This was Justin Masterson, the guy who brought a chicken to the ballpark, the guy who starred at charity bowling events, the guy who -- though he, deep down, felt that burning desire to be the best -- never veered from his laid-back approach during trying times. And there were plenty.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- There was the one postgame session in which Justin Masterson jokingly attributed his poor outing to his decision to shave.
There was another instance in which Masterson redirected the topic of conversation from his rough start to his wife's cookie business.
This was Justin Masterson, the guy who brought a chicken to the ballpark, the guy who starred at charity bowling events, the guy who -- though he, deep down, felt that burning desire to be the best -- never veered from his laid-back approach during trying times. And there were plenty.
He flashed his carefree attitude one final time during his exit interview with reporters on Wednesday, yet another unnecessary, classy gesture by the right-hander, who was traded by the Indians to the Cardinals.
"You appreciate what life brings you and you try to enjoy it the best you can," Masterson said, "because if you get too troubled with it, then you're not going to be able to enjoy what's going on and life was meant to be enjoyed."
Masterson could have soured. He never pieced together consecutive quality seasons in Cleveland. After every ace-like showing came a dud. He followed up an All-Star campaign in 2013 with a miserable '14, one in which he posted a 5.51 ERA in 19 starts for the Tribe.
That triggered Masterson to admit that the Indians probably "dodged a bullet" when the two sides failed to come to terms on a lucrative contract extension in the spring. Masterson probably cost himself millions with his post-negotiations performance. Now, he'll head to St. Louis, knowing that he could change zip codes yet again in two months. His future remains as uncertain as his output on the mound.
No sweat.
"You can't worry about too much of your future," Masterson said. "We're not even promised tomorrow."
After all, Masterson had no way of envisioning he'd end up in this position in the first place.
Five years ago, Masterson left the only organization he had ever known. The scene at Camden Yards in Baltimore was an emotional one, as Masterson and Red Sox manager Terry Francona embraced once Boston completed a deal to send the youngster to Cleveland in a package for Victor Martinez.
The two hugged again on Wednesday. This interaction meant a little more.
"The hug was maybe a little longer than normal," Francona said. "We may part teams, but my admiration for him isn't parting."
One day before the five-year anniversary of his relocation to Cleveland, Masterson was on the move again. This time, Masterson exits after a decorated, yet somewhat unfulfilling stint in a Tribe uniform.
"Tito keeps trading me away," Masterson said, laughing. "I don't know what's up with that."
In the early going, he bounced between roles as a starter and reliever. He finally emerged as the anchor of the pitching staff in 2011, when he logged a 3.21 ERA and totaled a career-high 216 innings. But a lack of run support and a second-half fade often overshadowed his exploits. He scuffled in 2012, as he posted an 11-15 record and 4.93 ERA in 34 starts, while the Tribe suffered through a 5-24 August en route to a 94-loss season.
The Indians handed Manny Acta a pink slip and Masterson was reunited with his old skipper, Francona. Masterson reversed course last year, as he amassed a 14-10 mark and 3.45 ERA and helped guide the Tribe to a berth in the Wild Card Game. The inconsistency reared its head again this season, though. Masterson experienced a sharp decline in velocity, one the Indians have been unable to explain. He struggled to command his wayward-traveling pitches. A litany of truncated, ineffective outings followed.
Masterson termed his departure as "bittersweet," a label representative of his time in Cleveland, given his propensity to perform at the two ends of the spectrum. When Masterson was good, he was an ace, heaving a bevy of heavy sinkers toward overmatched hitters. When Masterson was bad, he was often pegged as the central deterrent to the Tribe's lofty goals.
That was the case in the end, which ultimately led to his exodus. And, despite his typically jovial disposition, he wasn't immune to the dissatisfaction.
"That's the frustrating part in general of this season, is not being able to be where I want to be, where I should be, where everyone would like me to be," Masterson said. "It probably frustrates me more than any singular person in this world, as a competitor, a man. It's made it difficult."
Francona and Masterson reminisced on Wednesday about the setting in Baltimore five years ago, the previous time Masterson was dealt. They reflected upon the conversations Francona and then-Boston GM Theo Epstein had with then-Indians GM Mark Shapiro.
More than anything, they realized that this farewell was a bit easier. Masterson established himself during his five years in Cleveland. He grew up. It all came full circle.
"I'm forever grateful for all that they've given me the chance to do within my career," Masterson said. ... "It's one of those where you appreciate what life brings you."