Cleveland believes it's a good baseball town with cash-strapped owners. It's half right, sports columnist Bud Shaw writes in his Spin column.
Chuck Crow / The Plain DealerIndians fans have made their unhappiness with the team's recent struggles apparent with their absence from games. But Bud Shaw wonders why that same strategy isn't employed against the Browns, who have been far more futile over the last decade. CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Baseball and complaints about ownership are in the air again...
Cleveland thinks of itself as a good baseball town plagued by cash-strapped owners. The truth is it's a cash-strapped football town.
With spring training signifying open season on how the Dolans do business, not much can change the public perception except winning.
The Indians probably need to get to the World Series to change the sentiment in a town with a cast-iron stomach for annual displays of ineptitude if it's dressed up in brown and orange; and with no tolerance for poor performance and modest spending in a sport without a salary cap.
The Indians, after all, have been a lot better than the Browns a lot more recently. When they won 93 games in 2005, the Indians' attendance bumped 11 percent from the previous year. In 2006, it grew by a couple fans a game. You'd think more people than that would've wandered in by mistake.
When they won 97 games in 2007, attendance spiked 19 percent. It quickly declined the next season. Could that many fans have held a grudge against Joel Skinner for his stop sign? By 2009, attendance was down 19 percent.
This is not to suggest the Indians haven't earned some apathy. Or to blame fans for what they do with their discretionary income in a bad economy (but as far as that goes, this isn't the Roaring '90s that Dick Jacobs enjoyed. And if you know anything about Dick Jacobs, you know he made it a point to never outspend his revenues).
I'm not a season ticket holder. I don't pay my way into the ballpark or stadium. I didn't invest financially and emotionally in CC Sabathia or Cliff Lee only to see them traded away. It's just to say it's never been as simple as the we-got-cheap-owners rant used to blame ownership for many factors that are out of its control (Travis Hafner, Jake Westbrook, Kerry Wood). And other factors that owners in the NFL and NBA don't face.
You can blame the Indians for not getting more out of the Sabathia and Lee deals, especially if the payoff isn't apparent by season's end. You can find fault for dealing Lee earlier than necessary. They did it to maximize the value of the deal after all, so, again, have at it where applicable.
But railing against those trades for going down at all ignores what's happening most everywhere else in baseball.
Chuck Crow / The Plain DealerWhether or not Indians fans are front-runners -- and Bud Shaw has a pretty obvious opinion on that -- the Indians will have a early season opening to win back some fans thanks to the collapse of the Cavaliers. • Milwaukee couldn't keep Sabathia either. Now he's likely to opt out of the deal he signed with the Yankees in search of even bigger riches.
• Philadelphia traded Lee to Seattle, which traded him to Texas. The Phils got him on the rebound for the discounted price of $24 million a season.
• In St. Louis, a great baseball town, Albert Pujols and the Cardinals can't reach an agreement. Pujols supposedly wants a 10-year deal at approximately $30 million. He's 31. St. Louis won the World Series in 2006. The Cardinals were eighth in attendance in 2010.
If St. Louis can't keep Pujols, that's a bad sign. But hardly a first bad sign around baseball.
No matter, the Indians must win to get fans to come back. Fair enough. Attendance valleys can happen in a good baseball town.
But last in the league in attendance three seasons after a Game 7 loss in the ALCS? Sorry, that's not a good baseball town. That's a football town with a double standard.
That said, the Indians have a chance in April and May to turn sentiment their way, what with the only other distraction in town the roaring ambulance siren at The Q.
They need to make the most of it.
Math problem: If a ESPN motor home leaves San Antonio at 50 miles an hour headed for the Final Four in Houston, how soon before somebody points the DVD remote at Dick Vitale and presses "mute"...
The NCAA is once again changing geographical names for NCAA Basketball Tournament regional locations. New Orleans will be the "Southeast" and San Antonio the "Southwest" as opposed to "South" and "Midwest" designations.
OK, fine. But that's not going to help the 94 percent of American college kids who still can't find Egypt on the map but believe the Pyramids are somewhere outside a casino in Vegas.
SPINOFFS
Grady Sizemore spent eight hours a day rehabbing his knee in a Passive Motion Machine after undergoing microfracture surgery. I believe that's also another name for the Princeton offense...
Quarterback Nate Montana, son of Hall of Famer Joe Montana, announced he will leave Notre Dame. You'd like the poor kid's chances of escaping the pressure of carrying the family name if not for his transfer school: the University of Montana...
As negotiations continue between the NFL and irate fans displaced at the Super Bowl in Dallas, a victimized Pittsburgh couple estimates spending $8,000-$10,000 to attend the Super Bowl. Who knew bib overalls and two Iron City beer drinking helmets could cost that much ...
AP photoOhio State's sparkplug guard, even as a freshman. HE SAID IT
"We break down at times." -- Mo Williams on the Cavs' defense.
Or Edsel owners, circa 1957.
HE SAID IT
(In the Third Person)
"If you look at Trump's record, he is only interested in things he can control." -- Donald Trump, on why the man he most admires would only become a partner in the New York Mets franchise if he could call the shots.
SEPARATED AT BIRTH
Aaron Craft and Grady Sizemore. -- Jack E.
PD photoWithout this outfielder, the Tribe has been missing its spark.
Johnny Knoxville and Aaron Boone. -- Thom, Bay Village
YOU SAID IT
"Bud:
"Do you ever get negative comments about Cleveland sports?" -- Joe S.
Yes. But I've only been here 20 years.
"Bud:
"Since one of the primary knocks on Shaun Rogers was his 'questionable work ethic,' do you think there's any chance the Browns released him when they did so he could [catch on] with the Cavs?" -- Jeff Bing, Westlake
Dunno. Do the Cavs need a Spinning instructor?
"Bud:
"Now that we've had time to reflect, how will Danny Ferry be remembered? For being the stud we traded Ron Harper for or the GM who mustered-up Antawn Jamison and Mo Williams as the second and third players to support LeBron after seven years of trying?" -- Jim, Shaker Heights
Did Larry Hughes pay you to leave his name out?
"Bud:
"With Jayson Nix, Jason Donald and Jason Kipnis all competing for spots in the Indians' infield, will the 2011 season resemble the movie 'Major League' or the movie 'Friday The 13th?'" -- Kevin Prendergast
First-time "You Said It" winners receive a T-shirt from the Mental Floss collection.
"Bud:
"Isn't it sad that the closest thing we have to a pro basketball team is OSU? The same goes for a pro football team. How's OSU's baseball team looking this year?" -- Doug, Westlake
Repeat winners need to make better use of their time.