The Browns may change personnel in the off-season, but an improving defense should be given time to mature.
Second-year tackle Phil Taylor (tracking down Dallas QB Tony Romo) is part of Tom Heckert's construction of a stout 4-3 defense. Will the Browns' new regime maintain the philosophy regardless of off-season moves?
John Kuntz, The Plain Dealer
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Still waiting for snow, but there's no waiting for these thoughts, as we're talkin' ...
About the Browns ...
1. No doubt some changes are coming next season. But they must keep the 4-3 defense. General Manager Tom Heckert has piled up linemen, and the Browns use as many as eight in some games. Heckert put emphasis on the line, making defensive tackle Phil Taylor his top pick in 2011, wanting to pair him with Ahtyba Rubin.
2. The Browns believe the key to their 4-3 is depth on the line, a strong middle linebacker such as D'Qwell Jackson and excellent cover cornerbacks. Next season, they want to add another defensive end who can rush the passer, and at least one more cornerback capable of starting. Of course, all of this is based on the 4-3 remaining. It also would be wise to keep defensive coordinator Dick Jauron.
3. Remember the Browns played mostly a 3-4 under Romeo Crennel and Eric Mangini. Mangini had no use for the 4-3, he was a 3-4 coach who valued linebackers. So if the Browns switched to a 3-4 next season, they'd have to revise much of their defensive roster -- again. The accent would be on linebackers, not linemen.
4. At some point, someone in charge in Berea has to scream ... Stop! It's not just changing general managers and coaches every few years that causes problems, it's changing systems. One of the keys to the success of division rivals Pittsburgh and Baltimore is they play the same 3-4 defenses. Head coaches change, but that doesn't. In Pittsburgh, Dick LeBeau was going to remain as defensive coordinator no matter who replaced Bill Cowher. Ask Mike Tomlin if continuity works, as the Steelers consistently remain a top-rated defense.
5. In the AFC North, a winning team needs to be physical and deep on defense. The victories over Pittsburgh and Cincinnati show the Browns making serious steps in that direction. When Joe Haden is in the lineup and covering the opponent's best receivers, the defense is strong. They are 4-3 when Haden plays this season.
6. While the key guys are the cornerbacks, linemen and Jackson in the middle, the Browns are excited by the development of rookie LBs James-Michael Johnson (JMJ) and Craig Robertson. JMJ is already starting. Robertson plays in passing situations and may start next season. In his last two years with the Browns, veteran Scott Fujita battled injuries and his speed suffered. The young linebackers bring needed quickness, and the Browns believe JMJ and Robertson can start for several years.
7. In the 20-17 victory at Oakland, the Browns used seven defensive linemen who were on the field for at least 25 of 75 snaps. The breakdown: Jabaal Sheard (68), Rubin (49), Billy Winn (48), Frostee Rucker (39), Juqua Parker (38), Taylor (33), John Hughes (25). Sheard, Taylor, Winn and Hughes were all Heckert's draft picks. Parker (34) and Rucker (29) are the only linemen older than 26.
8. If the Browns hire a general manager and/or coach who wants to switch to the 3-4 defense, it will be a setback for a defense that is young and talented.
About Mike Holmgren ...
I received a letter from Dr. Robert Campbell, senior minister of Cleveland's Church of the Covenant. It's where the former Browns president attended. Campbell believes many in the media didn't understand the challenges faced by Holmgren. I also have been critical of Holmgren. In an effort to be fair, here are some of Campbell's points:
1. "Mike is one of the most impressive persons I have had the privilege to meet in my 45 years of ministry. ... Every home game, it amazed me to see him in worship when members of churches skip church to make a game."
2. "Mike makes winners, even when not that many games have been won. All one needs to do is look at the character of today's Browns players as opposed to the character of the (past teams) when well-paid athletes often behaved as entitled children."
3. "He was hired by an absentee owner to put some credibility and stability into a failing organization. Overlooked was that in his first year, the majority of his time was spent rebuilding infrastructure. In our time of immediate gratification an often missed ingredient is the need for a solid foundation, not only in personnel."
