The Indians are 177-147 in two seasons under manager Terry Francona.
CLEVELAND, Ohio – In 40 years of following the Indians, I never had watched every inning of every game until this one.
The project was thoroughly enjoyable but exhausting – and all I did was observe and take notes. The project gave me a new level of appreciation for any major leaguer, and especially those who play almost every day. I gained a new level of appreciation for the beat writers; the project was grueling -- and I didn't even travel. Props to such luminaries as Paul Hoynes of NEOMG, Jim Ingraham of The News-Herald and recently retired Sheldon Ocker of The Akron Beacon Journal, writers who have covered the Tribe year after year for decades.
I relied heavily on SportsTime Ohio telecasts primarily because I needed to watch replays -- and more replays -- in order to chart pitches and dissect at-bats. I did not want to depend on anybody for my material, but I certainly listened to STO play-by-play voice Matt Underwood, analyst Rick Manning, reporter Katie Witham, studio host Al Pawlowski and studio analysts Jason Stanford and Jensen Lewis. All pros.
Periodically, I piped in WTAM/AM 1100's broadcast in the background so I could hear legendary play-by-play voice Tom Hamilton and his sidekick, Jim Rosenhaus.
I subscribe to WTAM Indians reporter/host Nick Camino's belief that each game should be viewed in a vacuum, as 1/162nd of a season. Even though the MLB season unfolds over months and months, I don't like the long view because I think each game has plots and subplots that deserve to stand on their own merits.
I strove to be as objective as possible in chronicling a team that finished 85-77, third place in the AL Central. When the Indians won, I presented a "positive" picture. When they didn't, I didn't. When it came time to critique, I went to great lengths not to take perceived cheap shots. A Tribe player with whom I spoke early in the season said he was reading the reports, didn't always like what I was writing, but respected that I was fair. He said that, if I did go below the belt, he would let me know. He never voiced that concern.
Here is a capsule look at what I observed from the Indians in 2014:
Co-MVPs: LF Michael Brantley and RHP Corey Kluber
The Indians featured not one, but two players who performed at a star level. It is too bad fans -- and the baseball nation -- didn't get to see them in the postseason.
Brantley
- Nickname: Dr. Smooth.
- First-time All-Star.
- 7.0 Wins Above Replacement (WAR).
- Batted .327 (200-for-611) with 20 homers, 45 doubles, 97 RBI, 94 runs and 23 steals in 156 games.
- Only player in MLB with .300 average, 20+ HR, 40+ 2B, 90+ RBI, 90+ R and 20+ SB.
- Third in MLB in batting average.
- 18th player in franchise history with 200 hits, the first since Kenny Lofton had 210 in 1996.
- One of two players in MLB with 200 hits (Jose Altuve, Houston, 225).
- Only player in franchise history with 200+ hits, 20+ homers, 40+ doubles and 20+ steals. The 11th player in MLB history with that line.
- Ninth player in franchise history with 20+ homers and 20+ steals -- the first since Shin-Soo Choo (2009-10).
- Two extra-inning walkoff homers (May 19 vs. Detroit, Aug. 3 vs. Texas).
- 59 multi-hit games.
Kluber
- Nickname: Klubot.
- 7.3 WAR, second in MLB among pitchers (Clayton Kershaw, L.A. Dodgers, 7.5).
- Went 18-9 with 2.44 ERA in 34 starts. Gave up 207 hits in 235 2/3 innings, walked 51 and struck out 269.
- 18 victories are most by an Indian since Cliff Lee went 22-3 in his Cy Young season of 2008.
- 269 strikeouts ranked second in MLB (David Price, Tampa Bay/Detroit, 271) and sixth in franchise history.
- 26 Quality Starts (6 or more IP, 3 or fewer ER).
- MLB-best 10 starts of seven or more innings, two or fewer earned runs and 10 strikeouts.
- 11 double-digit strikeout games, most by an Indian since Herb Score's 11 in 1956.
- 21 starts of at least eight strikeouts, tied for third in franchise history (Bob Feller, 21, 1946).
- Went 4-0 with a 2.09 ERA and 60 strikeouts in May.
- Went 5-0 with 1.12 ERA (40 1/3 IP, 5 ER) in final five starts.
