The answer is clear -- the Browns didn't think anyone but RGIII would have been that much of an upgrade over Colt McCoy.
Chuck Crow, The Plain DealerColt McCoy isn't Robert Griffin III, but the Browns clearly consider him a better alternative than some of the free-agent QBs on the market, and that included new Seattle QB Matt Flynn, says Terry Pluto. GOODYEAR, Ariz. -- Between spring training and an NFL season that never really ends, I'm ...
Talking to myself about the Browns
QUESTION: Is Colt McCoy really going to be the Browns' starting quarterback?
ANSWER: At least on opening day, unless there is a shocking move to come.
Q: How did the Browns end up back with McCoy?
A: There's no reason to rehash the old hash about what the Browns did or didn't offer for the No. 2 pick and Robert Griffin III. Their point is they tried to move into the top two of the draft for a shot at the Baylor QB -- or Andrew Luck if the Colts stunned everyone and selected Griffin.
Q: But why McCoy?
A: You mean why not someone such as Matt Flynn? He signed a rather modest contract with Seattle -- three years, $19.5 million. It has an $8 million signing bonus/salary for 2012. In 2013, it's $5.25M. In 2014, it's $6.25M. Of the $19.5M, $10M is guaranteed.
Q: So why didn't the Browns sign him?
A: The answer is clear -- they don't think he's much of an upgrade. They looked at the two games (yes, only two) that he started for the Packers and thought he showed the ability to start in the NFL. But they were not sold on him. They haven't said this in a press conference, but their actions spoke loudly. They gave defensive end Frostee Rucker a five-year, $20.5 million deal with $8M guaranteed, so it wasn't money or cap space.
Q: Do you think Flynn is better than McCoy?
A: Who knows? He played two great games for a great team. But my point with this story is to figure out what the Browns are doing with their quarterbacks.
Q: This is news?
A: This is thinking about the news. The Browns didn't go after Flynn. They didn't go after Chad Henne ($6.5M, two years, Jacksonville) or any other free-agent quarterbacks, such as Jason Campbell ($3.5M, Bears) or Kyle Orton ($10.5M, three years, Dallas). The only quarterback move they made was the attempt to trade up in the draft.
Q: Meaning what?
A: They are sincere when they say McCoy should make some significant steps from 2011, in his second season in the same offense and coaching staff. They believe he had some trouble learning the West Coast Offense (WCO), partly because the lockout meant there were no minicamps, etc. They believe he is better than those free agents (OK, not Peyton Manning) who were available.
Q: How does McCoy feel about the Browns trying to trade for a quarterback?
A: The Browns have talked to McCoy. He knows it's a business. Look at all the teams that talked to Manning. The job is still his, and he has a new offensive coordinator in Brad Childress to help him with Pat Shurmur's offense.
Q: So they won't draft a quarterback?
A: Just the opposite, they probably will draft a quarterback, but I doubt it will be Ryan Tannehill at No. 4. They absolutely must use that pick on an impact player -- even if they trade down a few notches. The quarterback could be Brandon Weeden or someone else lower in the draft -- but McCoy is the starter.
Q: Didn't they say there would be a quarterback competition in training camp? What about Seneca Wallace?
A: Wallace will be 32 in August. He has a 6-15 record as a starter, 1-6 with the Browns. His stats were even worse than McCoy's last year. It makes no sense to start Wallace. In fact, the Browns should ask themselves if he is the right guy as a backup, because he has been unhappy in that role -- and it seems he wasn't exactly a lot of help to McCoy.
Q: What would you do?
A: I'd find another backup quarterback, but I'm not sure what they will do.
Q: If McCoy is the guy for this season, are they ever going to get him some help?
A: You mean like a right tackle, a running back, a couple of receivers? I'm hoping for a real big draft day, because those are huge holes that need to be filled.
About the Indians
Chuck Crow, The Plain DealerGiven a chance to win the third-base job, Lonnie Chisenhall has not be able to improve his high strikeout numbers during spring training. 1. From the start of spring training, the plan was for Lonnie Chisenhall to prove that he should open at third base by having a big spring where he showed better defense and more plate discipline -- cutting down strikeouts and adding walks. Otherwise, Jack Hannahan would start. Well, otherwise appears to be the case as Hannahan is expected to be named the Tribe's Opening Day third baseman, with Chisenhall sent back to the minors.
2. This spring, Chisenhall has one walk compared with 15 strikeouts in 34 plate appearances. He's hitting .242 (.537 OPS) with no homers and three RBI. There has not been the progress that the Tribe hoped for, and they believe Chisenhall is pressing and needs to go to Columbus to be more patient at the plate.
3. Last season, Chisenhall had only eight walks compared to 49 strikeouts in 220 plate appearances for the Tribe. He hit .255 (.699 OPS) with seven homers and 22 RBI. He had some nice moments, and some weeks when he looked like a 22-year-old in his first trip to the majors.
4. This is not about writing off Chisenhall, 23. He only hit .267 (.784 OPS) with seven homers and 45 RBI in 255 at-bats for Columbus, so it's not as if he destroyed International League pitching a year ago. Most players need at least one return trip to the minors before establishing themselves in the majors.
