The Browns' defense repeatedly failed when it mattered most in a 27-26 loss to the Patriots at Gillette Stadium in Foxborough, Mass. Upon DVR review of the CBS telecast, here are some observations.
CLEVELAND, Ohio – The Browns’ defense repeatedly failed when it mattered most in a 27-26 loss to the Patriots at Gillette Stadium in Foxborough, Mass.
Upon DVR review of the CBS telecast, here are some observations:
Flameout: The following is a partial list of facts pertaining to the Browns-Patriots game:
• The Patriots ran eight offensive plays in the first quarter and trailed, 3-0.
• The Patriots trailed at halftime, 6-0. Their quarterback, Tom Brady, was 7-of-19 for 95 yards and one interception.
• The Patriots trailed, 19-3, early in the third quarter and 19-11 late in the quarter. They lost standout tight end Rob Gronkowski to injury in the third.
• The Patriots trailed, 26-11, with 2:39 left in regulation. They had first-and-10 at the Cleveland 18.
• The Patriots trailed, 26-11, with 1:02 left.
And the Browns still lost. #oic (only in Cleveland)
It happened because the Browns' defense flopped late in the fourth quarter for the second straight game. As a result, all the positives heretofore were flushed.
In Week 13, Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Chad Henne directed a nine-play, 80-yard touchdown drive in 3:15 to enable his team to rally for a 32-28 victory in Cleveland. The TD came with 40 seconds left.
Brady directed an 11-play, 82-yard touchdown drive in 1:38 to pull New England within 26-21 with 1:01 remaining. After a successful onside kick by the special teams, Brady’s offense went 40 yards in two plays (and one giant penalty) to take the 27-26 lead with 31 seconds to play.
Brady, at the opposite end of the QB spectrum from Henne, added another pelt to the wall in his Hall of Fame career. He secured the Patriots’ third consecutive comeback from a double-digit deficit in the second half. Here is a capsule look at the Patriots’ final two drives, with who/what gets the credit/blame:
First-and-10 at Cleveland 18 – Brady to RB Shane Vereen for 6 yards over the middle. Armonty Bryant hit Brady on release. Clock kept moving. Browns will take that play in that situation every time.
Second-and-4 at New England 24 - Brady to Kent State product Julian Edelman for 23 yards. Clock stopped at 2:00. Edelman, lined up slot right, beat corner Leon McFadden on a seam route. Brady’s pass wobbled but still had enough mustard. Credit Brady, but McFadden needed to make the play more difficult.
First-and-10 at New England 47 - Brady to Edelman for 19. Virtually a carbon copy of the previous play. Credit Brady for recognizing a mismatch, but McFadden needed to be better and at least one safety needed to compress the field more.
The Browns had allowed three plays for 48 yards in less than 50 seconds. Yes, Brady was the QB. But it was too easy.
First-and-10 at Cleveland 34 - Brady incomplete to Vereen. Billy Winn used a spin move to beat the right guard and pressure Brady, who threw the ball in the neighborhood of Vereen. Credit the Browns for a good play.
Second-and-10 at Cleveland 34 - Brady to Vereen for 9. Good coverage downfield forced Brady to check down to his right. Vereen hopped out of bounds in front of Joe Haden. Browns got a bad break when officials missed an obvious hook-and-hold by the left tackle on Jabaal Sheard. Brady rolled away as Sheard tried to get free.
Third-and-1 at Cleveland 25 - Brady to Edelman for 6. Edelman, lined up slot right, beat McFadden on an out-cut and stepped out of bounds with 1:29 left. Edelman vs. McFadden simply was a mismatch that Brady continued to exploit.
First-and-10 at Cleveland 19 - Brady to Vereen for 4. Vereen flared out of the backfield to the right and was met by Haden, but Haden failed to prevent Vereen from getting out of bounds with 1:24 left.
Second-and-6 at Cleveland 15 - Brady to Vereen for 13. Vereen ran an arrow route from the left and was wide open at the 10. D’Qwell Jackson and T.J. Ward made the tackle. Credit Brady for recognizing how much cushion the Browns were giving in the middle of the field; he directed Vereen to move from the backfield to outside the left tackle, ensuring a clean release. Regardless, the Browns made it way too easy for New England to gain significant yardage.
First-and-goal at 2 - Brady spiked to stop clock with 1:09 left.
Second-and-goal at 2 - Vereen up the middle for no gain. Ward and Sheard made the stop. Patriots gambled with a running play, lost, and were forced to use their final timeout at 1:04. Credit the Browns for not falling for the banana in the tailpipe.
