The Tribe has its own version of a Big Three with Josh Tomlin, Justin Masterson and Carlos Carrasco.
Justin Masterson kept the New York Yankees off balance Wednesday night to propel the Cleveland Indians to victory.
CLEVELAND, Ohio - Tribe fans just watched their Big Three in the Yankees Series.
Josh Tomlin.
Justin Masterson.
Carlos Carrasco.
Yes, Carrasco had his first bad game in two months, giving up six runs in four innings in the 9-2 loss to New York. But the fact is Carrasco is 7-4 with a 3.51 ERA since coming off the disabled list on May 11.
Carrasco is still a work in progress, but you can really see the progress.
And you can look at the Tribe's Big Three and feel very good whenever they take the mound.
Just ask the Yankees, who lost two of three to the Tribe and managed a grand total of two runs in 16 innings off Tomlin and Masterson.
Talk about Fire and Ice, that's Masterson and Tomlin.
Masterson shut down the Yankees for eight innings, slinging 95 mph fastballs and 92 mph sinkers from a strange sidearm delivery that was the reason many believed Masterson could never be a starter. He's 6-foot-6, 250 pounds of arms and legs flying in different directions as if auditioning for a role as the world's largest pretzel before delivering a pitch.
Then there's Tomlin. Or as Manny Acta says of him: "That little cowboy from Texas is money in the bank for five innings."
The Tribe manager meant Tomlin's first 29 major-league starts, all being at least five innings -- the most since 1919, when people began counting these things.
But this season, Tomlin has pitched at least six innings in 16 of 17 starts. His record is 10-4 with a 3.78 ERA -- walking 13 . . . in 17 starts.
"If he walks one, I'm surprised," said Acta. "If he walks two, I want to blame the umpire."
No sweat from Tomlin
Tomlin's typical fastball (88 mph) is about the same speed as Masterson's changeup.
Tomlin is averaging the fewest walks per nine innings of any American League starter; Masterson gives up the fewest homers per nine innings. Between them, they have record quality starts (three or fewer runs in at least six innings) in 27 of 35 outings.
While Masterson's body appears headed for an appointment with a chiropractor, Tomlin's motion is compact, smooth with a minimum of effort. No doubt, he's sweated when on the mound -- but it's hard to remember when.
Masterson's stuff sizzles and burns up bats; Tomlin's takes its time, hugging the corners and baffling batters.
Where Masterson displays his cool is in terms of patience with his teammates. He went 11 starts without a victory this season -- his record 0-6 with a 3.34 ERA in that span. In four of those 11 games, the Tribe was shut out.
He never complained, he just vowed to pitch better.
His 7-6 record is deceiving, because his 2.66 ERA sparkles, eighth-best in the American League.
As for Carrasco, he has it all -- the 94 mph fastball, the sharp slider, the sinker, the changeup and the control.
Young arms available
Keep in mind that Tomlin and Masterson are 26, Carrasco is 24.
Since being promoted to Cleveland in September 2010, Carrasco is 10-7 with a 3.86 ERA in 23 starts. He is putting all those pitches together.
Yes, the Indians need to either fix or replace the remaining two spots in their rotation.
Fausto Carmona (4-10, 5.78) has the highest ERA of any regular AL starting pitcher. He is on the disabled list with a thigh injury, and will make at least one rehabilitation start before returning. It could be a good chance for the Indians to figure out what is wrong with the man who was their only All-Star in 2010.
Friday, Mitch Talbot starts. Since July 2010, he is 4-12 with a 5.40 ERA. He has been on the disabled list twice in the past 12 months. This is an important start for his future, as the Indians are expected to review the last two spots in the rotation during next week's All-Star break.
That's because the Tribe has serious alternatives at Class AAA Columbus.
Zach McAllister makes his major-league debut Thursday. The 23-year-old was 8-3 with a 2.97 ERA for the Clippers. Jeanmar Gomez, 23, is a prime candidate to grab a spot in the rotation, as he's 9-2 with a 2.26 ERA for the Clippers.
The hope is 22-year-old phenom Alex White can come back from his finger injury before the end of the season. Lefty Scott Barnes (7-3, 3.61 ERA) has emerged as a prospect at the age of 24. David Huff (8-2, 3.84) has been pitching better lately.
All four starters -- Barnes, Gomez, McAllister and Huff -- have been in Columbus, knocking on the big league door.
At Class A Kinston, Drew Pomeranz (top pick in 2010) is 3-2 with a 1.87 ERA in his first pro season. He will be at Class AA Akron soon.
The key to a strong starting rotation is a wealth of talented starters who are in their 20s -- and that's exactly what the Indians have this season.