The Indians fell to 6-13 on the road after a 5-4 loss to the Blue Jays on Tuesday.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- The Indians played the Toronto Blue Jays in the opener of a three-game series Tuesday. Here is a capsule look from The Plain Dealer reporter Dennis Manoloff:
Game: 39.
Opponent: Blue Jays.
Location: Rogers Centre, Toronto.
Time of day: Night.
Time elapsed: 2 hours, 29 minutes.
Result: Blue Jays 5, Indians 4.
Records: Blue Jays 20-20, Indians 18-21.
GPS required: The Indians are 6-13 on the road.
Bigger welt: Some defeats sting more than others. The Indians lost to a then-sub-.500 team despite having their ace, Justin Masterson, on the mound. Masterson entered on a two-start winning streak and with excellent career numbers against Toronto.
And the Indians lost despite scoring four runs. They slipped to 14-5 when scoring four or more.
Scoreboard watch: Cleveland trails the first-place Detroit Tigers by seven games in the AL Central. The Tigers, shut out for seven innings in Baltimore by former Indian Ubaldo Jimenez, rallied for four runs with two outs in the ninth against closer Tommy Hunter for a 4-1 victory. They are 23-12.
Since realignment in 1994, a divisional deficit of seven or more games at any point in the season has proven to be difficult to overcome. (Cleveland's largest deficit this season is 7 1/2, most recently on the morning of May 8).
Controversial no-call: With the Indians trailing, 5-4, cleanup batter Carlos Santana led off the eighth inning with a single against lefty Brett Cecil. Santana moved to second on a passed ball. (At this point, Indians manager Terry Francona left himself open to second-guessing by not pinch-running for Santana.)
After Asdrubal Cabrera and David Murphy struck out, Yan Gomes singled sharply to left.
Santana, who had a sizable secondary lead, appeared to be in excellent shape to score as left fielder Melky Cabrera scooped the ball at medium depth. However, The Melk Man threw a seed to catcher Josh Thole, who applied the tag on Santana's leg a split-second before the foot touched the plate. Umpire Jordan Baker emphatically signaled out.
If only it were that simple.
Replays confirmed that Baker had gotten the call correct -- but it didn't mean Baker had done his job well. What he missed was Thole straddling the plate as the throw was on its way. This season, in an effort to eliminate violent collisions at the plate, Major League Baseball instructed umpires to make sure catchers give runners a path, or lane, to the plate before they receive the ball. Otherwise, an out call could be reversed.
Santana is not fleet afoot, and he approached from a wide angle. Regardless, he should have been granted a path to the plate other than through the catcher.
According to Northeast Ohio Media Group's legendary Indians beat reporter Paul Hoynes, "Francona came out to ask plate umpire Jordan Baker if Thole blocked the plate, but the umpires did not initiate a review.'' (Francona couldn't force Baker and his crew to did so; his challenge only could concern the tag.)
Why Baker and his crew refused to initiate a review is a mystery, and it smacks of arrogance. Multiple replays showed that, until less than 10 feet remained of the ball's journey from Cabrera, Thole was straddling the plate -- with Baker directly behind Thole. If anybody should have known immediately that Thole was in violation of the new rule, it was Baker.
Yet no initiation. If the rule isn't at least going to be tested here, why even have it?
Hoynes reported that Santana, asked whether Thole gave him a path to the plate, said: "Maybe yes, maybe no.''
Why Santana wasn't fuming after the play or after the game is a mystery. His postgame comments focused on Cabrera's throw and Gomes's bat being in his path. Yes, Cabrera made a superb one-hop throw. Yes, Gomes's bat was in Santana's path. But those realities have nothing to do with the fact that Thole pulled one over on Baker and his colleagues.
SportsTime Ohio play-by-play man Matt Underwood calmly and sternly said, repeatedly, that Thole had not provided a lane for Santana. Underwood spelled out how the new rule came to be. Underwood said that, in Thole's defense, the throw took him across the plate -- but whether it was intentional or unintentional didn't matter.
Underwood summed up the entire situation perfectly by saying: "If you're asking the runners essentially to slide almost all the time now, then if you don't give them a lane, there has to be consequences for that. We're not going to run you over anymore, but if you don't give us a lane, there needs to be consequences for you, which is: OK, you're going to be called safe then.''
SportsTime Ohio studio analyst Jason Stanford, a former MLB player, articulated similar points in STO's postgame show.
Underwood and Stanford never blamed the Tribe's loss on the possible Thole plate block. Correctly so: The Indians did not lose because of it. But the play absolutely deserved to receive the attention it got.
Two games in one: Against righty Masterson's first 27 pitches, the Blue Jays were 0-for-9. The average of three pitches per out took him through three perfect innings.
Against Masterson's next 49 pitches, the Blue Jays were 6-for-12 with three walks, one sacrifice fly, five RBI and five runs. He averaged seven pitches per out, exiting after 5 1/3.