4. "Holmgren was criticized for not getting rid of Mangini. It was the fair thing to do, especially given all the other fronts that needed to be addressed. When time came for a replacement, I know that while Coach Holmgren clearly pondered taking the job. ... but his greater concern was how to run a profitable team that would be a credit to the city and at the same time build a winning organization ... when it came to contract issues, there was not the freedom that an owner would have, yet he was expected to perform in place of an owner."
5. "In many ways, it was an impossible job well done by a very gifted person. ... Cleveland is a much better place for having been blessed with his presence."
About Peyton Hillis ...
The Browns are fortunate, says Terry Pluto, that Peyton Hillis turned down their contract extension offer before the start of the 2011 season.
John Kuntz, PD file
1. Lost in Joe Thomas calling Hillis' 2011 season "toxic" because the running back was obsessed with his contract and the running back calling Thomas "a crazy ex-girlfriend," is that the Browns offered Hillis a deal before the 2011 season. Fans can be glad he turned it down.
2. I believe it was a four-year deal worth about $16 million with at least $8 million guaranteed. Hillis thought he was worth far more after his 2010 season where he made the cover the Madden and rushed for 1,177 yards. The Browns were worried about his durability, especially his hamstrings.
3. An Associated Press story from 2008: "Rookie Peyton Hillis, who had energized the offense during the past month, went on injured reserve when medical tests showed he had a torn right hamstring behind the knee and might need surgery. He faces a two-month recovery." That was when Hillis was in Denver. He didn't need surgery. But he also had hamstring problems in college and with the Browns last season.
4. Fans know Hillis was a mess in 2011. He had three agents. The Browns decided he wasn't worth the trouble early in the season, and decided to allow him to walk. Hillis ended up signing a one-year, $3 million deal with Kansas City that wasn't fully guaranteed. He comes to town with 193 yards on 53 carries (a 3.3 average). He missed three games with a high ankle sprain. He's viewed in the NFL as a backup.
5. In losing Hillis, the Browns targeted Trent Richardson, who has 827 yards this season. He needs only 351 yards in the final four games to pass the Hillis total from 2011. As offensive coordinator Brad Childress said: "He also is our leading receiver [44 catches], so he's been productive in the passing game. I've seen him [block] people in the blitz. He has carried the ball 20 times a game, I'd say he's a workhorse."
About the Cavaliers ...
Donald Sloan is playing hard for the Cavaliers, but the amount of playing time he is receiving reflects the roster's many current issues, says Terry Pluto.
Joshua Gunter, The Plain Dealer
1. With Kyrie Irving and Dion Waiters injured, about all fans can do is see if Anderson Varejao can grab 15 or 20 rebounds in a game. None of this is to diminish Varejao's season for the ages. He's a "15-15 guy," as in 15 points and 15 rebounds nearly every night. I'd add in another 15 -- as in 15 buckets of sweat that he produces each game. At least he's something to watch. But after that, it's not easy to follow this team at the moment.
2. A few people have been asking me why Byron Scott doesn't receive more heat for the Cavs' poor performance. When the coach has to pick between Donald Sloan and Jeremy Pargo as a starter -- or even ponder playing them together -- it sends a very clear message: The losing is not the fault of the coach. Two veterans imported by the front office -- C.J. Miles and Omri Casspi -- haven't delivered. The talent is thin.
3. The Cavs won't say it, but they sent this team on another lottery-bound journey at the start of the season. When the roster is so young and no significant veterans are added, you are telling your coach, "Play the young guys, help them improve, and we'll get you more help next summer."
4. The problem is Waiters (sprained ankle) and Irving (broken finger) are not playing together, and it may be a few more weeks before that happens. Veteran Daniel Gibson (shooting only 39 percent) often is battling bruises. His cranky elbow has hurt his usually sweet shooting touch.
