Browns quarterback Johnny Manziel has been demoted to 3rd string. Josh McCown is the starter going forward. Watch video
BEREA, Ohio -- Mike Pettine demoted Johnny Manziel from Browns starting quarterback to No. 3 in the span of a week after reviewing the film.
But it wasn't the kind of film any head coach wants to see.
Pettine benched his 2014 first-round pick after video surfaced on Monday of Manziel partying over the weekend in Austin, Tex.
The video was taken three days after Manziel was named the starter for the final six games of the season, and after Pettine sat him down and gave him a stern warning to behave off the field -- especially during the five days off for the bye weekend.
But Manziel partied it up on Thursday and Friday nights, and then tried to pass off the video as old on Monday when asked about it at the Greater Cleveland Food Bank, where he was volunteering.
"It was something that we felt had violated the trust that we had put in him before the bye coming out of the Pittsburgh game and it was a decision we made as a result of it,'' Pettine told the Cleveland Browns radio network Tuesday.
Josh McCown, who threw for a franchise-record 457 yards in a 33-30 overtime victory over the Ravens on Oct. 11, will start against them again on Monday night football at FirstEnergy Stadium and will be the starter 'going forward.' Austin Davis will be back him up, and Manziel will probably not even dress for the game.
"I informed the quarterbacks of that decision after I sat down and spoke with Johnny, Flip (John DeFilippo) and Kevin (O'Connell) after practice today,'' Pettine said in a statement. "Johnny will be the third quarterback. I've spoken to Ray (Farmer) and Jimmy (Haslam) to inform them of my decision, and they are in full support.''
Pettine stressed in the statement that Manziel's talk is still cheap, just like it was all of last season. Only this season, Manziel was fresh off 10 weeks in an addiction treatment center and the Browns hoped things would be different.
"Everyone in this organization wants what is best for Johnny just like we do for every player in our locker room,'' Pettine said in the statement. "I'm especially disappointed in his actions and behavior because he has been working very hard. The improvements from last year to this year have been tremendous, but he still has to consistently demonstrate that he has gained a good understanding of what it takes to be successful at the quarterback position on this level.
"It goes well beyond the field. We are going to continue to support him in every way possible, but at this point, we've decided it's best to go with Josh as the starter going forward."
Manziel's benching means that the Browns might not have another chance to evaluate him this season as their possible quarterback of the future. It also means they'll have to look long and hard at selecting a quarterback high in the draft. As it stands, the 2-8 Browns have one of the top three picks in the draft and a clear shot at one of the premier prospects.
The decision to demote him all the way to No. 3 could mean the Browns have reached the end of their rope with Manziel and that they're ready to move on at some point in the near future.
If they don't cut him -- which seems unlikely during the next six games -- they could always hang on and see if someone is willing to trade for him.
But the demotion is a stunning turnaround from last week, when the Browns handed Manziel the reins and gave him a chance to prove that he's their quarterback of the future.
"(It's) disappointing -- very,'' said Pettine after practice but before he made the decision. "I can't stand here and say it's not whatever word we want to use - disappointing, frustrating."
Pettine got Manziel's version of the story on Monday night, and then met with him again on Tuesday after practice, along with DeFilippo and O'Connell. Pettine also talked to Haslam and Farmer before making his decision, and again after.
"It's all part of the frustration, the disappointment,'' said Pettine of Manziel's pattern of missteps. "When the behavior repeats, it's certainly a cause for concern.''
Pettine acknowledged that his warning to Manziel about not messing up once he handed him the job factored in.
"The conversations that we had, it adds to it,'' he said.
It remains to be seen if Manziel will check back into rehab again. Sources close to Manziel believe he's relapsed from his program of sobriety. The partying videos are the latest in a long string of incidents for the troubled quarterback.
The day he was named the starter last Tuesday, he was also cleared by the NFL of domestic violence during his Oct. 12 roadway incident with his girlfriend, Colleen Crowley. But he admitted to drinking that afternoon, which sent up a red flag for the Browns organization.
