After Week 4, the Northeast Ohio Media Group high school sports staff is unanimous this as to which football team deserves the top spot in the cleveland.com high school football Top 25.
CLEVELAND, Ohio – The Northeast Ohio Media Group high school sports staff is unanimous this week as to which football team deserves the top spot in the cleveland.com high school football Top 25.
Medina enters the poll for the first time this year, receiving a vote from every high school staffer who submitted a ballot.
Voters are Tim Bielik, Nathaniel Cline, Matt Goul, Joe Noga, Scott Patsko and Rob Rozboril. Below are individual ballots for each voter, as well as an explanation for some of their decisions.
Share your take and/or your Top 25 in the comments section below.
Bielik's ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Mentor, 3. St. Ignatius, 4. Midview, 5. Benedictine, 6. Berea-Midpark, 7. Glenville, 8. Mayfield, 9. Stow, 10. Archbishop Hoban, 11. Avon, 12. Brecksville, 13. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 14. Maple Heights, 15. Aurora, 16. Solon, 17. Hudson, 18. Nordonia, 19. Bedford, 20. Strongsville, 21. Chardon, 22. North Olmsted, 23. Lake Catholic, 24. Perry, 25. Medina.
Bielik's ballot explanation
One week after St. Edward moved to No. 1 in the Top 25, I have the Eagles standing atop my ballot. They bounced back from their loss very well with a strong showing against Cincinnati Elder and thus have earned the right to move to the top. Mentor and St. Ignatius stay in the top three for the moment although the Cardinals fell behind early against Euclid and the Wildcats struggled at St. Joseph's Prep. But if there was a big gap between the Wildcats and No. 4 Midview, it's almost razor thin right now. The Middies are playing extremely well and have a strong defense to go with their potent offense. If they can keep this play up, they could make it all the way to Columbus in December. Avon is one of the biggest droppers following its loss to Midview, falling five spots to No.11. The Eagles have some concerns to address on defense after giving up 95 points in their last two games. Hudson vaults three spots up in the poll to No. 17, jumping ahead of Nordonia after beating the Knights in Week 4. Hudson's defense has been tough all season and it should only see two more tough tests this season. The newest member of the top 25 may be one of the biggest surprises in Medina. Coach Dan Sutherland deserves a lot of credit for leading the Bees to a 3-1 start after winning just two games in all of 2014. Medina RB Jimmy Daw may be one of the best players nobody talks about.
Cline's ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Mentor, 3. St. Ignatius, 4. Midview, 5. Benedictine, 6. Berea-Midpark, 7. Mayfield, 8. Avon, 9. Archbishop Hoban, 10. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 11. Glenville, 12. Stow, 13. Brecksville, 14. Maple Heights, 15. Aurora, 16. Hudson, 17. Strongsville, 18. Madison, 19. Solon, 20. Lake Catholic, 21. Medina, 22. Elyria, 23. Perry, 24. Nordonia, 25. North Olmsted.
Cline’s ballot explanation
The theme this week is high risk, high reward, and the defenses and special teams listed on my ballot helped make a strong case. Last week, there was a clerical error with me voting Benedictine ahead of Midview. With quarterback Dustin Crum at the helm behind a stout group of linemen, I favor the Middies’ offense. Hoban and St. Vincent-St. Mary moved up in my top 10, because, on average, they don’t allow a lot of points compared to previous top 10 members Glenville (22.5) and Stow (21.5). However when these teams give up points, they also have a high-risk reward that has kept them above the .500 mark. Moving down my ballot, a lot of shuffling took place after reviewing the points allowed by each team, and some teams gave up a lot more points than others. Medina earned a spot after topping Elyria last week, 31-14.Two notable moves for me were Strongsville moving up three spots and Bedford moving off my ballot. Strongsville is another rare case of high-risk reward, giving up a little more than 18 points per game. Bedford has shut out its last two opponents, but gets bumped off my ballot to make room for Medina. The Bearcats will surly return should they continue at this pace.
Goul’s ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Benedictine, 3. Midview, 4. Mentor, 5. Berea-Midpark, 6. Mayfield, 7. Archbishop Hoban, 8. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 9. St. Ignatius, 10. Glenville, 11. Stow, 12. Brecksville, 13. Maple Heights, 14. Avon, 15. Aurora, 16. Solon, 17. Bedford, 18. Strongsville, 19. Hudson, 20. Medina, 21. Elyria, 22. Perry, 23. Copley, 24. Madison, 25. Chardon.
Goul’s ballot explanation
In some ways, this week’s vote is much more interesting (and fun) than last week. The deeper we get into the season, the more on-field analysis and debate factors into these rankings than what’s on paper. The most notable drop is either Mentor or St. Ignatius. Mentor’s fall of just one spot has more to do with Midview’s impressive win, jumping out to a 28-0 lead on Avon. St. Ignatius drops just below St. Vincent-St. Mary for me, which gets to an interesting dilemma. I think Ignatius beats St. Vincent-St. Mary head-to-head, but two more losses is enough for me to give a nod to the Fighting Irish. Since I’m new to the poll this year and some have asked for an unbeaten to be No. 1, I am compelled to explain my general thinking. If St. Edward loses a second game, I would rank the Eagles below undefeated teams in the top 10. Might think the Eagles are better, but you could say I grade on a two-loss curve. The Wildcats could have dropped to 13 for me, but St. Joe's Prep is Pennsylvania's defending Class AAAA champion (D-I equivalent) and ranked No. 2 in that state last I checked. My watch list includes: Nordonia, Lorain and Elyria Catholic.