5. The 32-year-old Hannahan had to battle to make the team last season, and third base is not promised for the entire year. But he was superb with the glove for the Tribe, and batted a surprising (for him) .250 with eight homers and 40 RBI (.719 OPS). The Indians consider him a Gold Glove-caliber fielder, critical to their defense.
6. The Tribe also thinks the infield defense will be above average (after being below average the last few years). Hannahan and new first baseman Casey Kotchman are outstanding in the field. Asdrubal Cabrera is solid at short, and Jason Kipnis is improving at second. A year ago, they opened with Hannahan and Asdrubal Cabrera on the left side of the infield, so that remains the same. The Tribe believes Kipnis has much better range than 2011 opening second baseman Orlando Cabrera. Matt LaPorta is a below average first baseman.
7. If Jeanmar Gomez (11 scoreless innings) continues to pitch well, and Kevin Slowey (6.75 ERA) continues to struggle, the Indians will not hesitate to send Slowey to the minors. Yes, Slowey was 35-20 for the Twins from 2008-10, but he was 0-8 with a 6.67 ERA in 2011. He had injuries last season, but supposedly is healthy now. The Tribe is paying $1.25 million of Slowey's contract, and the 27-year-old has minor-league options left. So they can send him to Columbus and hope he pulls himself together.
8. Gomez has been so strong, there also is talk to putting him in the bullpen to pitch in middle relief. They believe he has the control and temperament to do it. It seems Gomez will make the team in some fashion.
9. The Indians want Carlos Santana to improve his defense behind the plate, to really work with pitchers and concentrate more on blocking balls in the dirt. The average major-league catcher's throws arrive at second base in 2.0 seconds. Santana has had a few in 1.85, but direction is just as important -- his throws sometimes sail high. Lou Marson's average is 1.92, but the key to making him one of the best throwing catchers in baseball is how his throws are right on the bag, knee high -- ideal for an infielder to catch and apply the tag.
10. Asdrubal Cabrera has been working extra to take off the added weight (the Indians don't say how much) that he gained in the off-season. He is playing well, but the Tribe believes he can finish stronger if he stays in better condition. Cabrera batted .244 (.729 OPS) with 11 HR and 41 RBI after the All-Star break compared to .293 (.946 OPS) with 14 HR and 51 RBI in the first half.
11. The Plain Dealer will have its annual Opening Day breakfast on April 5. It's $25 a person from 7:30-9 a.m. at The Plain Dealer. There will be a breakfast buffet with door prizes. I will be there along with Dennis Manoloff and Paul Hoynes. Call 216-999-4028.
About the Cavaliers
Duane Burleson, Associated PressManny Harris isn't a top NBA prospect, but Terry Pluto doesn't believe there's much reason not to give the former Michigan star regular minutes for the rest of the Cavaliers' season. 1. In the first 11 games of March, Anthony Parker is averaging 5.8 points, shooting 41 percent from the field, 35 percent on 3-pointers. In those 11 games, he's averaging 27 minutes. Only once has he scored more than seven points. He has been to the foul line only 11 times, making four free throws.
2. Parker will be 37 on June 19. He has battled back problems and clearly is not part of the franchise's future. If Byron Scott still wants to start him, that's fine. But cut the minutes way back. Lately, he has been on the court for 30 minutes a game, and doesn't do much. He is easy to defend because he seldom drives to the basket -- he's a stand-still jump shooter. Nor is he a great defender or passer. He also doesn't move as if he's close to 100 percent physically.
3. This is not about Manny Harris being a future star and being held back by Parker and Scott. It is about how Harris is an interesting prospect, as is Donald Sloan. The Cavs must find out if either (or both) can play next season. They need a backup point behind Kyrie Irving. They have no shooting guard. Daniel Gibson is a backup, and he's had a miserable shooting season. That's an issue, because Gibson's strength is his shooting, but he's at 35 percent from the field this season.
4. Some fans want all the veterans to sit ... but Antawn Jamison has been an asset with his attitude, rebounding and scoring. Yes, his shooting is streaky (42 percent). On the season, he's averaging 18.4 points, 6.7 rebounds in 33 minutes a game. He's at 21.9 points in March. He takes some of the offensive load off Irving, who doesn't always have to create a shot as the 24-second clock ticks town.
5. That's part of the problem when the Cavs have Gibson and Parker on the court (especially together) with Omri Casspi at small forward. None can create their own shot when a play breaks down. It appears Harris has some of that ability. Let's see if he can help. And let's definitely see if Sloan can be the backup point guard. This is how the Cavs learned Alonzo Gee was a keeper last season -- they gave him an opportunity.
6. With Tristan Thompson at center and Jamison at power forward, that creates minutes for Samardo Samuels (another interesting prospect). That's especially true as it appears Anderson Varejao will be out at least two more weeks, while Ryan Hollins was bought out (and signed by Boston). Semih Erden has not shown enough to earn regular minutes off the bench.