5. At 15.4 points, No. 4 pick Waiters ranks third among rookies in scoring. His dismal 36 percent shooting takes some of the glitter off the scoring average. No. 3 pick Bradley Beal is scoring 10.9 points, shooting 35 percent for Washington. Damian Lillard (19.3 points) and Anthony Davis (16.1 points, 8.3 rebounds) are the only rookies making a major impact.
6. Some fans wanted Harrison Barnes over Waiters. I watched Barnes twice on TV recently, and he looks OK for Golden State. He's averaging 9.8 points, shooting 45 percent from the field, 32 percent on 3-pointers. He does start.
7. Most players now enter the league so young, they just aren't ready to play at the level of even an average NBA player. It's impossible to guess right now who will be the best player in two years from a group of Waiters, Barnes, Lillard, Beal, etc.
8. Tyler Zeller is averaging only 4.9 rebounds -- he's battled a concussion and broken nose and plays wearing a mask. But that humble rebound average ranks fifth among rookies. I really think Zeller will be the young Cavalier (from the group of Waiters, Irving and Tristan Thompson) who makes the biggest improvement in the second half of this season.
About the Tribe ...
Can Carlos Carrasco provide some steady production to the Tribe's pitching rotation in his return from Tommy John surgery?
Chuck Crow, The Plain Dealer
1. The $44 million, four-year offer to Shane Victorino was real, just as was Victorino's decision to take $39 million from Boston. The Red Sox lost 93 games like the Tribe last season, but Victorino obviously believes Boston has a far better chance to climb back into contention.
2. Most players don't want to come to Cleveland, unless they are outrageously overpaid. The Tribe does have some cash to spend and has a decent chance to sign Kevin Youkilis, and perhaps an outside shot at outfielder Nick Swisher. But even if they add one of those players, their biggest problem remains -- starting pitching.
3. Tribe starters had a 48-76 record and a 5.25 ERA last season -- worst in the American League. Perhaps new manager Terry Francona and pitching coach Mickey Callaway can do something with Ubaldo Jimenez (9-17, 5.40). It wouldn't be a surprise if Justin Masterson (11-15, 4.93) improves. Francona really likes and believes in Masterson from their time in Boston. But the rest of the rotation is what? Zach McAllister (6-8, 4.24), Corey Kluber (2-5, 5.14 and having knee surgery but supposed to be OK by spring training), Carlos Carrasco (coming off elbow surgery) and maybe Jeanmar Gomez (5-8, 5.96) or David Huff (3-1, 3.38)?
4. That's why they are expected to trade Asdrubal Cabrera. There is very little free starting pitching available, and the price is ridiculously high. Tribe fans know the weaknesses of Cabrera -- gains weight, loses range as short. But he does have some power and trade value to bring in pitching.
5. The Indians were a bit surprised that Hector Rondon was picked by the Cubs in the Rule 5 draft. He has to be on the major-league roster on opening day, or offered back to the Tribe for $25,000. Rondon was once a top prospect, but has had two arm surgeries. He is throwing well, but it's hard to know if he's ready for big-league duty.
6. The Indians feared they'd lose Jesus Aguilar -- 15 homers with 71 RBI, batting .283 between Class A and Class AA. He was picked for the 2012 Futures Game, and is a first baseman with some power. But he's clearly not ready for the majors, which is why the Tribe kept him off the 40-man roster.
7. In the Arizona Fall League, Chris McGuiness hit .370. That's part of the reason the Tribe took the left-handed hitting first baseman from Texas in the Rule 5 draft. He still seems unlikely to make the big-league roster, as he hit .268 (.814 OPS) with 23 homers and 77 RBI in Class AA. But they are adding as many bats as possible.
8. That's also why they claimed Mike McDade on waivers from Toronto. The Blue Jays have Adam Lind and David Cooper at first base, so they took the 23-year-old switch-hitter off the 40-man roster. McDade batted .285 with 17 homers and 85 RBI between Class AA and Class AAA last season. He has minor-league options left, so he could be the starter at Class AAA Columbus this season. The Indians consider McGuiness more big-league ready than McDade, but McGuiness could end up back with Texas unless he makes the opening-day roster.