Cleveland Indians have third base questions ... Gio Urshela? Juan Uribe? Lots of Tribe notes.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Can the Indians count on Giovanny Urshela to play third base?
With the glove, absolutely. At the bat ... well ... we don't know.
If the Tribe had power hitters in the outfield, then they could go with a younger version of a smooth-fielding Jack Hannahan at third base. But fans know about Michael Brantley being out at least for the first month of the season because of shoulder surgery. It could be longer.
The projected opening day outfield is Lonnie Chisenhall (RF), Abraham Almonte (CF) and Rajai Davis (LF). Those three combined for 20 homers last season. The Indians are looking to platoon at some position in the outfield. Tyler Naquin could make the team, but he's not a power hitter.
That's why it would help the Tribe to have someone at third base who can drive in some runs.
ABOUT THE DEFENSE
On June 9, the Tribe promoted Urshela from the minors. Five days later, Francisco Lindor came up from Columbus. The goal was to stabilize the left side of the infield.
A story by Ben Lindbergh in Grantland (now defunct) discussed how the Indians went from "the worst-fielding team in modern history" in early May to one of the best in the majors by the end of the season.
Four big moves happened:
- Lindor replaced Jose Ramirez at shortstop.
- Urshela replaced Chisenhall at third base.
- Chisenhall took over in right field for Brandon Moss and others.
- Almonte replaced Michael Bourn in center.
Fangraphs.com rated the Tribe as the second-best defensive team in the American League. The World Series champion Kansas City Royals were first.
That's why the Indians are hoping Urshela can hit enough to hold down third base.
WHAT HAPPENED IN 2015?
It's very hard to judge Urshela's performance last season. He was leading the Venezuelan winter league with a .398 batting average (43-of-108) when he injured his knee. He didn't have surgery, but the injured knee required time to recover. He played only five spring training games in 2015.
Urshela opened at Class AAA Columbus, but hurt his back. He missed three weeks.
The Indians probably should have kept Urshela longer in the minors, but the Cleveland situation was such a mess. The pitchers were justifiably discouraged by the problems with the defense. Manager Terry Francona believed the Lindor/Urshela promotions would help the team, even if they struggled to hit.
It took 100 at-bats, but Lindor began to find his swing. By the end of the season, he was a .313 hitter (.835 OPS) with 12 HR, 51 RBI in 99 games.
What about Urshela?
- He was a .253 hitter at the All-Star break. That was in 103 plate appearances.
- After the All-Star break, he batted .208 in 183 plate appearances.
- He batted only .207 vs. righties, compared to .275 vs. lefties.
- The final totals were .225 (.608 OPS) with 6 HR and 21 RBI.
Until 2015, Urshela had been healthy since signing with the Indians in 2009. Then came the knee, the back and he had a shoulder issue late in the 2015 season.
In 2014, Urshela batted a combined .280 (.865 OPS) with 18 HR and 84 RBI between Class AA and Class AAA. So there is a reason to believe he can be respectable at the plate.
Urshela is only 24, so there is reason for optimism.
IS HE READY?
The Indians intend to contend for a playoff spot in 2016. One of the questions hanging over the team is Urshela. Can they count on him now?
They don't know. On the roster right now, the other third base option is Jose Ramirez. His best position is second base. He is considered the team's utility infielder for 2016.
Ramirez batted only .219 (.631 OPS) with 6 HR and 27 RBI last season. He was awful in the spring and sent back to the minors. He eventually returned and batted .259 after the All-Star break.
Urshela is better defensively at third, and it's doubtful Ramirez would supply a lot of offense.
The Indians are excited about Yandy Diaz, who played third and hit .315 with 7 HR and 55 RBI for Class AA Akron last season. But he's not ready to open the 2016 season in Cleveland.
The 24-year-old Diaz is fascinating, a Cuban defector who has played only two years of pro ball in the U.S. He could be a prospect who moves up quickly.
ABOUT JUAN URIBE
The questions hanging over Urshela is why the Juan Uribe rumors keep popping up. He'll be 37 on March 22. He's a very wide body, 245 pounds on a 6-foot frame.
Uribe batted .253 (.737 OPS) with 14 HR and 43 RBI with three teams last season. He had nine errors in 92 games at third. In 2014, he was a .311 hitter (.773 OPS) with 9 HR and 54 RBI for the Dodgers.
If the Indians do sign Uribe, he will join veterans Mike Napoli and Rajai Davis as right-handed hitters who are more effective against lefties than right-handed pitching.
ABOUT WALT WILLIAMS
My column about former Indian Walt Williams drew several meaningful emails. I wrote about how my friend Frank Sarmir and I became buddies with Williams in 1973. He was a Tribe outfielder, we were high school seniors.
FRANK SARMIR wrote: "In retrospect, our friendship with him and his invitation to hang out in the Detroit hotel room seem unbelievable. But at the time it seemed totally natural to me and seemed totally natural for him, as an African-American man, to spend time with some white teenage fans. This story is emblematic about how professional sports have changed in our lifetime ... an era never to be recreated."
PAT MCAULAY wrote: "Your story about Williams reminded me of a game in 1973 in which Walt broke up a no hitter against Stan Bahnsen of the White Sox with 2 outs in the ninth inning and the Indians trailing. He slapped a ground ball past Bill Melton (who later played for the Indians) who had come off of back surgery the previous year and couldn't even put a dive on the ball as it went by him."
PHIL BARTH wrote: "I was in the sixth grade and the Indians had a basketball team that would tour and play local teams during the winter. They came to our high school and played the local legends (and of course the Indians crushed our local legends). ... Walt Williams stood on the floor and signed autographs and talked with people. He talked with me for a while. I know I got other autographs that night, but Walt just seemed like he really enjoyed signing and talking to the fans."
MELINDA HANKINS wrote: "My family had season tickets from 1968-77. Walt was one of the players we got to know. He was everything you said. A wonderful person who was taken from us much too soon. He may not have had the advantages or talents that some players have, but compared to those he stood ten feet tall."