Ohio State has a quarterback decision this week, but the possibility of throwing in a true freshman can't be taken lightly.
Wilfredo Lee, Associated PressSenior Joe Bauserman has not thrown an interception this season, but his penchant for throwing the ball away has caused many OSU fans to sour on him as the team's starter.
Columbus -- Ohio State's starting quarterback against Colorado on Saturday could be the guy who threw two passes that mattered against Miami, and had one of them intercepted, and who, during his other 16 plays on the field, lost control of the football three times.
Or it might be the guy who most Buckeyes fans think is worse.
Freshman quarterback Braxton Miller is the first option. Fifth-year senior Joe Bauserman is the second option. And though some fans might have tired of the 25-year-old Bauserman after his three starts this season, starting a true freshman quarterback at this level of college football can't be taken lightly.
"I couldn't even imagine it," OSU junior Zach Boren said of starting at quarterback as a freshman, though Boren himself did start as a freshman fullback. "The quarterback, you have to know what everyone is doing every single moment, so it's definitely hard to be a true freshman and be out there playing quarterback."
Ohio State coach Luke Fickell was noncommittal on his quarterbacks Tuesday, saying the battle will continue to be waged in practice this week. Ohio State center Mike Brewster, speaking after Tuesday's practice, said the practice snaps were divided the same as they have been, as he worked primarily with Bauserman and Miller. No. 3 quarterback Kenny Guiton doesn't appear to be a major part of the conversation.
The contrast in the decision facing Fickell and his staff is stark, though the choice itself might not be as clear as the fans rooting for the freshman hope it is. Bauserman hasn't made many plays this season, but he also hasn't made any turnovers. Miller has made more of both, and Fickell is, in general, aggravated by the turnovers to the point of exaggeration.
Wilfredo Lee, Associated PressFreshman Braxton Miller appears to be a more dynamic presence on the field than Joe Bauserman, but his penchant for turnovers, he is recovering his fumble here against Miami, makes coach Luke Fickell hesitant to commit to him as the No. 1 guy.
Last year, Ohio State lost two fumbles in 13 games.
"I don't want to exactly tell you how many we've had already this year, but I can tell you it's almost three times or twice as many in three games," Fickell said. "We've got to get better."
The number is actually three fumbles lost in three games, two by redshirt freshman running back Rod Smith in the first two games and one by Miller on Saturday in the 24-6 loss to Miami. But Miller also mishandled a handoff that he fell on for a 4-yard loss and had the ball pop loose when he scrambled on another play, though he had the good fortune to have it fall back in his lap.
"You always need to take care of the ball, but at the same time, when you've got that playmaking ability, if you're able to get outside of the pocket, you can make something out of nothing," OSU right tackle J.B. Shugarts said. "You've got to keep the ball high and tight, but it's nothing to worry about. He'll be fine."
Miller also has thrown the only OSU interception, though it also can be argued that Bauserman, while interception-less, is too conservative and throws the ball away too often.
As some fans have pointed out, there aren't any other 25-year-old former minor-league baseball players starting in major college football. But there's less to worry about with old guys. There does have to be some caution exercised with a quarterback straight out of high school, and Miller talked during preseason camp about his gradual grasping of the playbook that Bauserman has been learning for five years.
This year, among the 100 top-rated passers in the NCAA statistics, only five of the quarterbacks are true freshmen. And none of them are from BCS conferences. Last year, seven of the top 100-rated passers were true freshmen, and only two of them were from BCS conferences: Chas Dodd with 4-8 Rutgers, and Penn State's Rob Bolden, who lost his starting job during the season to former walk-on Matt McGloin.
At this level, there's no such thing as just throwing in a true freshman quarterback. And while Miller was more advanced as a complete quarterback than Terrelle Pryor coming out of high school, Pryor's rare athleticism helped him survive and succeed in what was an unusual circumstance when he took over as a true freshman in 2008 for the Buckeyes.
What was right for Pryor, in the mind of then-OSU coach Jim Tressel, might not necessarily be what is right for Miller, this Ohio State team or Fickell. And while offensive coordinator Jim Bollman leads the offense, when it comes to decisions about who plays on offense, Fickell said he's pretty sure there will be a consensus among the staff, but, "ultimately we understand that when there's a decision that has to be made, there's got to be one place the buck stops."
This decision this week is a big one, with the Buckeyes (2-1) out of the top 25 for the first time since 2004. More Miller than last week, when he played 18 snaps to Bauserman's 37? Miller still as the second option to Bauserman? All Miller and no Bauserman? It can't be easy. But when asked if playing a freshman too early could set back his development, Fickell said, "Not that I know of."
So maybe it is time. But it wouldn't be because of how Miller played at Miami. It would be because the coaches feel like there's no other choice.