Cleveland State wrestling supporters say the school's plan for external funding is "set up to fail.'' A non-binding student referendum next week asks students if they will support new fees to fund wrestling and a new women's sport.
CLEVELAND, Ohio - Cleveland State wrestling supporters are urging the school to join a partnership to keep the sport alive in the wake of what they say are unrealistic financial requirements, while students will vote next week on whether to support a fee to fund wrestling and a new women's sport.
In a meeting with Athletic Director John Parry on Thursday, key wrestling supporters and boosters asked CSU to partner with them instead of leaving the program to find its own funding.
"We want to partner with CSU, but we don't want to partner in the way they have communicated, which is to create an entirely externally funded program,'' said Aaron Grossman, President of Cleveland-based Wrestlers in Business Network. "We hope we can retract some of the things that were done this week and work toward a better solution.''
Grossman said supporters want to create a three-way partnership with the university, alumni and community boosters each playing a role in keeping the program funded. Parry met with Grossman, Lou Joseph and former CSU wrestler Jason Effner of WIBN, and National Wrestling Coaches Association Executive Director Mike Moyer.
"If there's a way to get a partnership, that would be great,'' Parry said. "They were enthusiastic and really want to help, and if there's a way to tap into that, that would be great.''
Parry announced Monday the wrestling program will be defunded after the 2015-2016 season to make room for a new men's lacrosse team. He said the wrestling team can buy two more seasons (2016-17 and 2017-18) if it raises $800,000 by March 31, 2016. The team and its supporters have until 2018 to raise $5 million to endow the program in perpetuity.
"To suggest to you can raise $5 million in two years, we don't see that as a feasible plan. To set that up, it's set up to fail from the beginning,'' Moyer said. "Everyone has to believe this is a partnership as opposed to the wrestling program (raising) all the money.''
Grossman and Parry said the meeting was productive and not adversarial, and they plan to meet again next week.
"We hope to have a different proposal from the one that's on the table right now,'' Moyer said.
Both sides appeared hopeful about wrestling's future at CSU.
"I would give it a 60-40 it will continue in some format,'' Parry told Mat Talk Online's Jason Bryan this week in a podcast.
"I'm cautiously optimistic,'' Moyer said.
Students to vote on funding wrestling
Cleveland State students will vote Monday-Thursday next week on a non-binding referendum calling for a $4-6 per credit hour fee that would fund wrestling and pay for a new women's sport.
The referendum states: "In order to maintain Division 1 wrestling and create an additional women's team to maintain Title IX compliance, a fee would be implemented to cover staff salaries, equipment, travel, insurance, and medical care. Would you be willing to pay a fee of $4-$6 per credit hour (per semester) to maintain a Division 1 wrestling program and create an additional women's team?''
"I think that's great coming from the students,'' Parry said.
CSU spokesman Kevin Ziegler said the referendum is non-binding, but the administration would "take note of that and would have to consider it.''
Parry's initial plan had been to add lacrosse and a women's sport and pay for it with a similar fee, but the university decided not to implement the fee, and Parry chose instead to add lacrosse and defund wrestling.
Cleveland State wrestling coach Ben Stehura.CSU
Fundraising takes off.
CSU coach Ben Stehura said he was "extremely encouraged" by early response as fundraising begins.
A website has been set up for donations: www.crowdrise.com/SaveCSUWrestling, and as of Friday afternoon, $5,210 had been donated.
"It's very early,'' Stehura said. "You're not going to see big dollar figures. You're gauging interest at this point. A lot of people that are supporting us that were not previously known to us from across the country who have reached out to us, not just CSU alumni.''
Serious side effects
If the team is successful in raising the money, two serious side effects could result:
* Other men's sports at CSU could lose scholarships. CSU officials said if wrestling stays while men's lacrosse is added, it will either trim scholarships from other men's sports or add a women's sport such as track or lacrosse to keep the university compliant with Title IX.
Wrestling supporters have suggested an easier solution would be to add women's wrestling.
"We can make that (women's wrestling) part of the discussion,'' Parry said on Mat Talk Online.
* Also, other colleges could consider CSU a model for their Olympic sports, telling them, "Find your own funding like Cleveland State did, or you're gone.''
"The wrestling community does not want to endow $800,000 or $5 million because every school will line up to do that,'' Grossman said.
Moyer said none of the 77 NCAA Division I wrestling programs is fully endowed. Many have partial endowments, including CSU, which has two of its 9.9 wrestling scholarships endowed.
Asked why it was not more appropriate to have lacrosse boosters raise money to start a team, Parry told Mat Talk Online: "The irony in some ways is an existing sport with alumni base has more opportunity to raise money than a sport that doesn't exist.''
Attracting wealthier students
Parry said adding lacrosse dovetails with the university's goal of recruiting students from wealthier suburbs.
"There's a ring around Cleveland of primarily private or well-to-do suburbs that have lacrosse, and some of those same schools also have wrestling, and as institution, we desire to recruit the ring around Cleveland, the ring around Columbus and the ring around Cincinnati. The feeling among the enrollment people is that lacrosse will help that,'' Parry told Mat Talk Online.
Stehura said that was no different than the wrestling team's goals.
"We want to recruit those same kids,'' Stehura said.
Creating an elite program
Parry said this week the lacrosse budget will be $475,000 compared to wrestling's $384,000. Grossman said he argued in their meeting the additional nearly $100,000 could have been better spent to create an elite wrestling program that would help attract the same students a lacrosse program might.
Cleveland State is coming off its best season in about 10 years. It was 7-3 overall and 4-2 in the highly regarded Eastern Wrestling League, and had two national qualifiers.
CSU announced Monday it will defund the team after the 2015-16 season, and supporters this week asked the school to consider a partnership to keep it alive.Cleveland State University
Stehura said his program is on the upswing after years of development and said the loss of CSU wrestling would hurt the Greater Cleveland wrestling community on many levels because Cleveland State has been a USA Wrestling regional training center that has begun to attract recruits while also focusing on the development of younger wrestlers.
Elyria Catholic coach Erik Burnett, one of the nation's most highly regarded developmental coaches, co-coaches the Cleveland program along with former Kent State All-American Danny Mitcheff.
Current CSU freshman Andrew Coghill is among the wrestlers who came up through that program.
In addition, Cleveland State had the second-highest Academic Progress Rate in the EWL last season with a team accumulated grade-point average of 3.1.
Reaction continues
Reaction from around the country continued to pour in.
Former world champion, and Chardon High grad, Lee Kemp said he thought it was a bad joke when he heard the news. Kemp often trained at Cleveland State.
"Unfortunately, because it was so close to April first, I thought it wasn't true, because if any program embodies Division I wrestling, it's Cleveland State right there in Cleveland,'' Kemp said in a phone interview from his home near Chicago. "It not always been the greatest teams over the years, but it's a sincere, serious program with wrestlers who care about wrestling and maybe didn't want to leave the state.''
Cleveland State grad and Olympic silver medalist Matt Ghaffari said he was saddened because students whose fees help pay for athletics did not have a voice in the initial decision.
"There's justification for it,'' he said. "It's not a Title IX issue. It's not anything the wrestling team or coach did negatively. It's been 52 years of positive things for Cleveland State and the student body.''
Ghaffari, an Avon Lake businessman, was among those who campaigned to bring the NCAA Wrestling Championships to Quicken Loans Arena in 2018. The Mid-American Conference is the official host.
"The most embarrassing part for me is we fought to get NCAA Wrestling here in three years and my school, Cleveland State, won't have wrestling,'' he said.