Homers by Mike Napoli and Yan Gomes gave the Indians a 3-2 lead, but the White Sox hammered out five runs against Bryan Shaw in the seventh to win Saturday's game in a romp.
CLEVELAND, Ohio - The Indians put on a defensive clinic Friday against the White Sox at U.S. Cellular Field. On Saturday, they auditioned for an MLB Bloopers film to enterain fans during rain delays.
It was just another example that when it's 32 degrees outside baseball is a hard game to play. Still, as former Tribe manager Doc Edwards once said, "Victory is a sponge that soaks up all sins."
The chance for victory flashed in front of the Indians like the bright sunshine that filled the frigid ballpark all day. But then it was gone just as quickly in Chicago's 7-3 victory.
The Indians looked frozen in their tracks through five innings. Left-hander Chris Sale had a 2-0 lead with two out in the sixth. He'd retired 12 straight when Francisco Lindor reached on a harmless single to the hole at short.
Lindor's single grew fangs when Mike Napoli followed with a homer to center to pull the Indians into a 2-2 tie. When Yan Gomes started the seventh with his first homer of the season, the Indians had their first lead of the game.
But Bryan Shaw, starting the seventh in relief of Cody Anderson, allowed five runs on four hits while registering just two outs. Avisail Garcia ended Shaw's painful appearance with a three-run homer.
The Indians' defense improved dramatically last year. It's silly to say one bad game means that was a mirage. Especially after they did so many good things in Friday's 7-1 victory.
Tribe's defense shines on cold day in Chicago
The bullpen, well, that just might be a different story. Shaw has been a cornerstone of manager Terry Francona's pen for the last three years. He's been closer Cody Allen's set-up man for the last two years. In the process he's made a lot of appearances. To be exact, he entered the season with a major-league high 224 trips to the mound over the last three years. Could that be catching up to him?
In his first appearance of the season on Wednesday, Shaw was sharp in a 7-6 win over Boston. Such was not the case Saturday.
Austin Jackson started the seventh with a single. Jimmy Rollins doubled him to third and Jose Abreu, who hit his 12th career homer against the Indians in the third, was intentionally walked.
Todd Frazier scored Jackson with the tying run on a force at second that Jason Kipnis held instead of going to first for the double play. Melky Cabrera, after a 10-pitch at-bat, singled to right to put the White Sox ahead, 4-3. After Brett Lawrie flied out, Garcia homered to right.
Shaw usually pitches the eighth with Zach McAllister handling the seventh. With the top of Chicago's lineup due to bat in the seventh, Francona told reporters in Chicago that he felt Shaw matched up better against those hitters than McAllister. After Garcia's three-run homer, McAllister relieved to get the final out of the inning.
Don't tell Bryan Shaw he's unavailable
The Indians made three errors, one each by center fielder Rajai Davis, Anderson and third baseman Juan Uribe. Anderson added two wild pitches not to mention bad throws by Kipnis and Napoli to scuttle potential double plays.
The quick hands of Lindor saved Kipnis and Napoli from errors as he recorded outs at second base in the second and fourth innings. In the third, Cabrera hit a foul ball behind first base. Napoli drifted back, Kipnis drifted over from second. Then they turned and started at each other as the ball fell between them.
There was no damage done as Cabrera popped up to short. Unfortunately for the Indians there was more than enough damage done before and after that play.
Anderson, under the conditions, pitched well in his first start of the season. He allowed two runs on six hits in six innings.
Thursday conversation with Cody Anderson
He made a mistake against Abreu in the third when he threw him a high first-pitch fastball. Abreu drove it into the seats in left center field for a 1-0 lead. He's not the first Indians' pitcher to do that against Abreu and he won't be the last.
Chicago's other run against Anderson came in the fourth when Alex Avila's single skipped past Davis in center as Garcia to scored from second base for a 2-0 lead.