An NBA-record 25 losses in a row ... how did this happen? What should they do next?
John Kuntz / The Plain DealerFor much of the Cavaliers' 25-game losing streak, scenes such as this one with Jamario Moon reflected a disbelief that so much that had gone so right for so long could now go so wrong. Terry Pluto says there are many factors that have played into this wretched season. CLEVELAND, Ohio -- The Cavs have lost an NBA-record 25 in a row. Even more stunning, they've lost 35 of 36 games.
This from a team that opened the season with an upset of the Boston Celtics, the Eastern Conference champions. This from a team that actually was 7-9, a team coached by 10-year veteran Byron Scott, a team with one of the most free-spending owners in the NBA.
So how did this happen?
More important, what should they do next?
The Cavs' decision
This is not "The Decision" that LeBron James tortured Cavs fans with on July 8 when the two-time MVP announced he was "taking my talents to South Beach." It was a decision made by the Cavs at the start of the 2009-10 season, when they were unable to engage James in any serious talks about extending his contract.
Looking back, it's easy to say the Cavs should have known James was leaving because of his lack of interest in a new contract. Therefore, they should have traded him with one year left on his deal.
But go back a year. Imagine the response of the fans if they had traded James, without knowing for sure that he would leave. Imagine how James could have twisted that in his favor, insisting he still might have signed here, but wanted more time to think about it -- and the Cavs wouldn't wait.
Dealing him a year ago would have been a public relations disaster. It also might not have been simple, especially if James only wanted to play for a few teams. Look at all the problems encountered by Denver as it tries to trade Carmelo Anthony as he heads into his free-agent summer.
So the Cavs decided to go "all in" for a title, dealing for Shaquille O'Neal and later Antawn Jamison. They had the third-highest payroll in the NBA, nearly $100 million including luxury taxes. In the last few years, they traded draft choices and signed veterans to excessive contracts in an attempt to win a title and keep James.
They gambled and lost.
James' decision
A woeful season, well-earned
The Cavs rank 27th out of 30 NBA teams on both offense and defense. Here are the key categories through 52 games:
Category |
Cavs |
Opp |
Diff |
Points per game |
94.22 |
105.65 |
- 11.43 |
Assists per game |
21.04 |
24.35 |
- 3.31 |
Rebounds per game |
39.59 |
43.71 |
- 4.12 |
Blocks per game |
4.00 |
5.78 |
- 1.78 |
Steals per game |
6.75 |
7.57 |
- 0.82 |
Akron's native son did the Cavs no favors by acting as if he was open to signing with them -- and several other teams -- as he spent a weekend meeting with representatives from the Nets, Knicks, Bulls, Clippers, Cavs and Heat.
It now seems James, along with former Toronto star Chris Bosh, was planing to join Dwyane Wade in Miami -- planning this for months, if not longer. But Bosh and James kept their mouths shut about their future, leaving their old teams waiting and in poor position to replace them.
Free agency began on July 1. James made his announcement on the evening of July 8. Word of him heading to Miami didn't leak out until July 7. By then, the Cavs were taken out of the market for any major free agents.
James did more than leave, he left them with no real way to even come close to replacing him.
Being patient
Gus Chan / The Plain DealerFor better or worse, the Cavaliers hoped that the veterans who had won during the LeBron years -- including Daniel Gibson and Anderson Varejao -- could help the franchise transition to a new outlook this season. But injuries devastated that plan, with Gibson, Mo Williams and Anthony Parker all missing significant playing time and Varejao lost for the season with an ankle injury. Rather than sign or trade for high-priced veterans near the end of their careers -- much as they did with Jamison -- the Cavs decided to take the hit. They would not keep O'Neal or Ilgauskas. They traded the emotionally troubled but talented Delonte West for two young players -- Ramon Sessions and Ryan Hollins.
They also settled for four future draft picks from Miami in exchange for James: Two first rounders, two second rounders and a $14 million trade exception.
They decided to open the season with veterans Mo Williams, Anderson Varejao, Anthony Parker, Daniel Gibson, J.J. Hickson and Jamison as their core players. If that group proved it could stay around .500 and compete for a playoff spot by the end of 2010, then the Cavs would make a dramatic trade to win now.
But if they began to lose, all plans would involve being patient and planning for the future.
Over and over, General Manager Chris Grant talked about "being strategic" and "being flexible" with the salary cap, not selling out the future to take away some of the pain today.
Break up the Cavs
Jae C. Hong / Associated PressWhen the short-handed Cavaliers were forced to give starting roles to youngsters Manny Harris (8, against the Lakers), Christian Eyenga, Alonzo Gee and Samardo Samuels, their fate was set. Once James departed, some fans and media members thought the team should dump its best players and lose big. This is not baseball, where the lack of a salary cap allows richer teams to easily buy up stars from smaller-market franchises who are losing. Tribe fans know how this deal hurts.
