Danny Salazar and two relievers held the Rangers to five hits -- and the Indians still lost, 2-1, Sunday afternoon in Arlington, Texas. The Rangers won three of four in the series.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Left-hander Derek Holland allowed one run in six innings and Ian Desmond and Jonathan Lucroy each had an RBI single as the Texas Rangers defeated the Cleveland Indians, 2-1, Sunday afternoon at Globe Life Park in Arlington, Texas. Tribe right-hander Danny Salazar gave up two runs and struck out 10 in 5 1/3 innings.
Here is a capsule look at the key aspect(s) of the game, which was televised by Fox Sports Time Ohio:
Sad news up front: I was enthusiastic about writing Game Report 129 -- until I learned that my friend Ken Carpenter died of cancer at 59. Now I don't have much enthusiasm.
Kenny was a former sports copy editor at The Plain Dealer. He eventually moved to Florida, where he taught college journalism and did a million other productive things. He was a mentor to me and countless others. A truly special person.
Kenny knew as much about Cleveland sports -- specifically, the Indians -- as anyone on the planet. He was a baseball savant.
Kenny would be upset if we allowed his passing to affect our work rate for even a second, especially when the work involved baseball. So Game Report 129 will be done. But it will not be easy. Typing is difficult when everything is numb.
Rough week: The Indians (73-56), first place in the AL Central, went 2-5 on a trip that began Monday night in Oakland, Calif. They lost two of three to the bad Athletics and three of four to the Rangers, who at least lead the AL West at 77-54.
Offensive offense: The Indians scored one or fewer in six of the seven games. The outlier came Friday, when they defeated the Rangers, 12-1. In the other three meetings at Globe Life, they lost, 9-0, 7-0 and 2-1.
If the Indians faced an assortment of superior starting pitchers on the trip, the lack of production would have been easier for Tribe Nation to stomach. They scored a total of 16 and went 2-5 despite facing Andrew Triggs, Sean Manaea, Kendall Graveman, Cole Hamels, Martin Perez, A.J. Griffin and Holland.
Only Hamels has been high-end for the balance of the season. Predictably, Hamels gave up two hits in eight innings of the 9-0 victory Thursday.
This was the combined line of Triggs, Manaea, Griffin and Holland:
25 IP, 15 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 4 BB, 25 K (3-0)
On Sunday, Holland and his finesse gave up four hits, walked none and struck out five. He improved to 6-6 and lowered his ERA to 4.68.
Yes, Holland deserves credit for a game well-pitched. But he is no Hamels. No even close.
Bitter pills: The Indians pressured the Rangers in the sixth, seventh and ninth innings -- and managed a total of one run.
*Abraham Almonte led off the sixth with a single and stole second. Chris Gimenez grounded to Holland and Rajai Davis flied to center.
Jason Kipnis turned on an 0-1 fastball and ripped it to right for an RBI single. Francisco Lindor singled to left, Kipnis stopping at second. Mike Napoli lined a 1-2 breaking pitch to deep left, where Carlos Gomez reached high to grab it. Gomez initially seemed fooled by the trajectory before drifting back.
*Carlos Santana led off the seventh against hard-throwing lefty reliever Jake Diekman by drawing a four-pitch walk.
Jose Ramirez took consecutive balls Nos. 5, 6 and 7. Diekman threw a 3-0 fastball (93 mph) that scraped the bottom of the zone, and umpire John Tumpane gave him the benefit of the doubt. Ramirez took another fastball (94) for a strike and fouled a fastball (94). Diekman threw a fastball (94) at the shins that Ramirez grounded to shortstop Elvis Andrus, who triggered a 6-4-3 double play.
It is easy for an observer to say that a batter "swung at ball four'' when the observer is not the one trying to decide in a split-second whether a 94-mph pitch over the plate is several inches low. And Ramirez has been a terrific hitter this season, so he has earned the right to attack. In fairness to Ramirez, Tumpane's 3-0 call not only prevented a walk, it probably planted in Ramirez's mind that anything close to the knees would be called a strike.
Fox Sports Time Ohio play-by-play voice Matt Underwood said: "(Diekman) threw seven straight balls and got out of it with a double play.''
Brandon Guyer dumped a single to right. Almonte grounded to second.
*Lindor led off the ninth against righty closer Sam Dyson with a first-pitch single to center. As Napoli struck out swinging at a quality 2-2 changeup, Lindor stole second.
Santana walked in four pitches. Ramirez walked in four pitches to load the bases.
Lefty Tyler Naquin, an AL rookie of the year candidate, pinch-hit for Guyer.
Naquin took a fastball (96) outside and a fastball (95) outside. Problem for Naquin and the Indians was, Tumpane called the second one a strike. FoxTrax showed Tumpane blew the call, by plenty.
Tumpane's issues with outside pitches to left-handed batters dated to the first inning, when he punched-out Kipnis on a 2-2 fastball that FoxTrax showed to be a (really) bad miss.
Fox Sports Time Ohio analyst Rick Manning said: "(Dyson) got help from the home-plate umpire. Usually, when a guy's had a tough time throwing strikes -- he's thrown nine straight balls -- he's not going to get any help.''
Naquin fouled a fastball down and in. Dyson threw his best pitch of the appearance, a changeup (89) running off the outside edge below the knees, and Naquin swung and missed.
When a decision to pinch-hit fizzles, the ground is fertile for a second-guess. Indians manager Terry Francona likely will be enshrined in the National Baseball Hall of Fame someday, and Naquin made sense to a degree....but I wish Francona would have stayed with Guyer.
Guyer's strikeout rate was lower, and fly-ball rate higher, against righties than Naquin's respective numbers. Just as importantly, I submit, is that Guyer leads MLB with 28 hit-by-pitches, including one Sunday. I want that guy naturally crowding the plate against a right-hander who has struggled to throw strikes.
Almonte took an 89-mph pitch outside and a fastball (96) in the dirt. Dyson threw a fastball (96) running to the outer half, and Almonte popped it to center.
Only Almonte knows why he didn't force Dyson to throw at least one called strike. And Almonte got after a 2-0 pitcher's pitch. Almonte was late enough, and the contact off-barrel enough, that his bottom hand came off the bat near the finish of the swing.
Positive step: Salazar allowed five singles and walked two. He threw 63 of 98 pitches for strikes.
Salazar resembled the pitcher named to the AL All-Star Team, not the one of the past four starts (combined 11 innings, 19 earned runs).
Salazar primarily used a fastball/changeup combination. He mixed in a curve.
Salazar's stuff, and his control/command of it, would have gotten him deep into the game against most MLB teams. The Rangers' "professional'' approaches produced 25 fouls, and a total of six more against relievers Dan Otero and Mike Clevinger.
The Rangers fouled 122 pitches in the series.