The Indians are 0-6 when Corey Kluber starts.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Right-hander Corey Kluber allowed five runs (four earned) on eight hits in five-plus innings as the Indians were blasted by the Toronto Blue Jays, 11-4, Saturday afternoon at Progressive Field. Here is a capsule look at the game after a DVR review of the Fox SportsTime Ohio telecast:
Unable to build momentum: The Indians (8-15) have won two games in a row just once this season -- April 8-9 in Houston. (On Friday against Toronto, they won the second of the four-game series, 9-4.)
Runs aplenty: The Blue Jays (12-13) entered as the MLB leader with 126 runs.
They scored two in the fifth inning to take a 4-2 lead and six in the sixth to make it 10-2. Already this season, they own six innings of five-plus runs and six games of 10-plus runs.
Hard to believe, but true: The Indians are 0-6 when Kluber starts. (Last season, they were 22-12.)
In a rut: Kluber (0-4, 4.62 ERA) opened the season with three quality starts. In his past three, however, he has given up a combined 17 runs (14 earned) on 31 hits in 17 1/3 innings.
Kluber's fastball control and command have not been good enough -- particularly inside. His money pitch, the cutter, has been inconsistent; hitters have punished him for the below-average ones. His third pitch, the curve, hasn't kept hitters honest enough.
Kluber misses catcher Yan Gomes, who has been sidelined since April 12 because of a right-knee injury. Kluber never would use Gomes's absence as an excuse, and it doesn't account for failure to locate with the fastball, but their synergy was undeniable en route to Kluber's AL Cy Young season in 2014. Kluber and Gomes were so in sync that their rhythm and tempo put hitters on the defensive.
The Blue Jays, inherently aggressive and no doubt having read scouting reports or watched video of Kluber's previous two starts (at White Sox, vs. Royals), did damage early in counts. Six of their hits came within three pitches, including four on the first pitch.
Kluber was 10-of-24 with first-pitch strikes.
Here is a breakdown of Kluber's outing:
FIRST INNING
(R) Devon Travis -- fastball outside; fastball called strike; 88 cutter swinging strike (off outside corner); 94 fastball, single to right (inside corner).
Skinny: Decisive pitch was not inside far enough, especially for 1-2 count.
(R) Josh Donaldson -- 88 cutter outside; 91 cutter called strike; 94 fastball, foul pop to first.
Skinny: Got into Donaldson's kitchen, where pitch to Travis needed to be.
(R) Jose Bautista -- 89 cutter outside; 90 cutter swinging strike (outside corner); 90 cutter swinging strike; 84 curve foul (Travis moving); 94 fastball inside (Bautista hops back); 83 curve, swinging strikeout.
Skinny: Kluber used Bautista's aggressiveness against him.
(R) Edwin Encarnacion -- 89 cutter, RBI double to center.
Skinny: Catcher Roberto Perez was set up off the plate away -- standard for Kluber's cutter to right-handed batters -- but pitch stayed on outer third at thighs. When Encarnacion saw that he had swinging room, he attacked. Center fielder Tyler Holt almost made the catch, but he banged into the wall as he reached for the ball. Blue Jays have hit at least one double in 22 straight games.
(R) Russell Martin -- 92 fastball foul; 92 down and in; 90 cutter swinging strike; 94 fastball high; 83 curve, grounder to short.
Skinny: Martin off-balance.
(19 pitches)
SECOND INNING
(R) Kevin Pillar -- 91 fastball high; 87 cutter called strike; 93 fastball inside; 88 cutter foul; 94 fastball, pop to right (inside).
Skinny: Running catch by Brandon Moss on bloop.
(L) Michael Saunders -- 93 fastball, bunt single.
Skinny: Bunt off the plate meant no chance for Perez.
(L) Ryan Goins -- 91 fastball high (barely); 92 fastball foul (Saunders moving); 87 cutter, double into right-field corner.
Skinny: Cutter needed to be under hands; it stayed thigh-high on inner third. Moss's quick return throw, and Saunders' lack of speed, prevented Toronto from taking a 2-1 lead.
(L) Ezequiel Carrera -- 84 changeup called strike; 85 changeup swinging strike (appeal; Carrera went too far); 94 fastball, called strikeout (inside corner).
Skinny: Kluber worked over former Indian Carrera in a big spot. Fastball came back to catch the corner.
