A Columbus request for $5 million in taxpayer dollars to build a new training camp complex in Columbus for the Browns caused a stir. But the team has been talking for a year about a deal with Columbus.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Browns fan were flummoxed last week to hear Columbus had requested $5 million in state tax money to host the Browns training camp.
They shouldn't have been.
Any move is particularly touchy for fans who still bear the scars of the old Browns abandoning Cleveland and moving to Baltimore. And the potential for use of taxpayer dollars stirred passions more. But team owner Jimmy Haslam has talked openly about the idea for more than a year -- and been in talks with Columbus leaders for even longer.
Indeed, Berea Mayor Cyril Kleem said last week that the Browns have been open about their desire to move camp.
"They told us this could happen. They haven't done anything to us that's underhanded and it's no surprise they may relocate to Columbus in 2017," Kleem told 92.3 FM last week. "I'm not crazy about it, but it's not like the Browns are moving their headquarters. That's not the case."
So what do you want to know?
How long have the Browns had an eye on Columbus?
The Browns have been strengthening ties with Columbus since Alec Scheiner was named team president in December 2012. Haslam has had business dealings with Alex Fischer, president and CEO of the Columbus Partnership.
In August, when the Browns played an intra-squad scrimmage at Ohio Stadium, sources said Columbus officials were confident of wooing the Browns, though it might take up to six months to announce the deal. Haslam said then the negotiations had been ongoing for a year.
"Alec Scheiner has continued to work with the people in Columbus, and I think there's still some details to work out," Haslam said then. "We're excited about going down to Columbus and letting our fans in the middle part of the state come see us scrimmage."
After the scrimmage, which with 50,000 fans drew the biggest intra-scrimmage crown in a decade, Haslam said Columbus was great.
"I think it has been good for our guys to get away from Berea for a couple days. A little different scenario," he said. "And to play in front of 45, 50 thousand people is fun whether you're a veteran or a young person."
Previous coverage: Columbus officials hoping for a five- to 10-year commitment to host Cleveland Browns' training camp
Why is Columbus attractive for the Browns?
Columbus is the nation's 15th largest city. With surrounding Franklin County, the area is about the same size as Cuyahoga County. And more potential fans live just beyond in adjoining counties.
The area also is a battleground of sorts.
The Browns are among four NFL franchises competing for fans in Columbus, which has NHL and pro soccer teams. The area is on the fringes of fan bases for the Cincinnati Bengals, Pittsburgh Steelers and Indianapolis Colts.
Expanding the team's fan base would also allow the Browns to tap into the Columbus corporate community.
Where would the training facility be built?
Neither Ohio State University nor the Columbus Partnership were available to comment Monday about where the athletic facility might go.
Fischer, of the Columbus Partnership, has said that an official site has not been decided.
Speculation, though, is that the facility would be built near Ohio State University's West Campus, west of Ohio Stadium.
OSU's College of Agriculture still has large fields of open land in that area. It also has easy access to Ohio 315, a freeway that links the Interstate 270 outerbelt in the north with downtown and I-70 and I-71 in the south.
At one point last year, talk included Columbus Crew soccer stadium and open property around it's home near I-71, Mapfre Stadium. That would have involved property adjacent to the Ohio Expo Center and appears to have fallen through.
Does the move stand a chance?
Probably. But getting taxpayer money is probably a tough sell.
Fischer told The Columbus Dispatch he would have preferred that the Browns make an announcement first, but that the submission was needed for a shot at capital improvement money.
Lawmakers will debate the capital improvements bill this spring.
House Speaker Cliff Rosenberger, through a spokesman, said he was "most concerned" with what legislators think about the request.
"As we have seen over the past few days, there are obviously strong feelings on this topic, so it is important that everyone's concerns are taken into consideration and that all projects are properly vetted throughout the spring," spokesman Brad Miller said in an email.
State Rep. Michael Dovilla, a Berea Republican with some clout in the House, said he already has contacted Rosenberger.
"I am vigorously opposing the Columbus Partnership's capital appropriations request that would use taxpayer dollars to poach economic development from Greater Cleveland to elsewhere in Ohio."
It's hard to imagine the item would survive Gov. John Kasich's line item veto pen if it looks like it pits one city's interests against another.
Could the Browns move without taxpayer money?
Theoretically, yes, although if OSU is a partner in the project the public university almost certainly would have some money invested.
The Browns on Monday reaffirmed that the team has not asked for public money. The request for money in the capital budget came from the Columbus Partnership, not the team.
In a statement Thursday the team said it would "incur all the costs associated with moving and holding our operations at a remote site."
In a column last week supporting the move, The Dispatch's Michael Arace noted that Haslam is due to get between $17 million and $36.6 million for his share of relocation fees put up by the St. Louis Rams and the Oakland Raiders and/or the San Diego Chargers.
The NFL intends to charge a $550 million moving fee to any teams that move to Los Angeles.
When could the team make a move?
In the team statement, the Browns confirmed the team would remain in Berea for this year's training camp. The team said decision would be made based on what was best for football operations and winning.
Last year Haslam said that a move was unlikely before 2017 and that the team would continue to hold its practices in Berea.