Plain Dealer Cavaliers beat writer Tom Reed tackles questions from readers in regard to the Cavs and the NBA.
Wilfredo Lee, Associated PressShaquille O'Neal, left, was nearly impossible to stop if he decided to back a defender like Zydrunas Ilgauskas toward the hoop. One reader has a rather radical idea to slow this down.
Q: Hey, Tom: Derek Fisher is trying to sell the players on the notion that the owners group is badly divided, and if the players just hold on, the big-market owners will drive the NBA to make a deal to the players' liking. David Stern is saying that the owners are firmly behind a hard cap and the difference lies in minor wrinkles of the application. Where do you see the truth in this actually being? I've read that even [Lakers owner Jerry] Buss is backing a hard cap. -- J Smith, Rocky River
A: Hey, J: Any time you have a group of 30 owners representing such disparate markets, you are going to have some differences. There's no way ownership of the Los Angeles Lakers and Milwaukee Bucks look at the situation exactly the same. I think the owners are generally united, but that could change once regular-season games are missed.
Q: Hey, Tom: With the holdout being the only thing going on in the NBA right now, I thought I'd try to offer a refreshing change of subject.
Basketball is a beautiful sport because it possesses several very difficult athletic skills -- dribbling, shooting, passing, jumping, running, diving, defending, rebounding. Unfortunately, there's also one important asset that I see as boring, and not much of a skill at all. I would like to offer a simple rule change that would eliminate having to watch a guy slowly back his way toward the hoop.
My idea is simply to make it a traveling violation to progress backward toward the hoop if you are being checked. Basically, you would no longer be allowed to "plow" a defender toward the hoop. Let's force teams that want to get the ball closer to the hoop to do so with skillful passing and dribbling. Not by just dumping the ball into the guy who is bigger than his defender. There's so much pushing and shoving going on in a sport that was initially designed to be a no-contact sport, I think it would be OK to take away a little of it. Let's force the big fella to do something that requires some real coordination (like going around the defender, shooting over him, or performing a little give-and-go). I ask you: Which is more exciting to watch? If you say, "plowing" I think you're just being resistant to change.
I've done a lot of officiating. As things are, it's so difficult for the ref. He can't call charging, because the guy is going so slow. But he almost has to call a foul, because there's so much contact going on. It was painful watching poor Andy Varejao try to stop [Dwight] Howard in the post a few years ago. If Andy pushed hard enough to stop him, a foul was called. If he didn't, Howard just kept backing in until he could jump up and slam it. That's not the way the game was designed to be played. -- Dave Slavick, Eastlake
A: Hey, Dave: One of the interesting facets of the 2004-05 NHL lockout is the game emerged not only with a new financial structure, but stricter rules interpretations curbing restraining fouls. There is always going to be contact in basketball. The traveling violation idea seems a tad radical, but perhaps referees could call more offensive fouls on guys backing in on defenders.
Q: Hey, Tom: If there is no NBA season this year, will the Cavs get the first and sixth picks in the 2012 draft? -- Michael Barnauskas, Columbus
A: Hey, Michael: Ah, the million-dollar question. The NBA hasn't made a decision. The NHL established a lottery for the Sidney Crosby sweepstakes in 2005. Teams were assigned one to three pingpong balls based on their playoff appearances and first overall draft picks from the previous three years. Perhaps, NBA Commissioner David Stern will borrow from his old pal and NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman.
Q: Hey, Tom: Do you think there is a chance the Cavs could trade Antawn Jamison and his massive expiring contract before the season begins? It seems like the Cavs could get a decent return if they are once again willing to absorb a big contract. -- Brian Falb, Dublin, Ohio.
A: Hey, Brian: One idea reportedly gaining traction in the labor talks is an "amnesty" clause allowing teams to release a player by paying him, but not having the total count against the salary cap. If the Cavs theoretically went this route, Antawn Jamison or Baron Davis could be candidates.
Q: Hey, Tom: The Cavs roster is overstocked with players. Who will most likely need to go? Who will make up the top 10? -- Rick Shoemaker, New Carlisle, Ohio
A: Hey, Rick: It's my first week, and I'm already ducking a question. It's so hard to predict what will happen once the game returns and free agency commences. Assuming everyone is still on the roster and healthy, here is a projected top 10 in no order: Baron Davis, Anderson Varejao, Antawn Jamison, Kyrie Irving, Tristan Thomson, Omri Casspi, Daniel Gibson, Christian Eyenga, Ramon Sessions, Ryan Hollins. Don't forget Anthony Parker is a free agent, but the feeling is the Cavs would like to re-sign him.
Q: Hey, Tom: How well do you think Kyrie Irving will do if there is a season, and will he go above expectations? -- Dave Martin, Tampa, Fla.
A: Hey, Dave: I think Irving will have a solid season. He's healthy, and he has a proven guard in Baron Davis, who should help him, and a coach in Byron Scott who has a track record of developing guards.
Q: Hey, Tom: Wouldn't it be best for the Cavs if we just skip the whole season so we will be in line to get high draft choices one more time next year? I don't really like the NBA outside of the Cavs, and I have no interest at all in the good of the league . . . rather, I just care about the Cavs and their fan base. -- Mark Rhodes, Chapel Hill, N.C.
A: Hey, Mark: Maybe I'm in the minority here, but I think it's important that Kyrie Irving (19) and Tristan Thompson (20) play basketball this season. Remember, Irving played just 11 games last season. Plus, we're not sure what the draft format is if the season is canceled.
Q: Hey, Tom: Has any progress been made on getting a name for the Cavs' D-league team? Inquiring minds would like to know! -- Chuck Slone, Louisville, Ky.
A: Hey, Chuck: Not that I'm aware. They are close to naming a coach, however.
Q: Hey, Tom: If the season is interrupted, what happens with the usual midseason trade deadline? Will it be abolished for this season? -- Victor Hill, Indianapolis
A: Hey, Victor: Hard to tell. It would depend on how many games were lost to the lockout.
Q: Hey, Tom: What is the health status of Antawn Jamison, Semih Erden and Anderson Varejao? -- Patrick Greenlee, Fairfax, Va.
A: Hey, Patrick: Agents for Erden and Varejao say their clients will be ready for the season. Have not heard any updates on Jamison.
Q: Hey, Tom: If this season is ever played, how do you see the Cavs creating roster space for their two new rookies? -- J Smith, Rocky River
A: Hey, J: When a franchise has the first- and fourth-overall picks, they will make room. It will be interesting to see how Byron Scott uses Baron Davis and Kyrie Irving.
Q: Hey, Tom: It seems that not many people really notice or care that the NBA is locked out. It definitely does not get the coverage the NFL lockout did. Is the sentiment the same in Cleveland because the Browns are 1-1 and the Indians, although out of contention, are still playing? -- Dave Zsembik, Orlando, Fla.
A: Hey, Dave: I don't think the apathy is confined to Cleveland. Part of it is the predictability factor. The public was told the season wouldn't start on time, and it's looking like that will be the case. Part of it is football remains America's game. No league is even a close second (sorry, baseball lovers). And part of it is there's a strong belief the league requires fundamental change. The NBA is rivaling the English Premier League in predictability. There are only four or five teams with a legitimate shot at winning before the season even starts. Since 1980, there have been nine NBA champions compared with 18 in Major League Baseball.
-- Tom