Vote in our poll on which of five options for Miller makes the most sense, or add in your own choice for Miller's football decision.
COLUMBUS -- A year ago, Braxton Miller hadn't even had shoulder surgery yet. That arrived on Feb. 21, 2014, called "minor outpatient surgery" by Ohio State at the time.
But 12 months ago, Miller had decided to stay at Ohio State, his decision to bypass the NFL Draft affected by the hit he took early in the Orange Bowl that injured his labrum.
He had decided to be a Buckeye in 2014.
And he now he has to decide what he'll be in 2015.
Do yourself a favor, and find a Miller highlight package on YouTube to remind yourself what kind of player we're talking about here, because too many OSU fans seem to have forgotten what the two-time Big Ten Offensive Player of the Year was like on the field.
And then remember the story after Miller's second surgery in August, and the idea that nothing is guaranteed after a second labrum surgery.
"I can tell you that the labrum doesn't heal particularly well," Dr. Mark Schickendantz of the Cleveland Clinic told me then. "The surgery is difficult, the blood supply is poor and it's hard to get these things to heal. It's a difficult thing to come back from. If you look across the board, successful return to play is not all that predictable. People don't understand how difficult it is to come back from that type of surgery."
That's where we are. There's a college football star who has seen people talking about his future for months. That hasn't been easy, and that won't stop.
• Where Braxton Miller still stands tall
No one should forgot what kind of player Miller was. But no one knows for certain what kind of player Miller will be now. And no one knows for certain just how Miller is going to approach the next step of his football life.
We won't pretend to know, even though Miller seemed to drop a hint about remaining at Ohio State with his words to the crowd at Ohio State's National Championship celebration on Saturday.
"It's a privilege and an honor to be a part of this national championship team," Miller said. "Guess what? We've got another year to do it."
Legacy does matter, at least in some way, to Miller. And he was appreciative of the reception Saturday, when fans chanted "one more year."
But he also would like to prepare himself to take a run at making money playing football.
Much of his decision will have to be determined by his health, and whether his shoulder is ready to be a full-time college football quarterback's shoulder in September. But his decision will have to be made before then.
Miller can transfer anywhere and play right away since he has received his undergraduate degree. Russell Wilson didn't transfer from North Carolina State to Wisconsin until the final days of June in 2011.
Ohio State quarterback Braxton Miller spoke to the crowd at the Buckeyes' National Championship celebration on Saturday.Thomas Ondrey, The Plain Dealer
Miller has five months to work with. And five real choices.
1. Remain at Ohio State and fight for the starting quarterback job: If he's healthy, and that's a big if, what tells you that Miller couldn't win the starting job? J.T. Barrett worked the offense like a veteran last season and finished fifth in the Heisman Trophy voting, but he worked it in the way in which Miller had described wanting the offense to work his senior season.
Lots of things came together in year three of Urban Meyer's offense at Ohio State that helped both Barrett and Cardale Jones succeed. Miller would have as well. It's stunning what those quarterbacks did as No. 2 and No. 3 on the depth chart. But remember who was No. 1 until that second injury in mid-August.
2. Remain at Ohio State and change positions: Again, go watch some highlights. Nothing is wrong with Miller's legs. And that speed and cutting ability looks like it could work in the pros, one way or another.
There were absolutely valid questions before Miller's injury as to whether he could be an NFL quarterback. Absolutely, he'd have a chance. But he wasn't a sure thing or a lock as a first-rounder or anything.
Miller wants to be a quarterback, but this option must be on the table if the shoulder just won't let him return to his form as a thrower. And look at some of the former college quarterbacks making their way at other positions in the NFL, including Denard Robinson and Julian Edelman. Auburn quarterback Nick Marshall just moved to cornerback during the Senior Bowl while prepping for the pros.
My possible comparison?
Josh Cribbs. But Josh Cribbs-plus.
Cribbs threw for more than 7,000 yards and ran for more than 3,600 yards as a quarterback at Kent State, but he made his NFL bones as a returner. I don't think you just make Miller, at this point in his life, a true receiver or a between-the-tackles true tailback.
But to let him get the ball in space and go, as some kind of slot guy or H-back or return man? He is fast and he is elusive and his is an elite athlete.
That type of transition could begin at Ohio State.
3. Remain at Ohio State but primarily focus on getting ready for the NFL: Say the recovery period for his shoulder is at the long end of the range, at a year. That puts him still coming back and trying to throw in mid-August, just two weeks before the start of the next season.
Braxton Miller was ready to lead the Buckeyes in 2014 before a second shoulder surgery. Could he be their starting quarterback again in 2015?Paul Beaty, Associated Press
Say he doesn't want to push it. Say he doesn't want to risk a third tear. Say he begins to understand that his college career just didn't end the way he wanted it to end, and that his real focus is the NFL Combine in February of 2016.
Miller could remain in the quarterback room, continue to learn offensive football, train like a maniac, be ready if Barrett and Jones get hurt, but, in truth, be working primarily on getting ready for the NFL.
4. Transfer to another college football power to be the quarterback: Name a major program with a quarterback opening, and Miller's name has probably been linked to it - Oregon, LSU, Florida State.
Regardless of what Miller has said so far, these options aren't out of the picture until it's too late for him to make the move. But his shoulder makes this more complex than just leaving to step in to replace Jameis Winston or Marcus Mariota.
5. Transfer somewhere he has relationships and people know him: This is slightly different than option No. 4, because it would involve Miller finding a place with some familiarity, not just another powerhouse.
One option that has been floated by everyone is joining former Ohio State offensive coordinator Tom Herman at Houston.
Another choice, completely made up right here, could be Youngstown State, where Jim Tressel, the man who recruited Miller, is the president, and former Nebraska coach Bo Pelini, who coached against Miller in the Big Ten, is the new football coach. Again, that's nothing I've heard, just an idea in the search for familiarity.
Is there another option out there I'm forgetting? Add your thoughts in the comments and vote in our poll on what you think Miller should do.