Masterson's final line -- 5 1/3 IP, 6 H, 5 R, 5 ER, 3 BB, 4 K -- could have been worse. Lefty reliever Josh Outman inherited runners on first and second and stranded them.
Masterson's 76-pitch performance was his shortest non-injury start, by count, since April 17, 2012, at Seattle (3 2/3 IP, 7 H, 8 R, 71 pitches).
A nemesis re-emerging: Last year, Masterson got a handle on what had been a significant problem: left-handed batters. He held them to a .248 average and .698 OPS en route to a highly productive season (14-10, 3.45 ERA, 193 IP).
In Masterson's eight starts entering Tuesday, lefties were hitting .305 with a .798 OPS. In his ninth start, Blue Jays lefties Jose Reyes, Cabrera, Adam Lind, Juan Francisco and Thole were 0-for-5 the first time through the order but closed 4-for-6 -- all four of the hits for extra bases -- with two walks.
Reyes led off the fourth by slashing a 1-2 sinker down and away into left-center for a triple. The next batter, Cabrera, socked a first-pitch sinker deep to center, where Michael Bourn ran it down at the track. Masterson made it too easy for The Melk Man, whose sacrifice fly tied the score, 1-1.
With one out in the fifth, Francisco crushed a 1-0 flat sinker for a homer to give the Blue Jays a 2-1 lead. The ball rattled around in the upper tank in right-center. It was just the fourth homer allowed by Masterson.
Cabrera led off the sixth with a five-pitch walk. Cabrera has been one of the American League's best hitters and enjoys facing Masterson, but Masterson needed to do a better job of at least tempting him to swing.
After an infield single by righty Jose Bautista, Lind stepped in. Lind took a ball, then drove an 85-mph pitch on the outer half for a two-run double to left-center.
As in the case of the Reyes triple, the pitch qualifies as decent because it was (relatively) down and away. But both pitches featured tailing action onto the swing plane, which makes the outer half considerably more manageable when a hitter faces the opposite hand.
Masterson struck out righty Edwin Encarnacion. But Francisco jumped on a first-pitch flat sinker on the inner half and ripped it into the right-field corner for an RBI double and 5-1 advantage. Francisco effectively ambushed Masterson.
Francisco and Lind obviously were determined not to spot Masterson anything, having done their damage in a combined five pitches. Masterson helped them by throwing pitches without much movement and with too much swing room.
Slip-sliding: One of the reasons Masterson contained lefties last year was a filthy slider that dived under the hands. This season, Masterson's slider has featured more of a Frisbee effect, thereby staying more on plane. While such sliders can continue to work against righties, lefties aren't as threatened because they can see them better. Masterson needs the diving slider to return in order to enhance his ability to stop lefties.
Another issue for Masterson is that his four-seam velocity continues to be down.
Despite not having his best stuff for most of his nine starts, Masterson is 2-2 with a respectable American League ERA of 4.31. Regardless, the Indians need their staff ace to be much better.
Two games in one, part two: Blue Jays knuckleballer R.A. Dickey's first 90 pitches carried him through six innings. He gave up one run on three hits.
Dickey's next 12 pitches resulted in a single, error, walk and hit-by-pitch. He exited in favor of lefty Aaron Loup without retiring a batter in the seventh.
Loup allowed two of the inherited runners to score. It meant that Dickey's final line read 6 IP, 4 H, 4 R, 2 ER, 2 BB, 6 K.
Dickey is known for his hard knuckleball, which he used for the majority of his pitches against the Indians. But he spotted low-80s "fastballs'' and, more importantly, threw some wicked changeups to lefties. Santana (twice) and Bourn struck out swinging against the change piece, which ran hard off the plate away.
Slow going: Here are the pitch speeds, according to the readings shown on SportsTime Ohio, of the outs recorded by Dickey:
First inning -- 76 mph (FO-7); 74 (K); 77 (PO-4).
Second -- 73 (K); 78 (FO-8); 79 (FO-7).
Third -- 80 (GO 6-3); 83 (GO-3); 73 (FO-8).
Fourth -- 77 (K); 75 (PO-4); 81 (K).
Fifth -- 80 (GO 4-3); 78 (GO 6-3); 73 (K).
Sixth -- 78 (GO 4-3); 79 (K); 71 (FO-8).
Not very Smooth: Indians left fielder Michael Brantley went 0-for-4, ending his hitting streak at 11 games. Brantley normally feasts on any type of pitching in the Rogers Centre.
Brantley did not agree with Baker's zone on several occasions.
With two outs and Lonnie Chisenhall on second in the seventh, Brantley sent a liner up the middle against Loup. Shortstop Reyes, shaded that way, easily made the catch. The Blue Jays remained in front, 5-4.