Indians have a total of 506 plate appearances this season by players batting right-handed, last in the American League by a healthy margin. Other AL teams have averaged more than 1,000 plate appearances by righty hitters so far this season.
Chuck Crow, The Plain DealerMajor league veteran infielder Jose Lopez, signed by the Indians to a minor league contract during the last off-season, has given the Tribe some of its best offense from the right side of the plate. CLEVELAND, Ohio -- The
Cleveland Indians are getting little offensive production from the right side of the batter's box.
Often in sports, such a contention is exaggerated. In this case, it's not.
The Indians' right-handed batters, counting their switch-hitters when batting righty, have a .223 batting average, with 20 doubles, no triples, seven home runs and 49 RBI in 439 at-bats.
Their on-base percentage is .312; slugging percentage, .317; OPS (combination of on-base and slugging percentages, rounded out), .628.
Consider this: Texas Rangers' slugger
Josh Hamilton (well, yes, a left-hander), in 257 fewer at bats than the Indians' team total of right-handed at bats, has 14 more homers and eight more RBI. Hamilton has 139 total bases. Indians batting right-handed have a combined 139 total bases.
Cleveland has a 4-11 record against left-handed starting pitching, but that doesn't tell the whole story. Lefty relievers dominate the Tribe, too, and the Indians see plenty of them, with their lineup usually stacked with left-handed hitters. Shortstop
Asdrubal Cabrera and catcher
Carlos Santana being switch-hitters helps somewhat, but the few pure right-handed batters who have been with the Tribe at one time or another are essentially journeyman players.
All Indians batters are hitting a combined .214 against left-handed pitching. In 599 at-bats, they've totaled 29 doubles, four triples, 10 homers and 68 RBI. The on-base percentage (.312), slugging percentage (.326) and OPS (.637) are all quite sub-par.
Cleveland, in its 50 games this season, has a total of 506 plate appearances by hitters batting right-handed, compared to 1,444 by players from the left side.
The 13 other American League teams have had an average of 1,054.6 plate appearances by righty batters this season. Thus, the Indians are averaging almost 11 fewer right-handed plate appearances a game than the other AL teams.
Some might say that, despite the imbalance, the Indians are OK, scoring 4.38 runs per game to rank eighth among the 14 AL teams. That, however, has been trending downward for most of the season. After scoring 61 runs in their first nine games, the Indians have averaged 3.85 runs a game since. They have scored three or fewer runs 21 times during that 41-game span.
Some might say injuries have been a factor in the offensive downturn. A look at the individual players' games missed, however, indicates that the Indians' injury situation, though not ideal, has not been extraordinary, especially considering the health problems of numerous other teams around the major leagues.
Santana, expected to return soon, has missed the last five games with a concussion. Cabrera recently sat out three games with a sore hamstring. He also missed six games during April following the death of his grandfather in Venezuela.
Left-handed hitting right fielder
Shin-Soo Choo missed six games, beginning in late April, with a hamstring injury. Third baseman
Jack Hannahan, another lefty batter, has missed 15 of the last 16 games with back and calf muscle problems. Hannahan was off to a solid start with the bat, but is better known for his brilliant fielding.
Designated hitter
Travis Hafner has missed the last seven games, and will be sidelined for a few weeks after having arthroscopic knee surgery. The veteran left-handed hitter averaged just 81 games played (half the schedule) the last four seasons, though, and it would have been unrealistic to think this season would be any different.
Note that none of the injuries have been to the Indians' few righty-only hitters.
Should the Indians' roster makeup remain essentially the same, they are likely to face a heavier dose of lefty pitching as the pennant races enter the stretch drive, whether they're in contention or not. Teams may tweak rotations so an extra southpaw could face the Tribe, or call up an additional lefty reliever from the minors with an Indians' series looming.
More right-handed batting production would theoretically make things easier for lefty Indians hitters, too, as opposing managers wouldn't be as liable to call on every southpaw reliever in their bullpens.
One move the Indians could consider, of course, would be to recall
Matt LaPorta from Class AAA Columbus. The 27-year-old right-hander is batting .307 for the Clippers, with 14 homers in 166 at bats.
Critics might point to how bad LaPorta can sometimes look, but he did drive in 53 runs in 352 at bats for the Indians last season, an average of one RBI per every 6.64 at bats. Indians batters, from the right side of the plate this season, are averaging one RBI per every 8.96 at bats.
Late last season, we detailed how LaPorta's major league career track
resembles that of many current right-handed batters who have emerged as consistent run producers. That doesn't assure that LaPorta would do the same, but then again, can the Indians afford to not find out?
Let's look closer at how lacking the Indians' right-handed hitting is.
There are 15 individual right-handed batters in the American League who have more homers than the combined seven for Indians batting right-handed. The most at bats for any of those players is 208, compared to Cleveland's 439 total ABs from the right side.
Here's how the Indians' right-handed batting stands in several categories, among the 14 AL teams.
Plate appearances: 506, last (13th, Seattle, 721; first, Texas, 1,531)
Batting average: .223, 12th (14th, Oakland, .204; first, Texas, .281)
On-base percentage: .312, eighth (14th, Oakland, .274; first, New York, .341)
Slugging percentage: .317, 13th (14th Oakland, .314; first, Baltimore, .450)
*OPS: .628, 12th (14th, Oakland, .588; first, Texas, .777)
*OPS: Combination of on-base and slugging percentages.
Indians as right-handed batters
Asdrubal Cabrera .333 batting average, 19 hits in 57 at bats, 4 doubles, no triples, one home run, 6 RBI, 8 walks, 3 strikeouts
Jose Lopez .256, 21-82, 6 2B, 0 3B, 2 HR, 15 RBI, 4 W, 14 SO
Carlos Santana .231, 12-52, 2 2B, 0 3B, 0 HR, 9 RBI, 13 W, 9 SO
Aaron Cunningham .211, 12-57, 2 2B, 0 3B, 0 HR, 2RBI, 7 W, 10 SO
Shelley Duncan .204, 21-103, 4 2B, 0 3B, 4 HR, 11 RBI, 17 W, 33 SO
Jason Donald .178, 8-45, 0 2B, 0 3B, 0 HR, 4 RBI, 1 W, 16 SO
Lou Marson .147, 5-34, 2 2B, 0 3B, 0 HR, 1 RBI, 6 W, 10 SO
Juan Diaz .000, 0-4, 2 SO
Luke Carlin .000, 0-5, 1 RBI, 1 SO
Note: Cabrera, Santana, Diaz and Carlin are switch-hitters.