An AFC executive provides perspective on the Browns' draft, while the Cavaliers' own chance to improve is just a few months away.
Brody Schmidt, Associated PressBrandon Weeden's arm strength figures to give the Browns' offense more credibility in the AFC, a conference team official told Terry Pluto. CLEVELAND, Ohio -- After a full weekend of heavy-duty football construction, a few impressions ...
An outsider's look at the Browns ...
I talked to a vice president from a rival AFC team, here's what he had to say about the Browns' draft:
1. "Unless all 32 teams are wrong, Trent Richardson will be a star. Him in the backfield gives our defensive coaches something to worry about. That was never really the case, not even when they had [Peyton] Hillis. At least not like Richardson. Our personnel people love his talent, toughness and work ethic."
2. "Think about playing in the AFC North. The other three teams have big, strong quarterbacks -- especially [Pittsburgh's Ben] Roethlisberger and [Baltimore's] Joe Flacco. Those guys can take some hits and throw the ball into the wind and rain. Andy Dalton [Bengals] is not quite like that, but he's pretty good. We never thought Colt [McCoy] measured up in that division. Not enough arm strength in the wind, rain, snow and cold."
3. "We had [Brandon] Weeden rated higher than [Ryan] Tannehill. Better arm, more experienced, more mature."
4. "The Browns had to take a shot with Weeden. They couldn't come back with Colt as a starter and expect a big change on offense. Weeden is more like Dalton than he is like Flacco or Roethlisberger, but he should be an upgrade over Colt. We thought Colt couldn't consistently get the ball down field, no matter who they had at receiver."
5. "The Browns should keep Colt as a backup, he'll do a good job."
6. "We didn't have [right tackle Mitchell] Schwartz [second-round pick] rated as high as the Browns. We had him in the third round."
7. "We play a 3-4 so we didn't spend much time on [defensive tackle] John Hughes. He's mostly a 4-3 guy. We do really like their tackles -- [Ahtyba Rubin and Phil Taylor]. Guess they wanted depth. [Jabaal] Sheard was a great pick last year for them in the second round."
8. "They still have a long way to go, but Richardson and Weeden have to make them better."
About Brandon Weeden and Browns quarterbacks ...
Scott Shaw, The Plain DealerIn their third draft together, Tom Heckert and Mike Holmgren created a signature moment -- for good or bad -- for their Browns' regime. 1. For Mike Holmgren and Tom Heckert, the decision to draft Weeden is one that may define their time with the Browns. It will look great if Weeden has an Dalton-type rookie season (20 touchdowns, 13 interceptions, 80.4 QB rating) while the Browns come even close to .500. Dalton helped the Bengals make the playoffs, and the Browns don't have enough talent to do that in the AFC North. But if Weeden and Richardson lead them out of the 4-12, 5-11 rut of the past four years, this draft will be perhaps the best since the Browns returned in 1999.
2. If Weeden flops, fingers of blame will easily be pointed at a front office that used the No. 22 pick on a 28-year-old quarterback. He is the oldest player ever picked in the first round. Weeden needs to show an immediate return, because time is not on his side and the Browns are giving him the job.
3. In their third year running the Browns, this is the biggest draft risk of the Holmgren/Heckert regime. They believe in Weeden. Coach Pat Shurmur has to stop himself from some uncharacteristic gushing about the Oklahoma State quarterback. They believe he has the size, the maturity and arm strength to be a viable starter in the rugged AFC North.
4. The Browns believe Weeden has mental toughness from his frustrating five-year experience as a failed minor-league pitcher who never rose above Class A in the Yankees' farm system -- then recreated himself as a college quarterback. To get a picture of what Weeden endured in the minors, read "The Bullpen Gospels" (the language is raw, but the story is powerful) by former Kent State pitcher Dirk Hayhurst.
5. Shurmur and new offensive coordinator Brad Childress were on the Eagles' coaching staff when Donovan McNabb entered the NFL in 1999. They helped teach him the West Coast offense. At St. Louis, Shurmur was the coordinator when St. Louis drafted Sam Bradford, and helped him learn to take snaps. They are confident Weeden is a quick study.
6. The challenge for Shurmur and Childress will be to convert Weeden from the college spread offense, where he's almost always in the shotgun, to the WCO. Last season, the Browns were in the shotgun 48 percent of the time -- 27th of 32 teams. Detroit (80 percent) led the way, followed by Buffalo (75 percent) and New England (74 percent).
7. Here's one more plea for the Browns to keep McCoy, who is paid $540,000 and $570,000 over the next two seasons. Compare that to the near-$2.5 million paid annually to Seneca Wallace. Since Wallace has shown little interest in helping young quarterbacks, it makes no sense to keep him.
About right tackles and first guesses ...
1. There is no problem with drafting Schwartz in the second round. I don't worry that some drafting services have him in the third round. He started 51 games at California, played two years with center Alex Mack. He's played 35 games at left tackle, 16 at right tackle. Made first team All-Pac 12 as a left tackle. Unlike some left tackles who have to adjust to a new position with the Browns, that won't be a problem for Schwartz.
2. The Browns have Joe Thomas and Mitchell at the tackles, Mack at center and youngsters Jason Pinkston and Shaun Lauvao at the guards. They appear in very good shape for several years. The Browns absolutely love Schwartz. They targeted him in the second round and believe in his physical toughness, durability and run-blocking skills.