- Posted back-to-back starts of nine innings in which he faced one batter over the minimum (July 24 @ Kansas City; July 30 vs. Seattle).
Best stat: Kluber and Brantley are the first 250K/200H duo in franchise history, the first in the majors since lefty Randy Johnson (364K) and Luis Gonzalez (206H) with the Arizona Diamondbacks in 1999.
Biggest accomplishment, team: The Indians and manager Terry Francona finished with a winning record for the second consecutive season. The franchise hadn't posted back-to-back winning records since 2000-01.
Biggest accomplishment, individual: Kluber emerged as a Cy Young candidate and Brantley authored one of the best all-around offensive seasons in the majors.
Biggest disappointment, team: The Indians failed to make the playoffs and finished with a worse record than year's 92-70 club that played in a wildcard game.
Biggest disappointment, individual: The collective lack of production from the $48.26 million men.
The Indians' four highest-paid players for 2014, according to Cot's Baseball
Contracts via baseballprospectus.com, were: 1B-DH Nick Swisher ($15 million), CF Michael Bourn ($13.5 million), SS Asdrubal Cabrera ($10 million) and RHP Justin Masterson ($9.76 million).
Those four accounted for 57 percent of the franchise's Opening Day payroll of $84.4 million (also according to Cot's). The Indians received pennies on the dollar
for their investments.
- Swisher batted .208 with eight homers, 42 RBI and 111 strikeouts in 97 games. He had an OPS of .608. He was shut down in mid-August because of knees that required surgery.
- Bourn batted .257 with a .314 on-base percentage and 114 strikeouts in 106 games. He scored 57 runs and stole 10 bases. His surgically repaired left hamstring flared up again this season and forced him to miss games.
- Cabrera batted .246 with nine homers and 40 RBI and underwhelmed defensively in 97 games for Cleveland. The Indians traded him to the Washington Nationals at the end of July.
- Masterson, who began the season as the No. 1 starter, went 4-6 with a 5.51 ERA in 19 starts for Cleveland. He gave up 106 hits and walked 56 in 98 innings. The Indians traded him to the St. Louis Cardinals in late July; he was even worse as a starter for the Cardinals.
Game of the year: May 24 vs. Tigers at Progressive Field.
Final: Indians 11, Tigers 10 (13 innings).
The Indians trailed, 4-0, after one-half inning and 4-1 after 1 ½. They scored five
runs on six hits in the second against reigning AL Cy Young Max Scherzer.
The score was tied, 7-7, until the eighth, when Detroit pushed across two runs
against John Axford.
With one out in the ninth, Michael Brantley singled and stole second against Tigers
closer Joe Nathan. David Murphy homered to right-center to make it 9-9.
Detroit took a 10-9 lead in the 13th on Alex Avila's two-out homer off Josh
Tomlin.
The Indians scored once and loaded the bases with two outs in their half. With Ryan Raburn at bat in a 1-0 count, Tigers reliever Al Alburquerque balked -- a
walkoff balk.
The game required 475 pitches and lasted 5 hours, 16 minutes.
Most shocking swing of the year: Nick Swisher vs. LA Angels, June 19 at Progressive Field.
After the Angels took a two-run lead in the top of the 10th inning, the
Indians loaded the bases with two outs. Swisher, who had been 0-for-4 with
three strikeouts, stepped in against righty Ernesto Frieri. Swisher smacked a
1-2 pitch over the right-field wall for a grand slam to give the Tribe a 5-3
victory.
Best late show: June 4-5 vs. Red Sox at Progressive Field.
Final: Indians 7, Red Sox 4 (12 innings).
The scheduled start of the 7:05 p.m. game was delayed by rain for 2 hours, 28
minutes. The score was tied, 4-4, after nine innings. With runners on first and third and one out in the bottom of the 12th, Asdrubal Cabrera homered off former Indian Edward Mujica. Cabrera ended the game at 2:02 a.m.
The Indians completed a three-game sweep of the defending World Series champion. They went 6-0 on a homestand that included Colorado.
Play of the year: July 1 at L.A. Dodgers.
The Dodgers entered the bottom of the fourth inning trailing by three. Dodgers
pitcher Josh Beckett led off with a double against Justin Masterson. Beckett
advanced to third on Dee Gordon's bunt single and scored on Yasiel Puig's
single, the latter moving Gordon to third. With lefty Adrian Gonzalez due up,
lefty Kyle Crockett relieved Masterson.
