The Cleveland Indians defeated the Los Angeles Angels on Tuesday, 2-0, on Giovanny Urshela's two-out, two-run homer in the 12th.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Giovanny Urshela went 3-for-5 with a two-out, two-run homer in the 12th inning as the Cleveland Indians defeated the Los Angeles Angels, 2-0, Tuesday night at Angel Stadium in Anaheim, Calif. Tribe right-hander Carlos Carrasco allowed one hit in nine innings.
Angels Nos. 3-4 batters Mike Trout and Albert Pujols were a combined 0-for-8 with one walk and one strikeout.
Here is a capsule look at the game after a DVR review of the Fox SportsTime Ohio telecast:
Off the deck: The Indians (49-57) snapped a three-game losing streak, which included the series opener Monday night (5-4).
Tough to take: The contending Angels slipped to 56-50.
Goose eggs aplenty: Carrasco and relievers Bryan Shaw, Zach McAllister and Cody Allen combined on a two-hitter. They struck out nine, walked one and plunked one.
(The Indians had 10 hits.)
Cookie's ridiculous two-pack: Carrasco walked one and struck out seven in absolutely dominating for the second consecutive start. On July 30 against the Athletics, he pitched a two-hitter in a 3-1 victory in Oakland, Calif.
No wonder teams reportedly vulture-called/emailed Tribe General Manager Chris Antonetti in the run-up to the July 31 non-waiver trade deadline, wondering whether they could acquire Cookie. Antonetti did not need his Georgetown education in order to decline each time.
Carrasco retired 27 straight batters over the two starts -- the final 16 Athletics (17 outs) and first 11 Angels. Trout broke the streak with a four-pitch walk.
Against the Athletics, Carrasco threw 72 of 103 pitches for strikes. Against the Angels, he was 68-of-100.
The outings were virtual carbon copies in terms of release points, pitch quality and execution. Carrasco used a fastball/split-changeup/slider combination; each was plus to plus-plus, and nothing was straight. He stayed on top of the ball well enough to pound the lower half of the zone, and below. He shaved corners and threw on-purpose balls in certain counts to set up pitches in different areas.
Carrasco and catcher Yan Gomes read each other's minds for 18 innings. They showed how effective rhythm and tempo can be, putting the batter on the defensive.
The Angels, much more dangerous than the Athletics, managed precious few authoritative swings against Carrasco. Their output consisted of Trout's walk, David Murphy's leadoff single in the fifth and Johnny Giavotella's shirt-grazing HBP leading off the ninth.
After Shane Victorino bunted Giavotella to second, David DeJesus lined to second and Kole Calhoun struck out swinging. The pesky Calhoun finished 0-for-5 with four strikeouts.
Shaw worked a perfect 10th. McAllister gave up a two-out infield single to Giavotella in the 11th; Urshela's homer in the 12th put Z-Mac in line for the victory. Allen worked a perfect 12th, capped by Trout's grounder to first, to earn his 22nd save.
Carrasco is 11-8 with a 3.76 ERA.
Runs come late: Here is a batter-by-batter look at the Tribe's offense; it centered on a subjective assessment of the plate appearances as quality (YES) or not quality (NO). From this perspective, all hits -- no matter how they happen -- and walks/HBPs, SACs, etc, are quality plate appearances. Some outs are quality PA's, depending on how well the ball was struck.
First inning (vs. RHP Matt Shoemaker)
Jose Ramirez -- YES (Walk, in seven pitches.)
Notable: Excellent 2-2 take.
Francisco Lindor -- NO (Grounder to first on 2-1 fastball.)
Notable: Ramirez erased attempting to steal during Lindor's AB. Ramirez initially was safe with head-first slide but was unable to maintain bag with left hand.
Michael Brantley -- NO (Called strikeout, on 2-2 slider.)
Second inning
Carlos Santana -- NO (Grounder to pitcher on 2-1 splitter).