3. By failing to sign a strong right tackle in free agency such as Eric Winston, the Browns needed to use a second-round pick on the right tackle -- rather than a receiver. Of course, signing a veteran receiver could have helped when it comes to plugging holes.
4. I pushed for the Browns to sign Winston when Houston cut him in a salary-cap squeeze. He went to Kansas City on a four-year, $22 million deal. It appears at least $9.3 million is guaranteed, perhaps more. It's not an outrageous contract for a 28-year-old tackle who started every game for Houston since 2007. The Browns had the cap room to beat the Chiefs' offer.
5. When the Browns made the decision to draft Weeden while only signing veteran free-agent defensive ends Frostee Rucker and Juqua Parker, they simply created too many holes to fill in the draft. That led to them not taking a receiver in the first three rounds.
6. None of this is to second-guess drafting Schwartz. It's simply to say not signing a receiver or right tackle made it harder on draft day because their high picks went to fill other needs.
About the Cavaliers ...
AP fileWith the Cavaliers third in the current NBA draft order and no worse than sixth, Terry Pluto has visions of Kentucky's Michael Kidd-Gilchrist in wine and gold. 1. Cleveland is the town of drafts, and the Cavs will pick no worse than No. 6 in the NBA Draft. They have the third best chance to win the lottery and pick first. One second to dream ... Anthony Davis and Kyrie Irving ...
2. OK, back to reality. The Cavs should come up with a good player with their top pick. It's possible one of these small forwards could be available: Michael Kidd-Gilchrist (my favorite) and Harrison Barnes, depending upon how the luck of master coin-flip caller and NBA lottery winner Nick Gilbert holds out.
3. The Cavs also have 24th pick (from the Lakers for Ramon Sessions), along Nos. 33 and 34 in the second round. It's doubtful they will want four rookies, so don't be surprised if they trade one of these picks. With three between 24-34, they have value.
4. Daniel Gibson has a $4.8 million option for next season, with about $2.4 million guaranteed. He had another year with injuries, and shot only 35 percent from the field. Gibson has missed 62 games over the past three seasons. I do think the Cavs will probably pick up his option, but it's hard to count on him.
5. Omri Casspi had a chance to establish himself as a small forward, but averaged only 7.1 points and shot 40 percent in 21 minutes a night. He lost his starter's spot to Alonzo Gee. The Cavs still need shooting guards and small forwards, same as a year ago.
6. This is amazing: In 364 minutes (299 with the Cavs), Luke Walton did not attempt a single free throw! He averaged 2.0 points in 14 minutes a game for the Cavs. He was part of the Sessions deal, so the Cavs could add the Lakers' No. 1 pick. He's under contract for $5.8 million next year, but it's hard to imagine him on the 2012-13 roster.
7. It's Irving's outside shooting that gives him a chance to be a great player: 47 percent from the field, 40 percent on 3-pointers and 87 percent at the foul line. The reason he can drive to the basket so effectively is that opponents must respect his outside shot. Coach Byron Scott believes Irving's rookie season was even more impressive than Chris Paul's -- coached by Scott in New Orleans. He averaged 18.5 points in 30 minutes per game on a team that had few players who could create their own shots.
8. If the Cavs can keep Anderson Varejao healthy ... they were 10-15 with him in the lineup, 11-30 without him. When Irving and Varejao both played, the Cavs were 9-12. I'm anxious to see the interior defense next season with Varejao and Tristan Thompson, who really improved in the second half. Irving had 24 games of at least 20 points, and Antawn Jamison had 22. No one else had more than three. They must find another scorer, especially with Jamison headed elsewhere.
About the Indians ...
AP fileWith slumping bats hurting the Indians at several positions, Matt LaPorta (right, with Carlos Santana) could slug his way back to Cleveland in the near future. 1. Watching Shin-Soo Choo go down with a tight hamstring and Shelley Duncan showing that it's tough for him to play every day, I began looking at the minor-league stats. The star at Class AAA Columbus is Matt LaPorta, who entered Saturday hitting .371 (1.130 OPS) with six homers and 15 RBI in 18 games. He has played five games in left field, the rest at first base.
2. LaPorta has always hit at Class AAA, where his career mark is .321 (.924 OPS) with 29 homers and 94 RBI in 486 at-bats. He probably will keep hitting, and at some point, the Tribe will probably be forced to give him another chance. Too bad that he had a miserable spring, because left field was there for him.
3. Duncan entered Saturday batting .167 with 15 strikeouts in 32 at-bats over his previous 10 games. This season, he is 7-of-19 (.368) against righties, 6-of-36 (.167) against lefties. Yes, the Tribe continues to prepare Johnny Damon to share left field. Of course, the Indians really don't know if the 38-year-old Damon can physically handle it. He played only 16 games in the outfield in 2011, 36 in 2010. He has been mostly a DH the past two years.
4. Another issue could be Casey Kotchman, who entered the weekend batting .148. Yes, he's a terrific first baseman. But he hits for little power, so they need the Kotchman of 2011 (.306), not the Kotchman of 2010 (.217). But LaPorta could come into play at first base if Kotchman continues to struggle.
5. Great to see Strongsville and Kent State product Anthony Gallas hitting .343 (1.054 OPS) at Class A Carolina.
6. Jason Kipnis looks like an all-around athlete, especially at the plate where he already has three homers, two triples and a double. He's batting .257 after a slow start. He's stolen four bases in five attempts and has scored a couple of dramatic runs. He is fun to watch.