A new coach helped senior Missy Spahar become the top scorer and rebounder in John Carroll history.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- "We were a little scared."
That's how Missy Spahar remembers feeling before the team's first practice with John Carroll women's basketball coach Kelly Morrone.
"We knew she came from Division I," said Spahar. "And she had an assistant (Alicia Manning) who played at Tennessee. A lot of the girls wondered if they were going to be running us until we dropped or whatever."
Spahar was entering her senior season. A year ago, JCU was 14-13 overall, 6-12 in the Ohio Athletic Conference.
Morrone was the new coach. A first-year head coach. Her previous stops as an assistant were at William & Mary, Davidson and Buffalo.
She also was a starting point guard for a South Carolina team that reached the Final Eight. Two of her teammates later played in the WNBA.
Manning was the new assistant who started 44 games in her Tennessee career for Pat Summitt.
Would these coaches act as if Division III players knew nothing -- especially because none of the coaches were from Northeast Ohio?
"We wondered that," said Spahar. "But Coach Kelly was the opposite. She talked about it being our team, and how the coaches were there to make us better. No 'my way or the highway …' But soon, we figured out that the coaches thought we were better than we thought we were."
Not just better …
This is the best team in the 44 years of JCU's women's basketball, finishing with a 21-4 record overall, and tied for first at 15-3 in the OAC with rival Baldwin-Wallace.
JCU and Baldwin-Wallace will both be in the Division III NCAA tournament that opens Friday. John Carroll will face Texas Lutheran at 5 p.m. at Thomas More College in Kentucky. Baldwin Wallace played Lebanon Valley at 5 p.m. at York, Pa. Winners advance to play Saturday.
BW is making its 12th trip to the NCAA Tournament.
For JCU, it's the first in school history.
New goals
"I can't believe all the things that have happened this year," said Spahar.
She said the players believed they were a better team than they had shown in the past.
But the best in school history?
Or Spahar averaging 25 points a game, becoming JCU's all-time leading scorer? And rebounder? And also the OAC Player of the Year?
"We played Mount Union early in the season and killed them (82-64)," she said. "That was new for us. And then we started 11-0. That made us think that we could do something special."
Morrone deflects any credit for the team's success.
She mentions that JCU had talent and it's a "veteran team." She didn't recruit the key players.
"The main thing is the players were receptive to us," she said. "They could have made it hard for a new coaching staff."
Especially for someone with no area connections who had never been a head coach at any level.
"We didn't come in to blow the doors off and change everything," said Morrone. "We knew there would be some fear, especially from the seniors."
Morrone and her staff treated the players with respect.
Respect was returned, and winning followed.
"I do think Kelly raised expectations and added some discipline," said Laurie Massa, the JCU athletic director. "That made a difference. She is just a good teacher and coach."
John Carroll athletic director Laurie Massa took a chance on hiring a rookie head coach with no Division III experience to make the Blue Streaks a contender in the OAC.file photo New coach
Morrone is from Syracuse and never coached in Ohio before being hired at John Carroll.
Massa was an associate athletic director at South Carolina when Morrone played there. The two women kept in touch as Morrone pursued a coaching career that carried her from one program to another. Twice, the head coach that hired her was fired within a year. The staff also was wiped out.
"They had a coaching change at William & Mary and I knew Kelly was available," said Massa. "I thought she was at the right point in her career to be a head coach."
Morrone was looking for a different opportunity. Her relationship with Massa and the chance to be a head coach was intriguing.
"Especially in Northeast Ohio, because I know there is so much talent in this area," said Morrone.
JCU primarily uses six players. Three are from Lake Catholic: Beth Switzler, along with Missy Spahar and her sister, Katlyn Spahar.
The other key players are Emily Taylor (Elyria Catholic), Daniella Rice (Kent Roosevelt) and Allie Lustig (Palo Alto, California).
The high caliber of area high school girls basketball is why Massa had bigger dreams for JCU's program.
"For so long Mike (Moran) has done such a great job with the men's (basketball) team," said Massa. "It's great to have our women's team now getting noticed, too."
New hopes
In her early 20s, Massa was the women's basketball coach at Xavier. She loves the sport and knows how a successful basketball team can bring attention to women's athletics.
At JCU, she wanted a coach who could lead the women's basketball program to take a step from being in the middle of the OAC pack -- to being a contender.
That's a demanding task in a league that this year is sending four teams to the NCAA tournament.
Nearby are two premier programs. Cheri Harrer has reached almost legendary status at Baldwin-Wallace with a 486-178 record in 24 seasons.
Suzy Venet has led Mount Union to the NCAA tournament in three of the last four years.
Add in OAC powers such as Capital and Ohio Northern, and you know why Morrone said she "doesn't see much difference" between her Division I experience and "how hard it is to win and how competitive it is in the OAC."
Division III means no athletic scholarships.
"You have a lot of nice girls with very little sense of entitlement," said Morrone. "I don't have to stay on them to study. There are times when I get texts from some of the players at 1 a.m. and they say they are taking a break homework. I text them back and tell them to go to bed, get some rest."
This rookie head coach was named the OAC Coach of the Year.
Spahar said Morrone really blasted the team only once this season.
"We were losing by about 20 points to Wilmington," Spahar said. "We went into the locker room for halftime. I don't remember much of what Coach Kelly said, but she made us stand up all during halftime. We came back and won that game."
It seems the message was if you lazy during the game, you didn't need to rest at halftime.
But most of the season, Morrone has been able to stay very positive.
Lake Catholic product Kaylyn Spahar is the OAC Freshman of the Year. Her older sisrter, Missy Spahar, is the OAC Player of the Year.John Kuntz / The Plain Dealer New heights
Missy Spahar said one of the reasons that she went from averaging 16.9 points as a junior to 25.3 this season is that she often works with assistant Alicia Manning, the former Tennessee forward who is 6-foot-1.
The 5-foot-10 Spahar believes having some success in drills when defended by Manning, "gave me a lot of confidence. I remember early in the year, I was averaging 25 points. I didn't think it would last, but the coaches kept pushing me."
Spahar is second in the country in scoring, behind Sydney Moss. Consider that the Thomas More forward is the daughter of former NFL star Randy Moss. She was Kentucky's "Miss High School Basketball" and began her career at Florida, averaging 11.6 points as a freshman.
She became homesick, and transferred to Thomas More in Crestview Hills, Ky.
"I think Missy could have played at any Division I program where I have coached," said Morrone. "She's really nice off the court and humble, but a killer on it. You can foul her and she makes you pay at the line (87 percent). She's very tough."
Spahar praises Lustig, the 5-foot-5 point guard for "getting me the ball in great situations." Lustig was named All-OAC second team.
Morrone also went to more up-tempo basketball and the Blue Streaks averaged 81.6 points -- No. 9 in all of Division III. That also has helped some of the scoring stats.
JCU's second-leading scorer is Katlyn Spahar (13.6 points), who was named the OAC Freshman of the Year. She comes off the bench.
"She's really tough," said Missy Spahar. "She played tight end on the CYO football team. I'm more of a girlie-girl."
The sisters' older brother (Nick Spahar) played football for JCU.
Morrone said "we have a lot of blue-collar kids." She raved about the defense of Daniella Rice and Beth Swtizler. Emily Taylor (35 percent) is the team's second-best shooter from 3-point range behind Lustin (44 percent).
"I'm just so proud what of these players have accomplished and how they accepted us (the new coaches)," said Morrone. "They have made this so much fun for everyone."