Yan Gomes -- NO (Pop to center, on 1-2 fastball in).
Lonnie Chisenhall -- NO (Called strikeout, on 2-2 fastball on inner third).
Third inning
Jerry Sands -- NO (Called strikeout, on 0-2 fastball).
Notable: Plate umpire Jeff Nelson gave Shoemaker the benefit of the doubt; K-box showed pitch was off the outside corner.
Michael Bourn -- NO (Swinging strikeout, on 1-2 splitter).
Notable: Pitch featured good action down and away.
Giovanny Urshela -- YES (Single to right-center, on 0-1 fastball).
Jose Ramirez -- YES (Single to right, on 2-1 fastball).
Notable: Ramirez reacted to pitch off inside corner. Urshela stopped at second.
Francisco Lindor -- NO (Swinging strikeout, on 3-2 splitter).
Notable: Lindor stranded runners at first and second. Key to AB was Lindor chasing 3-1 fastball up and on inside corner. It not only prevented a walk (and Michael Brantley batting with bases loaded) but set up the splitter down.
Fourth inning
Michael Brantley -- YES (Single off top of right-field wall, out trying for second).
Notable: Right fielder Kole Calhoun played carom perfectly and made terrific throw to shortstop Erick Aybar. However, Brantley was not going full-throttle out of the box because he thought it might be gone, and, Brantley watched Calhoun as he ran to second, costing him a tenth or two.
Carlos Santana -- NO (Swinging strikeout, on 2-2 splitter).
Notable: Virtually the same pitch that struck out Bourn.
Yan Gomes -- NO (Grounder to short, on 3-2 slider).
Notable: Almost a quality PA, but not hit quite hard enough. Aybar made quality play ranging up middle but did not "rob'' Gomes.
Fifth inning
Lonnie Chisenhall -- NO (Fly to left, on 0-0 fastball).
Jerry Sands -- YES (Single to right, on 2-2 fastball).
Notable: Sands stayed compact and lined it to right.
Michael Bourn -- YES (Single to right, on 3-2 splitter).
Notable: Shoemaker wanted to finish off Bourn the same way he did in previous AB, but this split stayed up and never tailed. Bourn shot it off the glove of diving first baseman Albert Pujols. Sands, who was on the move, rumbled to third.
Giovanny Urshela -- NO (Swinging strikeout, on 2-2 slider).
Notable: Urshela reacted late to pitch that backed up and in. Failure to put ball in play was extra-painful given runners on first and third, one out.
Jose Ramirez -- YES (Walk, in five pitches).
Notable: Earlier in PA, Bourn stole second without a throw. Ramirez's walk loaded the bases.
Francisco Lindor -- NO (Swinging strikeout, on 0-2 splitter).
Notable: Brutal PA: 92-mph fastball foul (pitch to hit if going to swing); 85 splitter swinging strike; 85 splitter swinging strike. Before the 0-2 pitch, Shoemaker didn't even try to hide that the splitter was coming by fiddling with the grip... Indians now hitless in their last 14 ABs with bases loaded.
Sixth inning
Michael Brantley -- YES (Liner to right).
Notable: First quality plate appearance for Tribe that resulted in an out.
Carlos Santana -- NO (Called strikeout, on 3-2 fastball).
Notable: Shoemaker crossed up Santana, who was looking for something off-speed, with the fastball that shaved the inside corner.
Yan Gomes -- NO (Swinging strikeout, on 2-2 splitter).
Notable: Indians continued to flail at Shoemaker's splitter. Shoemaker's 10th strikeout; he should not be able to strike out 10 in six innings against any team.
Seventh inning (vs. RHP Trevor Gott)
Lonnie Chisenhall -- NO (Fly to left-center, on 2-2 fastball).
Notable: Center fielder Trout ran down ball that had hang time.
Jerry Sands -- NO (Grounder to short, on 3-2 fastball).
Michael Bourn -- NO (Grounder to second, on 0-0 fastball).
