rotation so that Justin Masterson (1.20 ERA vs. Chicago) or Josh Tomlin (who hasn't faced the White Sox yet, but has a 5-1 record with a 2.76 ERA against the league) is on the hill the next time Ozzie Guillen's team squares off against the Indians?
A few thoughts on that: First, Carmona is the Indians No. 1 pitcher because of his talent, and that talent SHOULD get him over the White Sox hurdle. Rejiggering the rotation to avoid them isn't really feasible, nor could it possibly benefit his psyche, and could have just the opposite effect. On the other hand, this the Major Leagues. You can't spot ANY team except maybe the Pittsburgh Pirates with a six-run lead in two innings or less.
Man, this is the toughest job in sportswriting (heavy sigh) ... Buuuuuut ... maybe the organization should be looking to make a change.
Around the horn
* -- Richard Bauer of the Cleveland arm of SBNation.com notes that this weekend's first round of interleague play, including the Indians-Reds battles at Progressive Field, features some pretty good matchups that could be a nice harbinger of which teams have the postseason in their future.
* -- Justin Masterson isn't what you'd call a fashion plate ... unless you're into tube socks and shorts. But the Indians pitcher has been a pretty nice surprise on the mound, if not the runway, this season, says Anthony Castrovince of mlb.com.
* -- The injury bug is attacking the Indians, and there's not a can of insect repellent in sight, says Paul Rados on yahoo.com.
* -- Sheldon Ocker of the Akron Beacon-Journal takes on the Tribe's injury situation.
* -- Oh, joy. The two-game sweep of the Indians has the White Sox feeling better about themselves, the Chicago Sun-Times reports.
From The Plain Dealer
Beat writer Paul Hoynes, in his game story about the Indians' loss to Chicago, also noted Fausto Carmona's high ERA against the White Sox. But he went a little further.
Carmona (3-4) allowed eight runs on seven hits in five innings. He walked two and struck out three. Carmona, in two starts against Chicago this season, has allowed 18 earned runs on 18 hits in eight innings. He has a 20.25 ERA against the White Sox and a 2.56 ERA (16 earned runs in 561/3 innings) against everyone else.Hoynsie's Indians Insider column covers the injury to Travis Hafner, which Pronk says could be an oblique.