Adam Scott has no shot. OK, maybe that's a little harsh. Let's say the dashing Australian has little chance of repeating as the winner of the World Golf Championships-Bridgestone Invitational, which begins Thursday on the South Course at Firestone Country Club. Scott's heart-wrenching collapse on the final four holes of the British Open has nothing to do with it. History...
JOHN KUNTZ/PLAIN DEALERAdam Scott hits out of a bunker to the second green where he scored a birdie during the final round of the World Golf Championships-Bridgestone Invitational at Firestone Country Club in Akron on August 7, 2011.
Adam Scott has no shot.
OK, maybe that's a little harsh.
Let's say the dashing Australian has little chance of repeating as the winner of the World Golf Championships-Bridgestone Invitational, which begins Thursday on the South Course at Firestone Country Club.
Scott's heart-wrenching collapse on the final four holes of the British Open has nothing to do with it.
History does.
Winning at Firestone more than once is not an easy task. Repeat winners emerge from the South Course with a futility similar to repeat winners in golf's majors, which now stands at 16 events in a row.
Professional tournaments on the South Course began about the time Dwight Eisenhower had a putting green installed on the front lawn of the White House.
Since then:
•Only nine men have been able to win more than once on the South Course. That's nine men in 57 years of professional events.
•Only four men -- three of them Hall-of-Famers and the other a sure-fire pick -- have won more than twice. That's four men in 71 professional events since 1954. Their names are Jack Nicklaus, Tiger Woods, Gary Player and Arnold Palmer.
•Only four men have been able to win on the South Course in successive years.
The last repeat winner is Tiger Woods -- there's a stunner -- who won in 2009 after winning in 2007.
Woods also won in 2005 and 2006, joining Nicklaus (1962-63 World Series of Golf), Al Geiberger (1965 American Golf Classic and 1966 PGA Championship) and Jay Hebert (1960 PGA Championship and 1961 American Golf Classic) as the only players able to string together back-to-back wins.
Before Woods' run of three straight, the last repeat winner on the South Course was Greg Norman, who is now playing in selected Champions (nee Senior) events. Norman won the World Series of Golf in 1995 and 1997.
Woods and Nicklaus, who have won a combined 32 majors, have won seven times each on the South Course. The only others to win more than twice are icons Palmer and Player, with three wins apiece.
That leaves a cart bag full of one-time winners.
Player, who won the old World Series of Golf in 1965, 1968 and 1972, has several theories -- ranging from the depth of the field to the latest technology -- as to why it has been so difficult to win multiple times.
The nine-time major winner was one of several players who suggested the depth of the talent pool at Firestone is deeper than most, this side of Augusta.
"I think that when you look at the current state of golf, repeating in any tournament is very difficult," he said via email. "I always enjoyed Firestone and have very fond memories of the tournament and its fans. Despite it being a very enjoyable tournament, the atmosphere is a lot more competitive because of the WGC field. Many of the best players in the world are there. Anyone can win."
Former Clevelander Jason Dufner had walked the South Course many times as a youngster but never played it until he checked out about five holes on Monday. Still, as a strong student of the game and its history in Akron, he feels the South Course plays no favorites.
"The strength of the field makes it more difficult," he said. "And, I think it's a testament to the golf course. It doesn't really fit any one style. You've seen a lot of different styles win here . . . straight-ball hitters, great putters, great chippers, power-game guys."
David Toms, preparing to play in his 11th event at Firestone, agreed with Dufner that the South Course is an equal opportunity venue.
"I am not surprised by the [few] number of winners," said Toms, one of the early arrivals in Akron. "It is a good golf course when it is playing firm and fast and it suits everyone. You still have to get it in the fairway. If anything it might favor the longer hitter when it's wet because it is such a long course [7,400 yards]. I know I struggle here when it's wet. But, I don't think it favors one particular style, which is why you've had so many different winners."
The South Course does not produce what you would call one-hit wonders, either. It produces quality champions. Of the 49 men who have walked off the South with the hardware and hefty check, 29 of them went on to win -- or had already won -- at least one major and had multiple Tour wins. The same with many of the one-time winners.
"Look at the players with the most success at Firestone," said Nick Faldo, the winner of six majors and now a television analyst. "Those four players [Nicklaus, Woods, Palmer, Player] are among the best of all time, the elite. So, I really don't know if it's all that much of a surprise that there are so few repeaters."
Faldo also points to the depth of the field. Of the 78 players set to tee it up on Thursday, 49 of them are regarded as the best in the world via the Official World Golf Rankings.
"You probably have 20-25 fellows who feel they have a good chance at winning," he said. "And, it is one of the few times, outside the majors, where you have the top 50 players in the world looking at one another. It's not always that way, is it? That has to decrease everyone's odds."
Said Toms, "The more great players you have, the harder it is to win."
Stonewater pro Jimmy Hanlin has played Firestone numerous times and knows what it takes to win.
"You just can't go to the South Course and whiff it around," he said. "You just can't go there and have a good putting week and win. You can't go there and just hit it well off the tee. That's not enough to win. You need to do everything well. You are not going to win there with your 'B' game."
Player feels the calendar also might have something to do with the lack of repeaters. Sandwiched between the final two majors of the season -- the British and the PGA Championship -- Bridgestone adds another week of mental strain. Another week of preparing to play one of the toughest courses on the PGA Tour.
"I definitely think having Bridgestone taking place in the two weeks between the Open and the PGA adds to the difficulty of repeating," he said. "More pressure is placed on the players. Everyone wants to go into the final major of the year with confidence of winning the week before."
Player also feels the advancement in equipment technology has unfairly evened the playing field.
"The equipment is so forgiving," he wrote. "It is so hard to have somebody with more talent come through. For example, if you went back to hickory shafts, the players with the most talent could win more often because the variety of shots would mean more. Today, this isn't the case because of the equipment."
Everyone is playing with the same equipment. Some just use it better than others. Those are the guys whose names you'll find on the South Course winners list.