Two weekends ago, during a mini-bye after the Bengals game, Manziel was splashed all over social media partying back at Texas A&M, a series of photos which the Browns also found disturbing. Manziel also threw a water bottle toward a fan at a golf tournament in May, and police were called to the scene.
Manziel's benching was also foreshadowed on the team's in-house radio show, Cleveland Browns Daily. The co-hosts, Nathan Zegura and Matt Wilhelm, harshly criticized Manziel in the two shows leading up to the move, saying the party video was a slap in the face to the organization.
Bustedcoverage.com first published the video that was posted on DJ LX's Instagram account of Manziel partying at the Summit Rooftop Lounge on Friday night in Austin. The video shows Manziel holding a bottle of what looks like champagne and singing and dancing in the DJ booth. The caption on the Instagram read, "Sippin on Dom Perignon for no reason with Johnny Manziel.''
Another Instagram photo of him at Austin's RIO rooftop lounge was published on Thursday night. A source confirmed for cleveland.com that Manziel was at RIO on Friday.
Later Monday afternoon, after DJ LX removed the video from his Instagram account and made his account private, TMZ Sports published a story saying that it had obtained its own footage of Manziel partying at Summit Friday night. The site said multiple witnesses saw Manziel "boozing'' at the clubs on back-to-back nights.
While volunteering at the Greater Cleveland Food Bank on Monday, Manziel wouldn't admit he was partying in Austin and tried to pass the video off as so yesterday.
"You know there's all kinds of people that come out,'' he said. "Videos can be old. Videos can be all kinds of different things. So like I said, I'm not in a state to be able to speak on it because my focus has been on this today and what really matters in this game on Monday. So that's where my focus has been. I did get a chance to relax. So I haven't seen anything like that, and I'm not going to be able to speculate on it right now."
Asked specifically Monday if the video was old, Manziel said, "I haven't seen it, so I can't speak on it."
The song that Manziel was singing in the video, March Madness by Future, came out in mid-March, when Manziel was in rehab at the Caron addiction treatment center. Even if the video was old, it still occurred after he left rehab for an unspecified addiction.
"I've been here for this (volunteer) event, and that's really what I want to talk about, the things that are really important, not what I'm doing off the field,'' he said Monday. "It's what we're doing here in the community and what we're doing to get ready for this game on Monday night. So that's where my focus is, and I haven't had my focus anywhere else. I know that."
Manziel only acknowledged that he went home to Texas and returned to Ohio Saturday morning and attended the OSU-Michigan State football game.
"The bye week was great,'' he said. "I got a chance to go to see the Ohio State-Michigan State game. For all of the Ohio people, I don't think it went as well as they would've liked to but I got a chance to go back home for a little bit and come back early on Saturday and just get a chance to start looking over for the game and watched Baltimore play and obviously get kind of a jump on them and come here today and do this. I was very excited to do that.''
Manziel noted that he returned to Ohio a few days early, like he said he would. The players had five days off, from Thursday through Monday.
"(I was) able to come back early on Saturday, see a cool game and then get to spend some time getting ready for the week and for the game on (Monday) which is obviously going to be really big,'' he said. "I think this will be my first night game at FirstEnergy other than a preseason game since I've been here, so really looking forward to seeing what the atmosphere's going to be like, especially for a Monday night game.
"I'm pumped. I'm looking forward to this week of prep, getting a chance to get a day off on Thanksgiving. So much to be thankful for but it's a big week and I'm very excited to be back here and ready to go.''
Manziel promised Pettine before he left for the bye weekend that he wouldn't make headlines during the five days off.
"I let him know that I'm not going to do anything that's going to be a distraction to this team or be an embarrassment to the organization,'' Manziel said before leaving town. "I'm going to get a chance to go and relax like everybody else in this locker room is. I don't think they're going to have to worry about me this week."
Unfortunately for everyone involved, they did. And now, Manziel's career with the Browns could be almost over.