The Cleveland Indians' winning streak ended at 14 on Saturday afternoon when the Toronto Blue Jays prevailed, 9-6, in Toronto. The game was wrapped in controversy.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Edwin Encarnacion, Troy Tulowitzki and Josh Donaldson homered and the Toronto Blue Jays were helped by an overturned call en route to defeating the Cleveland Indians, 9-6, Saturday afternoon at Rogers Centre in Toronto. The Tribe's franchise-record winning streak ended at 14 -- but not before left fielder and leadoff man Rajai Davis hit for the cycle.
Here is a capsule look at the key aspect(s) of the game, which was televised by Fox Sports Time Ohio:
Quite a run: The first-place Indians (49-31) had not lost since June 15 against the Royals in Kansas City, Mo.
The Streak began with three-game sweeps of the White Sox and Tampa Bay at Progressive Field. It continued with three-game sweeps in Detroit and Atlanta and victories in the first two of a four-game series at Rogers Centre.
The Indians forced Toronto (44-39) to work for the spoil. They rallied from deficits of 3-1 and 5-3 and grabbed a 6-5 lead in the seventh.
Ragin' Rajai: Davis homered to left in the first; tripled to right in the third; doubled to center in the seventh; and singled to right-center in the ninth. He became the eighth player in franchise history, and first since Travis Hafner on Aug. 14, 2003, to secure the cycle.
He is the first Indian ever, and sixth in MLB history, with a reverse-order cycle.
Davis narrowly missed a fifth hit. With two outs in the fifth inning, Davis grounded to shortstop Tulowitzki, whose throw to first beat Davis by a cleat.
Davis, a former Blue Jay, received a loud ovation after the single. Then Davis stole second -- his 22nd steal this season.
Rough beginning: The Tribe's scheduled starter Saturday was Trevor Bauer, but he became unavailable when manager Terry Francona needed him Friday. Bauer pitched the final five innings and threw 83 pitches in a 2-1 victory in 19 innings. The first 14 innings had been covered by Josh Tomlin and seven relievers.
Even though the rubber-armed Bauer said he would be ready Saturday if asked, he clearly was not an option. Instead, Tribe current relievers and newcomer Shawn Morimando were tasked with piecing together the outing. Lefty Morimando was recalled from Class AA Akron as utility man Michael Martinez was designated for assignment.
Francona opted to "start'' Zach McAllister. It did not go well. McAllister gave up the lead provided by Davis in a hurry.
McAllister overcooked his first pitch, a fastball, and plunked former Indian Ezequiel Carrera on the leg. McAllister struck out Devon Travis and got ahead of 2015 AL MVP Josh Donaldson, 0-2.
Donaldson fouled an 0-2 fastball. McAllister missed with two breaking pitches and two fastballs -- all outside -- for the walk.
Edwin Encarnacion took a fastball (94 mph) up and away and a fastball (94) on the outer edge for a strike. In the 1-1 count, catcher Chris Gimenez appeared to give McAllister the option of breaking pitch or fastball inside before they settled on a fastball away. The pitch looked too much like the previous one, and Encarnacion hammered it to center as Toronto surged ahead, 3-1.
Encarnacion, who has hit 22 homers and leads the American League with 73 RBI, no doubt had been itching to take out his frustration on a baseball for what happened in the first inning Friday. He was ejected by plate umpire Vic Carapazza for reacting angrily after being called out on strikes.
Jeff Manship replaced McAllister to begin the second.
Here they come: The Tribe pulled within 3-2 on Davis' RBI triple in the third and tied the score, 3-3, on Carlos Santana's homer in the fourth. Santana hit an elevated 1-2 fastball for his 18th of the season.
Costly mistake: Tulowitzki's two-out, two-run homer off Morimando in the fifth pushed the Blue Jays back in front, 5-3. Tulowitzki never should have gotten the chance to bat.
With none on and two outs, Russell Martin chopped weakly toward third near the line. Juan Uribe moved in and fielded cleanly but threw low to first baseman Santana, who was unable to scoop the short hop.
Incredibly (or not, given the home-cooked official scoring that occurs in certain venues), Martin was credited with a single. It absolutely was not a single. Uribe did not require extraordinary effort to get to the ball; he simply short-armed a throw into the dirt. As pointed out by Fox Sports Time Ohio analyst Rick Manning, Santana could have helped with better scooping technique -- but because the ball struck the ground, Uribe ultimately is responsible. Martin is not a speedster, so it is not as if he pressured Uribe into rushing the throw. Basic defensive execution would have gotten Martin with room to spare.
Morimando fell behind Tulowitzki, 3-1. Morimando opted for a changeup on the outer half but it stayed up, and Tulowitzki ripped it over the left-field wall.
Morimando finished with the two runs allowed on six hits in 3 2/3 innings. He walked one and struck out four. Hopefully, MLB will overrule the Blue Jays' scorer and change Martin's hit to an error, thereby making both runs unearned.
Her they come again: The Tribe scored once in the sixth (Uribe bases-loaded HBP) and twice with two outs in the seventh (Jose Ramirez RBI single, Mike Napoli RBI double) for the 6-5 lead.
So much for that: Donaldson tied the score in a blink. He led off the seventh with a first-pitch homer (No. 20) to center off Dan Otero.
We've got controversy: The Blue Jays, assisted by replay, scored three in the eighth to put them in front to stay.
Carrera drew a one-out walk against Otero. Tommy Hunter replaced Otero and allowed a single to Devon Travis, Carrera stopping at second. Donaldson blooped a single to center, where Tyler Naquin fielded and made a terrific throw home as Carrera attempted to score. Gimenez received the ball in front of the plate and made a swipe-tag at Carrera, who was diving head-first. Umpire D.J. Reyburn, in excellent position to see everything, called Carrera out.
As expected, Carrera was convinced he was safe. The Blue Jays challenged. After a lengthy delay, crew chief John Hirschbeck removed the headset and signaled that MLB replay command had overturned the call. So instead of runners on first and second, two outs and the score tied, 6-6, the Blue Jays led, 7-6, with one out and runners on first and second.
In real time, Carrera appeared to be safe. But replays showed that it was entirely possible for Gimenez's mitt to have clipped Carrera's flapping pants at the right shin a frame before Carrera's left batting glove touched the plate.
At the very least, the replays were inconclusive, which should have meant the call on the field stood.
Francona had every right to be upset.
"I looked at (the play) six or seven times,'' Francona calmly told reporters in Toronto, via Fox Sports Time Ohio, after the game. "I came in and looked at all the angles. They're supposed to have the same angles we do. I don't know how you can overrule that. If they called him safe, I don't know how you overrule it. If they called him out, I don't know how you overrule it. I know they keep telling us: 'It has to be conclusive.' I will look forward to an explanation from the league that I understand, because, as of now, from what I've seen, I don't know how they did that. I was shocked.''
With Encarnacion at bat, Travis and Donaldson executed a double-steal. Encarnacion struck out. Lefty Michael Saunders ran into a 1-1 fastball -- his reaction immediately after having made contact spoke volumes -- and lined a two-run double to left.