Clemson's Deshaun Watson has the gaudier numbers and the CFP experience. Ohio State's J.T. Barrett has a past to live up to.
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Ohio State's J.T. Barrett is barely a blip on the radar of Clemson's Jadar Johnson. But what's a College Football Playoff involving the Buckeyes without a perceived deficit at the most important position on the field?
"We've definitely faced better quarterbacks than him," said Johnson of Barrett. "I feel like if we can limit him on the ground, with his running, we'll be pretty good. His strong point is just his legs."
Clemson clearly wants to limit Barrett's runs and make him a passer.
Before the College Football Playoff semifinal kicks off on New Year's Eve Night, Clemson's Deshaun Watson, whose team was national runner-up last season, deserves the praise he has gotten. My Heisman Trophy ballot had him first. He finished second to Louisville quarterback Lamar Jackson.
For Barrett, who shared the Big Ten Most Valuable Player award this season, it comes down to revivifying an idealized past.
It's not 2014 anymore
Fans approach Barrett the way jilted lovers approach an ex. They wonder why Barrett has changed, why Barrett did not play in 2015 the way he played before breaking his ankle against Michigan in 2014.
Because he had to rehab it extensively and was not up to game speed for much of the season.
Then why did he not return to those thrilling days this year as the unchallenged starter at quarterback?
Because the offensive line isn't as good. The only game-breaking receiver is H-back Curtis Samuel. And Zeke Elliott is playing with the Dallas Cowboys.
An unknown knocked off the best
In 2014, Glenville's Cardale Jones -- almost a complete unknown as a former third-stringer, promoted to back-up by Braxton Miller's injury and to starter by Barrett's -- strong-armed Ohio State past Wisconsin, Alabama and Oregon to the national championship.
Said Ohio State coach Urban Meyer, "In any run, there are players who aren't well known who become well known."
Or, in the case of Jones, who become a cult figure.
The phenom is the stock in trade of the 24/7 cable television news cycle. If it's new, it'll do.
Barrett was outshone by the blinding light of Jones' playoff success, which was never quite as dependent on his arm as it was on his receivers' acrobatics.
Two elite lists
The leaders of the 2014 postseason opponents were, respectively, the Heisman runner-up, Melvin Gordon; third-place Heisman finisher, Amari Cooper; and Heisman winner, Marcus Mariota.
Michigan's Jabrill Peppers finished fifth in the Heisman voting this season after the Wolverines were eliminated from the College Football Playoff by Ohio State's comeback double-overtime victory.
Watson finished behind Louisville quarterback Lamar Jackson for the Heisman
Ever-present CFP entrant Alabama doesn't have anyone of Cooper's 2014 star power, but prevailing opinion is that the Crimson Tide could handle an All-Star team made up of the best from Ohio State, Clemson and CFP newcomer Washington.
But in no rational universe is the disparity in quarterback play as great now as it was in 2014.
Praise for Watson
Still, OSU defensive coordinator Greg Schiano said:
"Watson's as talented a guy as we've faced. He's got incredible arm strength; he's a very mobile athlete; he doesn't choose to (run) a ton, but when he does, he's as good as there is. Flick of the wrist -- it's 40 yards and pretty darn accurate. He's thrown 65 yards in the air on tape, so I'm sure he can throw it 80 yards. He's a freakish-type football player. You watch the video, you sit there and go 'Whoa! That's a rare cat.'"
Not a jet, unless New York drafts him
Barrett is a physical runner, not a jet. He would be a lumbering ground transport, capable of getting his team where it needs to go, but without the "whoa's" and the snooty feline pedigree.
Swing hard
Barrett's conservatism, which can harden into indecisiveness, has resulted in 24 touchdown passes to five interceptions, compared to Watson's 37 to 15 ratio.
"Now, maybe you don't want 15 interceptions - but if you're not throwing interceptions, you're not trying hard enough," said Schiano. "If everything's got to be wide open, we're not going to be explosive enough on offense."
"We want a team that's not afraid to make mistakes," Meyer said.
It's a fine line between boldness (good) and brazenness (bad). Meyer, an old minor league infielder, constantly tells his team, in a baseball/boxing allusion, "Swing hard!"
Barrett will take his swings.
That's Jadar Johnson, shaking his head and saying it didn't hurt a bit.