The Cleveland Indians moved to 3-0 against the Cincinnati Reds this season after a stirring 8-7 victory in 12 innings on Wednesday night at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Rajai Davis hit a two-run homer in the ninth inning and Francisco Lindor homered in the 12th as the Cleveland Indians defeated the Cincinnati Reds, 8-7, Wednesday night at Great American Ball Park in Cincinnati. Davis and the Reds' Jay Bruce homered twice.
Here is a capsule look at the key aspect(s) of the game, which was televised by Fox Sports Time Ohio:
Tito's Fun Bunch: Manager Terry Francona's Indians (20-17 overall, 9-9 on road) have won three straight -- the first three of a four-game season series against the Reds.
On Monday and Tuesday in Cleveland, the Indians held a combined 28-7 advantage in runs.
Reeling: The Reds (15-25 overall, 12-11 at home) have dropped six of seven.
Streak busted: The Indians had lost their first three extra-inning games this season. They were walked-off by homers in the previous two (Philadelphia, Houston).
They prefer to see red: Davis and Lindor have feasted on Cincinnati pitching for three nights.
Davis has gone 2-for-4 with two walks, an RBI and two runs; 3-for-3 with one double, two walks, three RBI and four runs; and 2-for-5 with the two homers, one walk, three RBI, three runs and one steal.
In four games before facing Cincinnati, Davis was a combined 0-for-18.
Lindor has gone 3-for-5 with one double, two RBI and two runs; 3-for-6 with two doubles; and 3-for-6 with the homer, two RBI and one run.
Legalized theft at GABP: On Wednesday, the Tribe entered the ninth trailing, 7-5. Reds lefty Tony Cingrani replaced righty reliever Ross Ohlendorf, who had struck out two in a perfect eighth.
Carlos Santana, pinch-hitting for pitcher Jeff Manship, grounded to short. Then came a plate appearance that must not be overlooked when reviewing this game.
Lefty Lonnie Chisenhall, against a lefty with a funky delivery, fell behind, 1-2. In other words: He was supposed to be in jail.
Chisenhall fouled twice, took two balls and fouled twice more. Cingrani threw a close pitch near the inside edge, and Chisenhall spit on it. Umpire Tim Timmons agreed with Chisenhall.
Davis bunted foul and swung for a foul, meaning he was down, 0-2. After a ball, Cingrani threw a hanging breaking pitch that Davis drove into the left-field seats to tie the score.
From the ninth through the 11th, Tribe relievers Bryan Shaw and Cody Allen combined to retire 9-of-9, four by strikeout. They made it possible for Lindor to bring his thunder.
Leading off the 12th against righty Keyvius Sampson, Lindor lined a full-count fastball over the wall in center.
No question that Cincinnati's bullpen is terrible, but pointing to it as the sole cause of the Tribe's comeback victory short-changes the clutch (power) hitting of Davis and Lindor.
Don't forget about me: Tribe second baseman Jason Kipnis went 1-for-5 with one double, one walk and one run, and he made two enormous defensive plays.
With Reds on first and second and two outs in the seventh, former Indian Brandon Phillips stepped in against Joba Chamberlain. Phillips tried to shoot an 0-1 pitch to right, but Kipnis gloved the liner while moving to his left. Kipnis appeared to have begun moving before Phillips swung; if so, it made the play that much more impressive. Kipnis prevented the Reds from padding their 6-5 lead.
With none on and one out in the Cincinnati 12th, Zack Cozart sent a bloop near the right-field line. Kipnis covered ground in a hurry and made a tumbling catch. If Kipnis had come up empty, Cozart might have had a double.
The play took on added significance when the next batter against Dan Otero, Billy Hamilton, slapped a single to left. Joey Votto walked. Phillips, in an 0-2 count, flied to right fielder Chisenhall.
Phillips has tormented his former employer for years, and he was 1-for-3 with a walk in each of the first two meetings this week. Wednesday, though, was not his night. He went 0-for-6 with one strikeout as the Reds' cleanup batter.
Mirror images: Each team finished 10-for-46 with two doubles, three homers, seven RBI and 14 strikeouts. The Indians walked four times; the Reds, three.
Not so fast: Indians right-hander Mike Clevinger, in his major-league debut, allowed four runs on five hits in 5 1/3 innings. He walked one and struck out five.
Clevinger gave up one run on two hits through five and carried a 4-1 lead into the sixth. The opportunity for a victory unraveled in a hurry.
Here is a pitch-by-pitch breakdown of his start:
First inning
Zack Cozart -- 94 fastball, single to left.
Skinny: Cozart ambushed Clevinger with good piece of hitting. He pulled in hands against pitch on inner third.
