Two late drives proved too much to overcome for Tim McGee's Cincinnati Bengals and Pierre Woods' New England Patriots in past Super Bowls.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Tim McGee and Pierre Woods are two of many Northeast Ohio natives who have participated in a Super Bowl.
Unfortunately, Woods and McGee had disappointing outcomes in their big game. And each player shared the same experience of watching their Super Bowl dreams fade while standing helplessly on the sideline.
The Carolina Panthers and the Denver Broncos will play in Sunday's Super Bowl 50 at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, Calif. Memories of past games, especially for the players, resurface each year during Super Bowl week.
Game: Super Bowl XLII, 2008
Teams: New York Giants 17, New England Patriots 14
Background: Woods, out of Glenville High School, was in his second season as a linebacker with the Patriots in 2007.
That season the Patriots were a victory away from matching the 1972 Miami Dolphins, the only undefeated NFL champion. The Patriots had defeated the Giants earlier in the year, and the Patriots were heavily favored to win the Super Bowl.
"When we beat the Giants during the regular season, Michael Strahan comes up to me after the game and says, 'Hey youngster, I'll see you in the Super Bowl.'"
Strahan reminded Woods about his prognostication several weeks later at the Super Bowl media day.
"I see him and he says, 'I told you youngster' and he was smiling with that big gap in his teeth. It was an eerie feeling because you didn't want to believe him when he said it weeks before."
View from the sideline: The Pats led 14-10 with 2:39 left. The Giants began a drive inside their own 20. The Giants converted the first key play on fourth-and-1 at the 38 for a first down. The Patriots could have ended the game with an interception but the pass was dropped.
And then came the play.
"That was a heck of pass rush," Woods said. "Someone had (Eli) Manning's jersey and since the refs previously blew the whistle when someone grabbed him, [our rush] let up."
That was costly. Manning went into Fran Tarkenton mode to avoid the rush and heave a pass caught by David Tyree. It was a spectacular catch initially pinned on Tyree's helmet with one hand. Seconds later, Manning threw the winning 25-yard TD pass.
"Tyree made a heck of a catch from God," Woods said. "He was even amazed that he caught it. ... When I say a hell of catch, I mean one hell of catch."
Game: Super Bowl XXIII, 1989
Teams: San Francisco 49ers 20, Cincinnati Bengals 16
Background: Issues for the Bengals began a day before kickoff when fullback Stanley Wilson was caught using cocaine in his hotel room.
The Bengals left him off the roster and Wilson, with his third drug violation, was banned from the league for life. It was a brutal blow because Wilson added toughness to the offense.
"That was just the start of it," said McGee, a John Hay grad and the Bengals starting wide receiver back then. "There was a riot on the west side of our hotel, Stanley Wilson and the drugs, we changed hotels the night before the game and our bus was late getting us to the stadium. And [All-Pro nose guard] Tim Krumrie broke his leg early in the game. And despite it all, it all came down to one play."
View from the sideline: The 49ers trailed by three with 3:20 left. Montana began the drive at his own 8.
"It was the most nerve-racking game I've ever been involved with," McGee said.
The great Montana began the drive with two completions in the middle of the field. The 49ers continued to move the ball. Montana regrouped from a 10-yard penalty and moved the 49ers to the 18. With 39 seconds left, Montana finished the drive with a 10-yard touchdown pass to John Taylor for the winning score.
The Bengals could have ended the game during the same drive when cornerback Lewis Billups allowed a potential interception to slip through his fingers in the end zone.
The winning drive aided Montana's legacy.
"It was the greatest example of the thrill of victory and the agony of defeat," McGee said. "The Super Bowl was the most exciting event I've ever been in and the most disappointing event I've been in."