Cleveland Browns coach Mike Pettine owes a lot to Rex Ryan, but Pettine also had to break away.
PITTSFORD, N.Y. -- Something to think about: Rex Ryan was the coach of the New York Jets from 2009-14. In that same six-year period, the Browns had four head coaches.
Ryan became the Jets head coach in 2009. His defensive coordinator was Mike Pettine, the current Browns head coach.
Ryan was 9-7 and 11-5 in his first two years. He lost in the AFC championship both years.
That bought him time, even in New York. In the next four seasons, Ryan was 8-8, 6-10, 8-8 and 4-12. No playoff appearances. By the time he was fired, it was obvious things had fallen apart for Ryan in New York.
Buffalo turned to Ryan, giving him a five-year, $27 million contract.
That lucrative contract came after a 4-12 season -- and after four years without a winning record or a playoff appearance. He left New York with a 46-50 overall record.
Pettine often talks about how this is a "What have you done for me lately?" league.
That didn't exactly apply to Ryan, who was granted patience even in ever-anxious New York, thanks to the success in his first two seasons.
But patience has rarely been a gift to most Browns coaches. Consider this lineup of Cleveland head coaches during Ryan's six seasons in New York:
- Eric Mangini (2009-10): He came here after he was fired by the Jets and replaced by Ryan. Record: 10-22.
- Pat Shurmur (2011-12): He was hired by team president Mike Holmgren. After the 2012 season, the entire Holmgren front office and coaching staff was fired by new owner Jimmy Haslam. Record: 9-23.
- Rob Chudzinski (2013): He was fired after a 4-12 season.
- Mike Pettine (2014-current): He had a 7-9 season, the best record of any Browns head coach since Romeo Crennel was 10-6 in 2007. But he lost the final five games of the season, leaving many question marks about a possible improvement in 2015.
MOVING UP THE RANKS
When the Browns and Bills practiced together at St. John Fisher College this week, I asked Ryan about Pettine.
"I knew he'd get to this spot," said Ryan.
He meant that Pettine would one day be a head coach in the NFL.
"Our backgrounds are very similar," added Ryan. "Both our dads are legendary coaches."
That's true, to an extent.
Buddy Ryan was a famous defensive coordinator with Chicago and Houston. He also was the head coach in Philadelphia and Arizona. Rex Ryan seemed have inside passage to the NFL.
Mike Pettine Sr. was the winningest high school coach in Pennsylvania history when he retired in 1999. He had a 327-42-4 record with four state titles for Central Bucks High School outside of Philadelphia.
Pettine's pedigree was a path to good high school positions. He spent 10 years as a high school coach -- but not the NFL.
That's why their two careers eventually went in different directions.
JUST A HIGH SCHOOL COACH
In 2002, Pettine begged his way into a spot as a video assistant with the Baltimore Ravens. He took a massive pay cut from a high school coaching job for an entry level spot in the NFL. He did it at the age of 35.
Rex Ryan was the defensive line coach with the Ravens. Members of the Ravens front office told me how Pettine made himself valuable to Ryan, because Ryan had trouble learning all the new computer systems that were becoming part of the modern NFL.
Pettine was hungry to learn anything that would keep him in the league, and he embraced the technological advances. The two men soon became friends. They had the same defensive-minded view of the game.
Pettine always had more to prove in the NFL than Ryan.
"Being 'Just a high school coach' always drove me," said Pettine.
Suddenly, Pettine found himself embraced by a member of one of the NFL's royal families. As Rex Ryan rose from defensive line coach to defensive coordinator, Pettine went up with him.
It was the best way for a former high school coach to establish himself in the NFL. He needed someone with credibility to be his mentor.
"(Mike) is smart and knows the game extremely well," said Ryan. "He's hard working, dedicated and passionate. So I knew he'd get an opportunity (to be a head coach)."
NEW YORK, NEW YORK
When Ryan was hired as the head coach of the Jets in 2009, he brought along Pettine. Suddenly, the former high school coach was now a defensive coordinator in the NFL.
When the Jets had those two trips to the AFC title game in the 2009 and 2010 seasons, they had a rugged defense.