Notable: Indians made it too easy for Gott.
Eighth inning (vs. RHP Joe Smith)
Giovanny Urshela -- NO (Grounder to third, on 0-2 fastball).
Notable: On previous pitch, Urshela missed a double down left-field line by a foot.
Jose Ramirez -- NO (Grounder to second, on 0-2 breaking pitch).
Francisco Lindor -- YES (Double to right, on 0-0 fastball).
Notable: Lindor devoured a cookie.
Michael Brantley -- YES (Intentional walk).
Carlos Santana -- NO (Grounder to first, on 0-0 fastball).
Notable: Brutal PA: Two-hopper to Pujols on 89-mph pitch.
Ninth inning (vs. RHP Huston Street)
Yan Gomes -- NO (Grounder to second, on 0-0 pitch).
Lonnie Chisenhall -- NO (Swinging strikeout, on 1-2 off-speed in dirt).
Jerry Sands -- NO (Fly to left, on 0-0 pitch).
Notable: Six-pitch half for Street.
10th inning (vs. Jose Alvarez)
PH Ryan Raburn -- NO (Fly to right, on 1-0 fastball).
Giovanny Urshela -- YES (Double to right, on 0-0 fastball).
Notable: Urshela shot it inside the line.
Jose Ramirez -- YES (Fielder's choice/6-5, in 2-1 count).
Notable: Ramirez hit ball in hole for what should have been a single to short. Aybar's only play was to third base because of Urshela's mental error. As pointed out by Manning, Urshela needed to wait to see if the ball got past Aybar: "You know that in the minor leagues.... A bad mistake.''
Francisco Lindor -- NO (Fly to deep right, on 0-1 off-speed pitch).
Notable: Hang time prevented quality PA. Calhoun made catch in front of wall.
11th inning
Michael Brantley -- YES (Bunt single to third, on 0-0 fastball).
Notable: Brantley surprised Angels, whose third baseman, Conor Gillaspie, was back. Gillaspie might have had a play if he fielded cleanly with the bare hand.
Carlos Santana -- NO (GIDP 5-4-3 on 3-1 fastball).
Notable: The most brutal PA of them all. Santana, instead of laying off a pitcher's pitch (outside corner above knees) or trying to punch to right, rolled over it for the first two outs of the half-inning.
Yan Gomes -- NO (Swinging strikeout, on 2-2 off-speed pitch down and away).
12th inning
Lonnie Chisenhall -- YES (Single to left-center, on 0-2 fastball).
Notable: Five-star PA, which turned out to be enormous. On previous two pitches, Chisenhall fouled good breaking pitches away and at different speeds (76, 82).
(RHP Cam Bedrosian relieves Alvarez)
Jerry Sands -- YES (Liner to right).
Notable: Calhoun made running catch near line in huge spot.
Tyler Holt -- NO (Called strikeout, on 1-2 fastball).
Notable: Brutal PA. Fastball on outer third at thighs.
Giovanny Urshela -- YES (Two-run homer to left, on 1-0 breaking pitch).
Notable: Urshela made amends for the base-running issue in the 10th with the swing of the game: Urshela gave away much of his front side but maintained just enough back-leg integrity to give himself a chance. Most importantly, he kept the hands back long enough to drop the barrel on the shin-high pitch and hook it hard.
Jose Ramirez -- NO (Pop to left, on 2-2 fastball).
Notable: Still, a game of four quality PA's for Ramirez.
Spotlight on... Michael Brantley: He entered the night batting .302 and riding an eight-game hitting streak.
Here is a pitch-by-pitch breakdown of his plate appearances:
First inning vs. Shoemaker (none on, two outs) -- 78 curve in dirt; 93 fastball low; 93 fastball called strike; 93 fastball foul (Brantley late); 86 splitter foul (inside; ripped right side); 86 slider, called strikeout.
Skinny: Tip of the cap to Shoemaker: The strikeout pitch was a nasty front-door slider. It backed down and over the inner half.