But fate broke up the Cavs, as in a broken bone in the foot of Varejao -- Scott's favorite player and perhaps the team's most valuable because of his ability to play center and power forward, to rebound, defend and inspire his teammates.
During the 25-game losing streak, Varejao has missed 19 games, Williams missed 14, Parker missed eight and Gibson missed seven.
There have been nights when Jamison and Hickson are surrounded by Alonzo Gee, Manny Harris, Christian Eyenga, Samardo Samuels, Sessions and Hollins. That group is simply not NBA ready -- Samuels, Harris and Eyenga are rookies, Gee a guy who bounces between the D-League and the NBA.
Sessions is a promising player, but perhaps best as a backup.
For much of the losing streak, the players available on the roster looked destined to lose nearly every night.
What about coaching?
John Kuntz / The Plain DealerByron Scott never anticipated that so many of his veterans would be unavailable this season, and the youngsters have struggled to understand his offensive and defensive strategies. But the Cavaliers haven't quit -- as shown in repeated narrow defeats over the last two weeks. If Scott were a rookie head coach, there would be more of a temptation to put some of the blame on him. But he has been through rebuilding situations in New Jersey and New Orleans. He has taken two teams to the NBA Finals in New Jersey, and was Coach of the Year in New Orleans.
You can criticize him for making too many changes to the offense and defense, but he also believes an up-tempo motion offense is how the Cavs must play in a post-James era. He also hasn't had a group of players healthy enough for an extended period to make his Xs and Os come to life.
Too many nights, he has guys just trying to figure out what it takes to play in the NBA -- and looking overwhelmed by the pace and physical demands of the game.
During this record losing streak, there has been little dissension. Certainly Jamison and a few others would welcome a trade to a contender, but no one is demanding it. There is little second guessing of the coaches.
Scott had a public spat with Hickson, sitting him for a game after a missed practice. But Scott's tough love has dramatically increased Hickson's desire to rebound -- which is what the coaches wanted. He's averaging 11.7 rebounds in the last 15 games. He was at 5.4 before Jan. 1.
Rather than quit, the Cavs actually have been playing better of late -- losing their last four games by an average of five points. They seem to be listening to Scott.
James is vindicated?
National viewpoints on the Cavs
The national media takes a quick glance at the standings and concludes James is right, the Cavs stink -- so he can't be blamed for leaving. Injuries are ignored. So is the fact that owner Dan Gilbert would have continued to spend and add talent if James had stayed.
In fact, the Cavs believed they had a deal for Bosh with Toronto if James would have signed an extension.
Miami was 37-14 heading into Tuesday night. It was the second-best record in the Eastern Conference, and the Heat have been indeed hot since wiping out the Cavs, 118-90, on Dec. 2. That dropped the Cavs to 7-11, Miami moved to 12-8.
But remember that no team won more games than the Cavs over the last two regular seasons. It was in the playoffs where they stumbled. It will be the playoffs where the final verdict on James' decision will be delivered -- not now or even in early spring.
Let's see if Miami is still playing basketball in June.
What's next?
LM Otero / Associated PressAntawn Jamison is averaging over 17 points and six rebounds per game, to little reward in the win column. It will take a while for the hangover from this season to fade. Losing a star and rebuilding is hard. Just ask Chicago, which has not made it past the second round since Michael Jordan left in 1998. You have to be both good in terms of scouting and coaching, and lucky that you happen to have a high draft pick when a great player is available.
So it's hard to project what will happen next season.
The Cavs are interested in adding draft picks and young players -- such as the deal for Sessions. They are active in trade talks. Mo Williams may have been of interest to some teams, but he has been hurt most of the season -- injuries ranging from a groin pull to an inflamed hip.
When Williams did play, he moved poorly on defense and his ballhandling was sloppy. He said his injuries prevented him from having his usual mobility. Varejao is out for the season with ankle surgery and is as close to an untouchable as the Cavs have on their roster.
Jamison has a contract that pays him $15 million next season, which makes it difficult to trade him. They may be able to move veterans Jamario Moon or Parker for second-round picks as they have expiring contracts.
But the key is to keep working with young players such as Hickson, Harris, Eyenga, Sessions and Samuels. If they have the worst record in the NBA, it guarantees them the best odds for the top pick in the college draft -- and they will pick no lower than fourth. In June, they have their own first- and second-round picks, plus a second rounder from Miami.
They also may be open to adding a veteran in a trade as they will have salary cap room.
So yes, it's wait until next year -- or at least the June draft.
Until then, it will be a very long season for the team and its fans.