(L) Billy Hamilton -- 94 fastball called strike; 94 fastball outside; 88 changeup swinging strike; 93 fastball foul; 89 changeup foul; 73 breaking pitch outside; 95 fastball, grounder/fielder's choice 4-6.
(L) Joey Votto -- 95 fastball outside; 95 fastball up and in (barely); 94 fastball called strike; 88 changeup foul; 81 breaking pitch, swinging strikeout (Hamilton steals).
Brandon Phillips -- 95 fastball called strike (outside corner at knees); 75 breaking pitch, grounder to short (Hamilton was on the move).
Skinny: Pitch on outer half at knees had B-Phil off-balance.
Second inning
(L) Jay Bruce -- 94 fastball called strike (knees); 93 fastball foul; 87 changeup outside; 74 breaking pitch outside; 93 fastball outside; 94 fastball outside, walk.
Skinny: Clevinger tried to be too fine after getting ahead, 0-2.
Eugenio Suarez -- 93 fastball foul; 80 breaking pitch called strike; 80 breaking pitch, swinging strikeout.
Skinny: Excellent sequence capped by pitch down and just outside.
Tyler Holt -- 94 fastball called strike; 74 breaking pitch called strike; 94 fastball, fly to right.
(L) Tucker Barnhart -- 94 fastball low; 88 changeup foul; 94 fastball low; 93 fastball, fly to left.
Skinny: Clevinger 31 pitches through two innings.
Third inning
(L) Brandon Finnegan -- 91 fastball outside; 92 fastball called strike; 93 fastball ball (should have been a strike); 92 fastball foul; 94 fastball foul; 93 fastball foul; 75 breaking pitch foul; 94 fastball outside; 92 fastball foul; 94 fastball, swinging strikeout.
Zack Cozart -- 81 breaking pitch called strike (outside edge); 93 fastball foul; 78 breaking pitch, fly to center.
Skinny: Cozart off-balance.
(L) Billy Hamilton -- 88 changeup swinging strike; 74 breaking pitch called strike; 94 fastball outside (barely); 86 changeup outside; 86 changeup outside; 93 fastball foul; 92 fastball, pop to center.
Skinny: Clevinger 51 pitches through three.
Fourth inning
(L) Joey Votto -- 85 changeup outside; 93 fastball called strike; 92 fastball inside (barely); 93 fastball foul (pitch to hit); 87 changeup outside; 86 changeup, swinging strikeout.
Skinny: Votto fooled into half-swing.
Brandon Phillips -- 81 breaking pitch down and away; 93 fastball outside barely; 92 outside (barely); 92 fastball called strike; 93 fastball foul; 80 breaking pitch, grounder to short.
Skinny: Outer third and down took sting out of bat.
(L) Jay Bruce -- 87 changeup, homer to right.
Skinny: Hanging changeup. Marlon Byrd narrowly missed leaping catch as ball snuck over wall.
Eugenio Suarez -- 94 fastball swinging strike; 93 fastball inside; 81 breaking pitch swinging strike; 81 breaking pitch foul; 93 fastball, grounder to third.
Fifth inning
Tyler Holt -- 91 fastball low; 92 fastball swinging strike; 93 fastball foul; 80 breaking pitch, pop to center.
(L) Tucker Barnhart -- 87 changeup swinging strike; 74 curve high; 92 fastball called strike; 87 changeup low and away; 87 changeup, grounder to pitcher.
Skinny: Clevinger fielded backhanded with back to plate.
(L) Brandon Finnegan -- 92 fastball, grounder to second.
Skinny: Clevinger 79 pitches through five.
Sixth inning
Zack Cozart -- 92 fastball called strike; 80 breaking pitch swinging strike; 79 breaking pitch foul; 92 fastball, single to left.
Skinny: Catcher Yan Gomes was set up away; pitch tailed over middle. Bad pitch, especially in 0-2 count.
(L) Billy Hamilton -- 92 fastball, bunt single to third.
Skinny: Juan Uribe almost made the play. Throw hit Hamilton in back.
(L) Joey Votto -- 92 fastball inside; 92 fastball called strike; 93 fastball, two-run double to center.
Skinny: Gomes was set up inside; pitched tailed over inner half. Why Gomes and Clevinger would not opt for a 1-1 changeup is head-scratching.
Brandon Phillips -- 80 breaking pitch foul; 92 fastball foul; 80 breaking pitch foul; 87 changeup, swinging strikeout.
Skinny: Good changeup in dirt.
(LEfty Kyle Crockett relieves.)
Not good: Crockett gave up a bloop single to Bruce. Zach McAllister replaced Crockett and allowed a three-run homer to Suarez (2-0 fastball down/to right field) that put Cincinnati in front, 6-4.
The Tribe pulled within 6-5 in the seventh. Bruce homered off Manship in the eighth.