Gonzalez flied to left fielder Michael Brantley, who fired a strike to catcher Yan Gomes to erase the speedy Gordon. As Gomes looked down, Puig took off for second. Gomes spotted Puig and threw on-target to second baseman Jason Kipnis, who was convinced the Indians had just pulled off a 7-2-4 triple play. However, second-base umpire Paul Nauert called Puig safe.
The Indians challenged Nauert's call; it was overturned. The Dodgers challenged
plate umpire Adrian Johnson's call on Gordon; it was upheld. The Indians had, in fact, turned a 7-2-4 triple play.
The Tribe won, 10-3.
Game of the year, position player: Lonnie Chisenhall, June 9 at Texas.
Chisenhall went 5-for-5 with three homers and nine RBI in a 17-7 victory over the Rangers. He became the first MLB player with those numbers since at least 1920, when RBI became a statistic. Three others have posted five hits, three homers and nine RBI.
Chisenhall hit an RBI single off Nick Martinez in the first; a two-run homer off Martinez in the second; a two-run homer off Scott Baker in the fourth; an RBI double off Baker in the sixth; and a three-run homer off Baker in the eighth.
Chisenhall raised his average to .385 and his slugging percentage to .615. The bat was shipped to the National Baseball Hall of Fame.
Game of the year, pitcher: Corey Kluber, July 30 vs. Seattle at Progressive Field.
Kluber allowed three hits and struck out eight in an 85-pitch complete game as the Tribe won, 2-0. He out-dueled Felix Hernandez (7 IP, 4 H, 2 R).
Kluber became the first Indian to craft a shutout with fewer than 90 pitches since
Charles Nagy on June 12, 1992.
Kluber threw 69 strikes (81 percent) and faced one over the minimum. The game wrapped in 2 hours, 10 minutes.
Seattle's Kyle Seager singled with one out in the second. He was erased by Logan
Morrison's double-play grounder. Robinson Cano singled with two outs in the second and advanced to second on right fielder David Murphy's error. Kendrys Morales, in what turned out to be Seattle's lone AB with a runner in scoring position, grounded out. Morrison singled with one out in the fifth and was erased by Mike Zunino's double-play grounder.
The Mariners went 1-2-3 on eight pitches in the ninth.
Biggest mystery: What type of player is second baseman Jason Kipnis?
Is Kipnis the player who, in his first full season in 2012, batted .257 with a .714 OPS, 14 homers and 76 RBI in 152 games?
Or is he the player who last year batted .284 with an .818 OPS, 17 homers and 84 RBI in 149 games and made the All-Star Team?
Or is he the player who this year batted .240 with a .640 OPS, six homers and 41 RBI in 129 games?
Kipnis's WARs in those respective seasons: 3.7, 5.9, 0.9.
An oblique injury sidelined Kipnis for most of May, and some observers wondered if the lingering effects sapped him of his power. At the very least, he appeared to be playing through discomfort.
Kipnis owns a high baseball IQ and plays hard. He wants to win badly. He doesn't make excuses. But the intangibles don't mean much when the numbers aren't where they need to be.
Most startling start: Josh Tomlin, June 28 at Seattle.
Tomlin threw a one-hitter and struck out 11 as the Indians won, 5-0. He threw 77 of 111 pitches for strikes. His Bill James Game Score was 96.
Seattle's Kyle Seager led off the fifth with a single. With two outs, Seager advanced to second on Tomlin's wild pitch and to third on catcher Yan Gomes' throwing error. Michael Sauders, in what turned out to be Seattle's lone AB with runners in scoring position, struck out looking.
In Tomlin's previous start, June 22 against Detroit, he gave up eight runs
(five earned) on eight hits in four innings. In Tomlin's first start after the one-hitter, July 4 against Kansas City, he allowed five runs on 10 hits in 5 2/3 innings.
Best full-service performance: Yan Gomes, twice – July 30 vs. Seattle and Sept. 17 at Houston.
On July 30, Gomes caught Kluber's 85-pitch complete game and hit a two-run double in the fifth off Felix Hernandez as the Tribe won, 2-0.
