The Indians optioned TJ House to Class AAA Columbus, which cleared the way for Josh Tomlin and Cody Anderson to decide the fifth spot in the starting rotation.
CLEVELAND, Ohio - Spring training is a strange time of year. The clock is always running and good performances do not always lead to good news.
Left-hander TJ House threw four scoreless innings Sunday as the Indians beat Seattle, 10-5. It was House's best performance of the spring.
Monday morning House was called to manager Terry Francona's office and told he was being optioned to Class AAA Columbus. House's demotion means the competition for the fifth spot in the starting rotation is down to Josh Tomlin and Cody Anderson.
When Francona tells a player he's being sent to the minors, he sometimes asks, "Are you able to sit here and process this for the next five or 10 minutes? Because sometimes all a guy hears is that he's being sent down."
House said he was able to keep a clear head.
"I know this isn't what guys want to hear when they come to camp, but he was pretty realistic," Francona told reporters Monday morning in Goodyear, Ariz. "I showed him the board (roster) and told him, 'You missed so much time last year and when you look at the board it's hard to jump you ahead of those guys.'"
House made the Tribe's opening day rotation last year. He came down with a sore left shoulder and pitched only 37 innings in the big leagues and minors.
The Indians rotation is the strength of the team. The top four starters are going to be Corey Kluber, Carlos Carrasco, Danny Salazar and Trevor Bauer. The fifth spot will be decided between Tomlin and Anderson. House, working on his last minor league option, has to be wondering where he fits.
Francona told him, "If you do what you do -- you've pitched for us before and that was plenty good enough - you can do that again. And I fully believe that. I think he does to.
"I told him he's done a really good job of getting back to where he needs to be. I give him credit for being smart enough to see the bigger picture."
Francona says House's breaking ball, which looked good Sunday, still needs work.
"There is some rust he has to shake off," said Francona. "He needs to find some consistency. It was nice to see him throw like he did Sunday. We've seen when he's good what he can do."
Francona gave Tomlin a vote of confidence Sunday for the fifth spot. Tomlin can pitch out of the bullpen and rotation, but Francona said the Indians prefer him to start.
Kluber in control, Tomlin gets vote of confidence
In an interesting development, Tomlin and Anderson are trying to solve the same problem despite their different pitching styles. Last year Tomlin's average fastball was 88.4 mph. Anderson's fastball averaged 92.2 mph.
This spring they are both throwing harder. Tomlin is pitching healthy following spring-training surgery on his right shoulder in 2015. Anderson has reshaped his body, flexibility and strength through two years of training. This spring he's been throwing between 95 mph and 97 mph.
Francona said Tomlin has a new gear that he's still coming to terms with.
"Josh isn't throwing now trying to find an arm slot where it doesn't hurt," said Francona. "He's letting it go and sometimes he's got to remind himself who he is."
Regarding Anderson, Francona said he's learning to throw at his new velocity. Anderson told one reporter that he feels like a "baby horse who is still learning how to run."
Said Francona, "It's more like a baby bull."
How Tomlin and Anderson control their new found velocity will go a long way in determining their success this season.
Testing, testing: Asked what the Indians want to see out of Marlon Byrd in the last two weeks of spring training, Francona said, "I couldn't tell you one thing. We don't need to see him hit a home run. This is going to be hard one. We're balancing not trying to do too much too quick."
Byrd asked Francona if he wanted him to play in a minor league game on Tuesday. It's the Indians only off day this spring and Francona told him no.
"I felt a day away would probably be good for him," said Francona.
Byrd, who played Sunday against Seattle, started against Chicago on Monday and doubled in his first two at-bats. The Indians signed Byrd on Friday to a minor league deal.
Tribe signs Byrd to minor league deal
"Our goal will be to get the best evaluation we can," said Francona. "It's going to be hard unless something jumps out one way or the other."