Noga's ballot
1. St. Edward; 2. Mentor; 3. Midview; 4. Benedictine; 5. St. Ignatius; 6. Berea-Midpark; 7. Stow; 8. Mayfield; 9. Brecksville; 10. Avon; 11. Glenville; 12. Archbishop Hoban; 13. St. Vincent-St. Mary; 14. Aurora; 15. Maple Heights; 16. Nordonia; 17. Bedford; 18. Solon; 19. Notre Dame-Cathedral Latin; 20. Strongsville; 21. Perry; 22. Madison; 23. Elyria; 24. Hudson; 25. North Olmsted.
Noga's ballot explanation
Midview breaks up the big-school party at the top of my ballot by checking in at No. 3 after a convincing win against Avon. St. Ignatius, which opened the season at No. 1, tumbles to No. 5. The Wlldcats must once again overcome key injuries and quickly find answers on defense if they are going to qualify for the Division I playoffs this season. Berea-Midpark, Stow and Mayfield each move up one spot and Avon slips to No. 10. Notre Dame-Cathedral Latin, unbeaten at 4-0, jumps to No. 19. The Lions, under first-year coach Andrew Mooney will get a tough road test against Division V state runner-up Canton Central Catholic on Friday. Kenston and Lake Catholic fall off my ballot this week after losses, while wins by Hudson and North Olmsted put those schools back in my Top 25.
Patsko’s ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Mentor, 3. Midview 4. St. Ignatius, 5. Benedictine, 6. Berea-Midpark, 7. Stow, 8. Mayfield, 9. Archbishop Hoban, 10. Avon, 11. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 12. Glenville, 13. Brecksville, 14. North Olmsted, 15. Maple Heights, 16. Aurora, 17. Strongsville, 18. Hudson, 19. Nordonia, 20. Medina, 21. Lake Catholic, 22. Highland, 23. Solon, 24. Bedford, 25. Elyria.
Patsko’s ballot explanation
My top five teams see some changes this week. St. Edward solidified its spot at the top of my ballot with an impressive win against Cincinnati Elder. Mentor isn’t making it easy to keep it in the top three. When I heard the Mentor-Euclid halftime score (19-17, Euclid) I had to ask for it to be repeated. But the Cardinals won, so they stay put. The changes come at Nos. 3-5. St. Ignatius slides a spot due to a jump from No. 7 to No. 3 by Midview. The Middies have impressed and should be higher than I’ve had them. St. Ignatius lost on the road to two-time defending Pennsylvania big-school state champ St. Joseph Prep. No shame in that, but at 2-2 and with defensive issues, the Wildcats take a step back. I want the teams at the top of my ballot to be the ones winning playoff games in November. I still think the Wildcats will be one of those teams. But, boy, they’re running out of options to gain computer points. Avon drops from the top five after needing three OTs to beat North Olmsted, then getting routed by Midview. The other big change this week is Medina entering at No. 20 and Elyria falling to No. 25 after the Bees’ 31-14 win on Friday.
Rozboril's ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Midview, 3. Benedictine, 4. Mentor, 5. St. Ignatius, 6. Berea-Midpark, 7. Glenville, 8. Mayfield, 9. Stow, 10. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 11. Avon, 12. Brecksville, 13. Maple Heights, 14. Bedford, 15. Hoban, 16. Aurora, 17. North Olmsted, 18. Hudson, 19. Nordonia, 20. Solon, 21. Strongsville, 22. Perry, 23. Madison, 24. Medina, 25. Highland.
Rozboril's ballot explanation
St. Edward takes the top spot in my poll this week after an impressive win against Elder while Mentor had to rally to beat Euclid. I gave the Cardinals the benefit of the doubt last week after their major loss against St. Xavier but feel they should have been able to rebound and beat Euclid easily. Their inability to do so is why I have them slipping to No. 4 while St. Ignatius, coming off a blowout loss to St. Joseph Regional (N.J.), slides to No. 5. Midview and Benedictine get Top 3 votes from me this week. Midview's passing game proved superior to that of Avon and the Bengals defeated University School by a significant margin, which given the way Benedictine has played all season is how that game should have turned out. I expect both teams to continue to prove they deserve high praise the rest of the season. North Olmsted moves back a couple spots after barely squeaking past unranked Westlake. Hudson jumps up to No. 18 with a win against Nordonia which falls to No. 19 in my ballot. Elyria falls off my ballot this week and the team that handed the Pioneers their first loss, Medina, enters at No. 24, ahead of Highland which I have still holding on at No. 25.
Follow our high school sports Twitter account @NEOvarsity and tag your high school sports Tweets and score updates with the #NEOVarsity hashtag.