"If you would have told me at the start of the year some of the things that transpired would have happened, I'm not sure I would've been optimistic that we would've won 75 games, let alone 85 games."
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- There are varying perspectives any insider or outsider can apply when reflecting upon the Indians' season.
In short, an 85-win campaign was not enough to extend the club's season into October. Especially on the heels of a 92-win year that included a three-hour playoff cameo, falling short of the postseason served as a disappointment for the players, coaches and front-office executives.
"We're [no longer] playing, so we're all a little bit disappointed," General Manager Chris Antonetti said Monday at an exit interview with reporters at Progressive Field.
Here is a smattering of what Antonetti and manager Terry Francona had to say, one day after the completion of their season.
For four months, the Indians' rotation was unsettled: Nick Swisher, the club's highest-paid player, battled knee ailments and an ineffective bat. Once the starting pitching rounded into form late in the summer, the team's lumber went dormant. Carlos Santana, Yan Gomes, Jason Kipnis and David Murphy all suffered injuries at various points in the season. The club fielded the worst defense in the league.
And yet, Francona somehow guided the team to 85 wins.
Antonetti: "When you're able to step back and take a broader view, it was an incredible year, in terms of progress. If you would have told me at the start of the year some of the things that transpired would have happened, I'm not sure I would've been optimistic that we would've won 75 games, let alone 85 games."
That said, those setbacks prevented the club from qualifying for the postseason. Historic performances by Michael Brantley and Corey Kluber were not rewarded with a ticket to October baseball.
Kipnis followed up an All-Star season with one mired in inconsistency. He missed May with a strained oblique. Francona said he rushed back from the injury, though he refused to blame the second baseman's struggles solely on that. Kipnis batted .240 with six home runs and a .640 OPS in 129 games.
He did not record an RBI over the final month of the season, a span of 89 plate appearances in which he hit .183 with a .491 OPS.
Francona: "It reinforced that not winning and playing the game to his standards bothered him a lot."
Antonetti: "We expect him to be a cornerstone guy for us next year, so rather than spending a lot of time dissecting what happened, our focus is: How do we help him take advantage of the off-season, come into spring training ready to go and look at 2015 rather than dwell on '14?"
Kluber is in contention for the American League Cy Young Award, after posting an 18-9 record, 2.44 ERA and 269 strikeouts.
Antonetti: "It was an incredible year. He was, in our view, the best pitcher in the American League this year. His consistency and consistent dominance was a big part of the reason we were able to win as many games as we did. It's not an accident why that happened. It's because of the work that he's put in."
Brantley became the first player in franchise history to register 200 hits, 40 doubles, 20 home runs and 20 stolen bases in a single season. He finished the year with a .327/.385/.506 slash line, 20 homers, 97 RBIs, 23 steals and 94 runs scored.
Antonetti: "He's a complete player and we think [he's] deserving of MVP consideration with the year he had. He was a huge part of our success and we think [he's] one of the best players in the American League.
The Indians scored three runs or fewer in half of their games. They went 25-56 in such affairs.
Francona: "When your pitching gives you a chance -- even the last couple of months, as hard as runs seemed to be for us to score, we seemed to pretty much have a chance every night. ... It's not just the Indians; it's league-wide right now. Teams are trying to figure out the adjustments that need to be made, because the power is down, but the strikeouts aren't. So how you move forward is going to be really interesting."
The Indians committed 116 errors, five more than any other team in baseball. They finished last in fielding percentage and second-last in FanGraphs' defensive rating system.
Antonetti: "We've spent a lot of time talking about it. ... The encouraging thing is it was much better in the second half than it was in the first half."
Quick hits
• The Indians have no plans to change their coaching staff, though they anticipate some of their guys may get interviews elsewhere.
• The club has yet to choose whether it will pick up Mike Aviles' $3.5 million option for 2015. It comes with a $250,000 buyout. The Indians have until three days after the conclusion of the World Series to decide.
• Will the Indians engage in discussions with Kluber on a long-term contract extension? They won't tip their hand. Antonetti said it's a conversation for later in the winter.
"He's a guy we value incredibly high and we're thankful that he's going to be here for a while. That's a good starting point for us."