But the credit for it went to Ryan. There were whispers that Pettine was not fully the coordinator. Supposedly, Ryan's fingerprints were all over the game plans and his booming voice was the heartbeat of one of the NFL's top defenses.
That may have been the case in Pettine's first year. But Ryan gave him far more control after that.
Nicholas Dawidoff wrote a superb book about the 2012 Jets called COLLISON LOW CROSSERS.
Pettine receives nearly as much attention from the author as Ryan. Dawidoff was granted complete access by the team, and spent a lot of time in Pettine's defensive meetings.
By 2012, Pettine was the pulse of the defense.
Ryan is criticized by the author for taking a very low-key, almost distant approach with all of the assistant coaches. Ryan had become a celebrity, and seemed to have lost some of the drive that made him effective early in his career.
THE BREAKUP
By 2012, Pettine knew it was time for him to leave Ryan.
Like Ryan, he is a very ambitious man. And like Ryan, the blood of a head coach pumps through his veins. After 10 years together, these two men who had taken family vacations together knew it was time to part.
"He wanted to be a head coach in this league and sometimes, rightly or wrongly, they're going to attach everything we do defensively to me," Ryan told reporters in 2013. That was when Pettine left Ryan to become the defensive coordinator in Buffalo. Ryan talked about how Pettine needed to "get out and make (his own) name."
In his book, Dawidoff wrote, "For Pettine, the Bills were his opportunity to become his own coaching man, to show he could run a first-rate defense without Ryan."
Pettine said Sunday it was "just time" for him to leave the Jets. Dawidoff's book indicated there was a distance growing between Ryan and Pettine. Ten years together was enough.
Ryan did Pettine a major favor. He allowed Pettine to take Jets assistants Jim O'Neil and Anthony Weaver to Buffalo. They are now members Pettine's staff in Cleveland.
In 2013, Ryan had an 8-8 record. Pettine's Buffalo defensive ranked No. 10 and set a franchise record for sacks. The Bills defense was No. 22 in 2012.
The move to Buffalo put Pettine in position to interview for the Browns job. That never would have happened had he remained in New York with Ryan.
In 2014, Pettine became the head coach of the Browns. Ryan's Jets were 4-12, and he was fired.
STARTING OVER
So Ryan and Pettine will face each other for the first time as head coaches in Thursday's preseason game.
Just as Pettine left the Jets for Buffalo as a way to pump more life into his career, Buffalo became the landing pad for Ryan after he was dropped by the Jets.
Ryan told me how both men "build teams the same way." He meant based on rugged defenses and a powerful running game.
Pettine joked Sunday that the two men "have had conversations before, asking who has the bigger curse on quarterbacks."
Both men were frustrated over the years in New York with the inconsistency and lack of development of quarterback Mark Sanchez.
Ryan will start Tyrod Taylor against the Browns. Taylor threw only 35 regular season passes as a backup for Baltimore from 2011-14. The Bills also have veteran Matt Cassel and 2013 first-round pick E.J. Manuel as quarterback options.
Ryan doesn't seem to know who will be his starter.
Pettine is starting 36-year-old journeyman Josh McCown. The coach is trying to help Johnny Manziel find his spot in the NFL, at least as a viable backup with the potential to eventually start.
THE BIG CHALLENGE
Ryan has at least a few years to make it work in Buffalo. That's the blessing of his lucrative five-year contract.
While there is reason to believe Jimmy Haslam is sincere when he says he does want to "blow up" the front office and coaching staff, Pettine is still proving himself in his second season. He doesn't have Ryan's pedigree or early record of success.
"Our relationship hasn't changed," said Pettine. "It was good then and it's good now... he'll be a friend until I take my last breath."
But now that they are apart, both men are re-creating themselves. They are doing it in two football-crazy cities with frustrated fan bases. The Browns have been to the playoffs only twice since 1990 (1994 and 2002). The Bills last playoff appearance was 1999.
Neither is expected to make the postseason in 2015. The "quarterback curse" is the main reason for skepticism.
It will be interesting to see if either coach can beat the odds.