Fourth inning vs. Shoemaker (none on, none out) -- 91 fastball low; 91 fastball low; 93 fastball, single off top of right-field wall (out trying for double by Kole Calhoun).
Skinny: Fox SportsTime Ohio play-by-play voice Matt Underwood said: "Brantley really never had a chance, unless Calhoun muffs the throw.''
Fox SportsTime Ohio analyst Rick Manning said: "He had a chance... I didn't see him bust out of the box. It looked like he thought it was going to be a home run.''
STO showed multiple replays.
Manning: "He didn't break out like it was a double. He thought it was a home run. I tell you: Calhoun played it beautifully.... (Brantley) kicks it into gear after he gets to first base. It's way too late. That cost him a double.''
Credit Calhoun with beginning his crow-hop before he secured the carom, which gave him the extra half-second needed to erase Brantley.
Sixth inning vs. Shoemaker (none on, none out) -- 90 fastball inside; 91 fastball, liner to right.
Skinny: Calhoun made catch in front of track.
Eighth inning vs. Smith (runner on second, two outs) -- ball; ball; ball; ball, intentional walk.
Skinny: No-brainer.
11th inning vs. Alvarez (none on, none out) -- fastball, bunt single to third.
Skinny: Good idea, good enough execution.
Spotlight on... Mike Trout: The reigning AL MVP entered the night batting .310 with 32 homers, 68 RBI and a .400 on-base percentage.
Here is a pitch-by-pitch breakdown of his plate appearances:
First inning vs. Carrasco (none on, two outs) -- 97 fastball called strike (inner third); 91 split-changeup swinging strike (down); 95 fastball up and in; 88 split-changeup, grounder to third.
Skinny: Carrasco did of textbook job of using fastballs up to set up changups down.
Fourth inning vs. Carrasco (none on, two outs) -- 90 slider inside; 97 fastball inside; 88 slider inside (barely); 95 fastball inside.
Skinny: Carrasco a fraction off with release point. Snapped streak of 11 outs to open game.
Seventh inning vs. Carrasco (none on, one out) -- 96 fastball, fly to center.
Skinny: Fastball featured serious late action, which jammed Trout.
10th inning vs. RHP Bryan Shaw (none on, none out) -- 93 cutter outside; 93 cutter outside; 92 cutter called strike; 92 cutter called strike; 95 fastball high; 94 fastball, grounder to first.
Skinny: Trout with excuse-me swing on pitch that was up.
12th inning vs. RHP Cody Allen (none on, two outs) -- 96 fastball called strike; 87 curve called strike (inside corner); 86 curve, grounder to first (down and away).
Skinny: Trout didn't like the call on the second pitch. He had defensive swing at 0-2 pitch.
Spotlight on... Albert Pujols: He entered the night with a career .314 average and 2,619 hits, 550 homers, 1,669 RBI, 1,146 strikeouts and 955 walks. For the season, he was batting .257 with 30 homers and 66 RBI.
Here is a pitch-by-pitch breakdown of his plate appearances:
First inning vs. Carrasco (none on, none out) -- fastball called strike; 89 slider low; 90 splitter, grounder to pitcher.
Skinny: Pujols missed a pitch to hit -- over plate and above knees.
Fourth inning vs. Carrasco (runner on first, two outs) -- 94 fastball called strike; 89 split-changeup foul; 89 slider foul; 88 splitter, swinging strikeout (in dirt).
Skinny: Strikeout pitch was nasty.
Seventh inning vs. Carrasco (none on, two outs) -- 89 slider outside; 96 fastball foul; 90 slider, grounder to short.
Skinny: Pujols hit it hard but directly at Jose Ramirez. Because the pitch was at shins, the worst result for Carrasco would have been a single.
10th inning vs. Shaw (none on, one out) -- 81 breaking pitch outside; 92 cutter, fly to center.
Skinny: Pujols missed a pitch to smash.