(R) Devon Travis -- 89 cutter low and away; 83 curve swinging strike (low); 84 curve swinging strike (three-quarters swing); 84 curve, fly to center (low).
Skinny: Kluber and Perez didn't try to re-invent the wheel. They recognized that Travis was uncomfortable against the curve and stayed with it.
(16 pitches)
THIRD INNING
(R) Josh Donaldson -- 92 fastball ball; 93 fastball called strike; 93 fastball called strike (outside corner); 85 curve foul; 95 fastball, grounder to first.
(R) Jose Bautista -- 81 curve high; 94 fastball called strike; 94 fastball inside (Bautista hops back); 95 fastball foul (inside); 89 cutter, swinging strikeout (down and away).
Skinny: Cutter, which was nasty, set up by Kluber's willingness to pitch inside to a batter who doesn't like to get pitched inside.
(R) Edwin Encarnacion -- 94 fastball ball; 90 cutter swinging strike; 95 fastball high; 94 fastball away; 94 fastball called strike (outer half; Encarnacion looking for something inside and flinched); 84 curve, grounder to third.
(16 pitches)
FOURTH INNING
(R) Russell Martin -- 91 fastball called strike; 87 cutter outside; 87 cutter foul (outside corner); 83 curve ball (low); 83 curve, homer to right-center.
Skinny: Homers after a 1-2 count are doubly painful. Decisive curve ballooned over plate at belt. Too big of a mistake to a solid hitter.
(R) Kevin Pillar -- 93 fastball called strike; 92 fastball called strike; 95 fastball foul; 95 fastball outside; 88 cutter, pop to first.
(L) Michael Saunders -- 93 fastball, grounder to third.
Skinny: Third baseman Lonnie Chisenhall picked the ball at the cut of the grass while moving to his left.
(L) Ryan Goins -- 92 fastball low; 93 fastball foul; 95 fastball, grounder to pitcher.
(14 pitches)
FIFTH INNING
(L) Ezequiel Carrera -- 93 fastball, single to center.
Skinny: Carrera got payback with an ambush; he wasn't willing to spot Kluber a routine first strike. Carrera can't be an igniter under any circumstances, but he was.
(R) Devon Travis -- 91 fastball called strike (inside corner); 87 cutter foul (into right-field corner); 94 fastball outside; 95 fastball foul; 95 fastball up and away; 83 curve foul (Zeke moving); 94 fastball away; 90 cutter, walk (low).
Skinny: A pitcher the caliber of Kluber needed to finish off Travis after getting ahead, 0-2. Travis showed excellent discipline to lay off the full-count cutter, especially with shadows between mound and plate. It is possible that Carrera's threat to run influenced Kluber into throwing five fastballs to Travis, who had struggled against the curve.
(R) Josh Donaldson -- 94 fastball inside; 89 cutter foul (over plate); 95 fastball low; 94 fastball outside; 95 fastball, walk (high).
Skinny: Kluber didn't miss by much on two of the pitches, but he missed.
(R) Jose Bautista -- 93 fastball inside (Bautista backs away); 90 cutter, two-run single to center (just off outside corner at knees).
Skinny: Bautista went to school on the cutter, which he had seen four times. The one that whiffed him in the previous at-bat darted out of the zone; this one stayed up just enough for him to catch it off the end of the barrel. Bat shattered. More good hitting than bad pitching -- but the cutter needed to be nastier against a hitter of Bautista's talent.
(R) Edwin Encarnacion -- 93 fastball high; 94 fastball called strike (outer half); 93 fastball called strike; 94 fastball away; 84 curve, GIDP 5-4-3.
Skinny: Good pitch down and away. Chisenhall seamlessly triggered double play after fielding on the move to his left. Chisenhall has been involved in 10 double plays this season.
(R) Russell Martin -- 93 fastball low; 93 fastball foul; 94 fastball foul; 94 fastball, grounder to second.
Skinny: Above-average play by second baseman Jason Kipnis, who fielded in the hole.
(25 pitches)
SIXTH INNING
(R) Kevin Pillar -- 91 fastball, double to left (up).
Skinny: Fastball didn't have much on it, and Pillar pounced. Pillar's sixth straight game with XBH.
(Kluber was hooked for lefty Marc Rzepczynski. Pillar eventually scored the first of six runs in the inning.)