A running half-joke is that a caddie's job involves "the three ups" -- show up, keep up and shut up. In reality, most top golfers expect much more.
John Kuntz, The Plain DealerThis week, Tiger Woods has long-time friend Bryon Bell carrying his bag for the WGC-Bridgestone Invitational. But it's likely Woods will eventually find a full-time caddie to replace Stevie Williams, "someone who probably has been there before and who understands it and can deal with that," Woods says. AKRON, Ohio -- Next to the return of Tiger Woods, the soap opera turns to the new guy he hired to lug his clubs.
In a very public separation late last month, Woods fired caddie Steve Williams and replaced him -- at least for the moment -- with Bryon Bell, a long-time friend and president of Woods' golf design firm.
Woods and Williams had 12 mostly wonderful years together, but like a bad divorce, it got a little messy. Williams, now caddying for Adam Scott, has said he felt like he wasted the last two years of his life working for Woods as the golfer wrestled with his actual divorce, injuries and trying to rediscover his game.
"Well, that's what he says and what he feels," Woods told the media this week at the World Golf Championships-Bridgestone Invitational at Akron's Firestone Country Club. "I thought it was time for a change," Woods continued, keeping his decision strictly business.
But to describe a caddie change as just business, not personal, greatly undervalues the relationships that endure.
"It has become much more personal than ever before," said Dan Weigand, editor of the Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, and co-author of "Caddy-Talk: Psychology of Being a Great Golf Caddy."
For as much time as they spend together, for as linked as their livelihoods are, no one, family members aside, is closer to a golfer than his or her caddie.
"We're almost more like brothers," said Heath Slocum, describing his relationship with 20-year caddie D.J. Nelson.
Woods and Williams were in each other's weddings. Tom Watson and the late Bruce Edwards together publicly dealt with Edwards' gut-wrenching battle with Lou Gehrig's Disease. Caddie Joe Skovron, who is just 30 himself, has known his boss, Rickie Fowler, since the 22-year-old player was four.
Previous Plain Dealer coverage
Related stories
When asked this week the most important attribute a caddie can have, golfers and their caddies repeatedly described a successful relationship in two words: Trust and confidence. Trust that each has the other's best interest at heart. Confidence that, together, the combination will consistently finish in the money.
"The biggest thing -- he reinforces 'pull the trigger,' that last little bit of encouragement before [the golfer] goes up to hit the ball," said Dennis Cone, president and founder of the Professional Caddies Association.
Cone, who represented Mike "Fluff" Cowan when Cowan was Woods' caddie, compared the role to a coach offering a last-ditch "you can do it" before a little leaguer steps to the plate.
"They also know when to shut up, too," Cone said. "It's just like a relationship with your wife. There's times when you talk about it and times when you leave it alone."
A running half-joke is that a caddie's job involves "the three ups" -- show up, keep up and shut up. In reality, most top golfers expect much more. In fact, a caddie who's mum is an invaluable as one who never stops yapping. Like success on the green, it's all touch and feel.
"Knowing when to kind of stay out of the way and when to step in," said Fowler, who as a young golfer looked up to Skovron when the caddie was a rising player back in Murietta, Calif. "You've got to have someone when you're playing good, [when] kind of everything's clicking, to just sit back, give you some numbers and let you go," Fowler said. "And there's times where you're having a rough day that they need to step in and say, 'Settle down, let's figure this out.' So it's just someone who kind of knows your personality, knows how you react and play on the course."
Some combinations survive for decades. Some golfers change caddies like they change putters. In April, Dustin Johnson dumped Bobby Brown after three years for Joe LaCava, who carried for Fred Couples. In May, Scott fired Tony Navarro after seven years and replaced him with Michael Doran before hiring Williams. Cowan is working for Jim Furyk.
Like some marriages, the relationship can just get stale.
"There's a belief," Weigand said, "that change is a quicker solution than working to make it work."
Woods may not yet be done with his caddie carousel. He told reporters this week that Bell's position was an interim one, based on how things go. "For now" could become "for good" if Woods and Bell mesh with a tournament on the line.
"You know, someone that obviously understands the pressure of the game coming down the back nine," said Woods, when asked what he looks for in a caddie. "Someone who probably has been there before and who understands it and can deal with that."
On the course, the player is CEO and caddie the employee. But when a golfer is struggling, the roles seem reversed -- which is where the trust and confidence come in.
"If a golfer's attitude was going down the wrong road," said caddie John Wood, "you need to kind of give them a little correction and say, 'Look, you know you don't play your best golf doing what you're doing right now.'"
Wood has been a PGA caddie for 15 years, the last six with last year's Bridgestone champion, Hunter Mahan. He was managing a bookstore when Kevin Sutherland, who knew him from their home town of Sacramento, asked if he might be interested in carrying his bag on tour.
Wood smiled when asked if the job is lucrative. "It can be, working for a good player, absolutely," he said, declining to offer specifics.
At Bridgestone, no golfer gets cut, so everyone gets paid. For caddies, this is a good week.