With the MLB amateur drafted slated to begin on Monday night, here is a look through the history of the Indians' selections. The Indians will make the 17th, 42nd and 59th overall picks on Monday.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- With the MLB amateur drafted slated to begin on Monday night, here is a look through the history of the Indians' selections. The Indians will make the 17th, 42nd and 59th overall picks on Monday.
Best late-round selections
Tony Sipp, LHP, 2004 (45th round)
The southpaw provided steady left-handed relief for the Tribe from 2009-12.
David Riske, RHP, 1996 (56th round)
The righty was a mainstay in Cleveland's bullpen from 2001-05.
Richie Sexson, 1B, 1993 (24th round)
Before he was dealt to Milwaukee for Bob Wickman, Sexson provided right-handed pop for the offensively potent Tribe of the late '90s.
Cody Allen, RHP, 2011 (23rd round)
Allen blitzed through the Tribe's farm system and has pitched in the late innings since 2011.
Vinnie Pestano, RHP, 2006 (20th round)
The right-hander was one of baseball's best set-up men in 2011 and '12.
Best first-round selections
Charles Nagy, RHP, 1988 (17th overall)
Nagy, a three-time All-Star, produced 25.2 WAR in 13 seasons with the Indians.
Manny Ramirez, OF, 1991 (13th overall)
He posted a .313 batting average and .998 OPS, with 236 home runs in eight seasons with the Tribe.
CC Sabathia, LHP, 1998 (20th overall)
He won 106 games and tallied 1,265 strikeouts in eight years with Cleveland.
Greg Swindell, LHP, 1986 (second overall)
An All-Star in 1988, the southpaw posted a 3.86 ERA and tossed 32 complete games in seven seasons with the Tribe.
Ray Fosse, C, 1965 (seventh overall)
A two-time All-Star, Fosse spent eight seasons with the Indians and was a force when healthy.
Best early-round selections
Albert Belle, OF, 1987 (second round)
Belle clubbed 242 home runs and posted a .580 slugging percentage in eight years with the Indians.
Dennis Eckersley, RHP, 1972 (third round)
Eckersley racked up most of his accomplishments with other franchises, but he did register three strong seasons -- including one All-Star campaign -- with the Indians to begin his career.
Worst first-round selections
These players reached the big leagues, but didn't do much at the level.
Trevor Crowe, OF, 2005 (14th overall)
Crowe posted a .245/.295/.329 slash line in three seasons with Cleveland
Jeremy Sowers, LHP, 2004 (sixth overall)
Despite a promising rookie cameo in 2006, Sowers finished his four major league seasons with an 18-30 record and 5.18 ERA.
Michael Aubrey, 1B, 2003 (11th overall)
Aubrey tallied nine hits in 45 at-bats with the Indians in 2008. He appeared in 31 games with the Orioles the following year. That's it.
Mark Lewis, SS, 1988 (second overall)
The infielder compiled a .255/.289/.332 slash line, with seven homers in five seasons with the Tribe.
Jack Heidemann, IF, 1967 (11th overall)
In five seasons with Cleveland, he batted .206 with a .523 OPS.
The 15-year struggle
Here is a list of Indians selections from the first or supplemental round from 1993-2007
Daron Kirkreit, RHP, 1993 (11th overall, never reached majors)
Jaret Wright, RHP, 1994 (10th overall, career war of 4.7)
David Miller, 1B, 1995 (23rd overall, never reached majors)
Danny Peoples, 1B, 1996 (28th overall, never reached majors)
Tim Drew, RHP, 1997 (28th overall, career WAR of -2.3)
Jason Fitzgerald, OF, 1997 (41st overall, never reached majors)
CC Sabathia, LHP, 1998 (20th overall, career WAR of 54.8)
Corey Smith, IF, 2000 (26th overall, never reached majors)
Derek Thompson, LHP, 2000 (37th overall, career WAR of 0.2)
Dan Denham, RHP, 2001 (17th overall, never reached majors)
Alan Horne, RHP, 2001 (27th overall, never reached majors)
J.D. Martin, RHP, 2001 (35th overall, career WAR of 0.7)
Mike Conroy, OF, 2001 (43rd overall, never reached majors)
Jeremy Guthrie, RHP, 2002 (22nd overall, career WAR of 19.0)
Matthew Whitney, 3B, 2002 (33rd overall, never reached majors)
Micah Schilling, 2B, 2002 (41st overall, never reached majors)
Michael Aubrey, 1B, 2003 (11th overall, career WAR of 0.2)
Brad Snyder, OF, 2003 (18th overall, career WAR of -0.1)
Adam Miller, RHP, 2003 (31st overall, never reached majors)
Jeremy Sowers, LHP, 2004 (sixth overall, career WAR of 1.6)
Trevor Crowe, OF, 2005 (14th overall, career WAR of 0.0)
Johnny Drennen, OF, 2005 (33rd overall, never reached majors)
David Huff, LHP, 2006 (39th overall, career WAR of -1.3)
Beau Mills, 1B, 2007 (13th overall, never reached majors)
The ones that got away
These players blossomed after they left the Indians' organization.
Sean Casey, 1B, 1995 (second round)
"The Mayor" played in six games for the Indians before he was traded to Cincinnati for Dave Burba. He played in three All-Star games and batted .305 in eight seasons with the Reds.
Chris Archer, RHP, 2006 (fifth round)
The Indians sent him to Chicago for Mark DeRosa in 2008. He owns a 3.10 ERA in 74 outings with Tampa Bay and is 7-4 with a 1.84 ERA and a league-leading 108 strikeouts this season. In nine of his 13 starts, he has held the opposition to one or zero runs.
Brian Giles, OF, 1989 (17th round)
He posted an .876 OPS in parts of four seasons with Cleveland. After being dealt to Pittsburgh for Ricardo Rincon, his OPS jumped to 1.018 over five seasons, two of which included trips to the All-Star Game.
Jeremy Guthrie, RHP, 2002 (first round)
Guthrie has posted 19.2 WAR across 12 big league seasons, but he never got his footing with the Indians, as he posted a 6.08 ERA in 37 innings with the Tribe before being selected off waivers by Baltimore.
If only they had signed
Tim Lincecum, RHP, 2005 (42nd round)
The righty was the 10th overall selection by San Francisco in 2006. He has logged four All-Star Game nods and two Cy Young awards.
Doug Drabek, RHP, 1980 (fourth round)
Selected by the White Sox in the 11th round in 1983, Drabek posted a 3.73 ERA in 13 big league seasons. He won the National League Cy Young Award in 1990.
Brian Jordan, SS, 1985 (20th round)
The 30th overall pick by St. Louis in 1988, Jordan batted .282 over 15 big league seasons and was an All-Star in 1999.
Terry Steinbach, C, 1980 (16th round)
A ninth-round selection by Oakland in 1983, Steinbach was a three-time All-Star.