On Sept. 17, Gomes caught Carlos Carrasco's two-hitter and went 2-for-4 with two
RBI as the Tribe won, 2-0.
Biggest waste of jet fuel: Trip in late April.
On the night of April 24, the Indians flew to California for a three-game series
against the San Francisco Giants that began April 25. They lost 5-1, 5-3 and
4-1.
The Indians traveled to Anaheim for a three-game series against the Angels. They
lost 6-3, 6-4 and 7-1.
Then they flew home.
Most impressive career turnaround: Carlos Carrasco.
Carrasco began the season, his sixth as an Indian, in the rotation. He struggled in four starts and was demoted to the bullpen. It did not appear that the talent in his
right arm ever would translate as a starter, at least in Cleveland.
Carrasco pitched well in the bullpen -- which happened last season, as well.
On Aug. 10, Tribe manager Terry Francona inserted him back into the rotation for a start against the Yankees in the Boogie Down. Carrasco gave up two hits in five
shutout innings of a 4-1 victory. The performance served as a springboard to a
fantastic run. In his final nine starts, Carrasco, working exclusively out of the stretch, allowed one or zero earned runs seven times. Part of the dominance was a two-hit shutout Sept. 17 in Houston, with both of the hits infield singles.
In a span of two months, Carrasco went from a career in question to the Indians' No. 2 starter.
Biggest embarrassment: Offensive defense.
The defense – or lack thereof – was historically bad. Nothing makes a team look worse than failure to make routine plays, and the Indians excelled at it, most ingloriously on the infield and at catcher.
The issues extended beyond the high error total (116) to a boatload of plays not made: The list included double plays that turned into nothing more than forceouts and grounders that eluded range-challenged fielders for singles. Opposing runners routinely took an extra base on the Tribe's below-average arms in center and right field. Yes, the Indians played better defense later in the season, but by then, a lot of the damage had been done. A strong case can be made that the Indians failed to make the playoffs simply because of their leaky defense.
Most under-the-radar contributor: T.J. House.
Lefty House began the season in the minors. He made his major-league debut May 17 against Oakland, working a hitless inning in relief. His next 18 appearances
for Cleveland were starts. He went 5-3 with a 3.35 ERA in 102 innings overall. House does not possess dazzling stuff, but he does compete, stay calm in tight spots and give his team a chance to win. He knows his limitations and understands how to pitch. House's solid rookie season has put him at least in the discussion for the fifth-starter spot next year. An organization never can have enough pitching, and House is young (he turned 25 on Monday) and throws left-handed.
Best series, team: May 19-21 vs. Detroit at Progressive Field.
The Indians won the opener, 5-4, in 10 innings on Michael Brantley's homer off Al Alburquerque. Corey Kluber gave up three runs in seven innings. Cody Allen allowed a homer to J.D. Martinez in the ninth to make it 4-4.
The Indians won the second game, 6-2. They built a 5-1 lead off Justin Verlander through two innings. Trevor Bauer allowed two runs in six innings.
The Indians completed the sweep with an 11-10 victory in 13 innings. The winning run scored on Alburquerque's bases-loaded balk. Tribe bats knocked around reigning AL Cy Young Max Scherzer for 12 hits and seven runs in seven innings.
Best series, individual: Carlos Santana at Kansas City, July 24-27.
Santana combined to go 9-for-14 with five homers, one double, eight RBI, six runs and five walks. Unfortunately for him and the Indians, the Royals went 3-1 in the series.
Loudest finishes: Seven walkoff homers, by six players.
Here is the list:
- May 19 vs. Detroit (W, 5-4, in 10 innings): Michael Brantley, solo.
- June 1 vs. Colorado (W, 6-4): Michael Bourn, two-run.
- June 4 vs. Boston (W, 7-4, in 12 innings): Asdrubal Cabrera, three-run.
- June 19 vs. LA Angels (W, 5-3, in 10 innings): Nick Swisher, grand slam.
- Aug. 3 vs. Texas (W, 4-3, in 12 innings): Michael Brantley, solo.
- Aug. 13 vs. Arizona (W, 3-2): Zach Walters, solo.
- Aug. 15 vs. Baltimore (W, 2-1, in 11 innings): Mike Aviles, solo.