Third-and-goal at 2 - Brady to Edelman for touchdown. Edelman, lined up slot left, beat Haden to the inside in the back of the end zone. Haden and Buster Skrine, who was assigned to Danny Amendola on the left, were moving at the snap after Amendola went in motion and set up behind Edelman. Brady had Amendola open, as well, in the front of the end zone.
Safety Jordan Poyer drilled Edelman after the catch and was penalized 15 yards for “unnecessary roughness/contact on a defenseless receiver.’’ Translation: The official(s) thought Poyer hit Edelman in the head with his right shoulder.
As CBS showed a replay from the back of the end zone, analyst Steve Tasker said: “Oh … I don’t know. He hit him with the shoulder. His head missed Edelman. I’ll tell you what: I don’t think Poyer will get fined for that – not that anybody cares at this moment.’’
The camera shot from the back of the end zone did, indeed, seem to show Poyer avoiding Edelman’s head and striking his right shoulder. The shot looking into the end zone, however, was inconclusive. It is possible that Poyer’s shoulder might have grazed Edelman’s facemask; therefore, the correct call might have been made.
Beyond questioning whether Poyer did, indeed, hit Edelman illegally, the Browns must have wondered why their quarterback, Jason Campbell, had been hit in the facemask by Pittsburgh’s William Gay in Week 12 – but no flag was thrown. Campbell fumbled, crashed to the ground and suffered a concussion. The Steelers scored a TD moments later off a turnover that should not have been. The NFL later fined Gay, confirming the blown call.
The Poyer penalty meant New England’s onside kick would be at the 50. The kick worked when the ball bounced off Fozzy Whittaker at the 40-plus yard line and Kyle Arrington recovered.
First-and-10 at Cleveland 40 - Brady to Amendola for 10. Amendola, lined up slot left, beat Skrine on an out-cut. Skrine kept Amendola inbounds.
First-and-10 at Cleveland 30 - Brady incomplete to Josh Boyce in end zone with 35 seconds left. The ball went through Boyce’s hands, but field judge Dyrol Prioleau penalized McFadden for interference in the end zone, putting the ball at the 1. Replays showed nothing even close to egregious from McFadden. The only possible explanation from Prioleau would be that, based on his line of sight, McFadden’s left hand was too tight on Boyce’s left shoulder. However, another angle showed that McFadden did nothing wrong.
Tasker, a former receiver, disagreed with Prioleau – and how. “That’s pretty incidental to me,’’ Tasker said. “That, to me, seems like a pretty soft call … I think it’s a horrible call. I think it’s a horrible call. … That was a touch call. … There’s no way there was interference in the end zone. Maybe outside the end zone – maybe. I doubt it. That’s, I think, a terrible call.’’
First-and-goal at 1 - Brady to Amendola for touchdown. Amendola went in motion from right to the middle, then popped back to the right and scraped along the goal line in front of Skrine as Brady rolled right. It was a classic short-yardage play from the old school West Coast Offense playbook.
Of the final two New England possessions, the Browns can say that they were beaten by Brady, one of the greatest ever to play his position. That would be accurate: Brady did what Brady does. But the Browns deserve as much blame as Brady does credit, if not moreso -- regardless of the officiating. Given the circumstances, the 82-yard TD drive having unfolded as it did simply can’t happen if a defense wants to be taken seriously.
Phone numbers: Brady overcame the slow start to have a monster day, finishing 32-of-52 for 418 yards and the two touchdowns. He was intercepted once and sacked four times. Some of Brady’s early struggles were because of what the Browns did to him and his teammates, but Brady made unforced errors and his receivers dropped a handful of passes. And Brady lost Gronkowski to the injury (from a perfectly legal and clean hit by Ward).
Leaky coverage: The Browns’ defense has struggled all season with non-receivers catching passes at the second and third levels. Brady turned Vereen into Roger Craig, connecting with him 12 times for 153 yards.
Late in the third quarter, the Patriots began a possession at the New England 28 and were trailing, 19-3. Vereen moved from the backfield to line up wide left opposite linebacker Craig Robertson. Vereen ran a go-route past Robertson and caught a well-thrown ball from Brady for a 50-yard gain. On the next play, Vereen beat Robertson to the inside for a 16-yard gain. On the next play, Vereen scored easily on a 6-yard run. The Patriots had gotten back into the game in a blink.
Robertson and Jackson are active run-stoppers. Covering backs and tight ends one-on-one is not their strong suit.
So much for the blitz: The Browns’ much-hyped “attacking’’ 3-4, at least as pertains to quarterback-wrecking blitzes, is a rumor.
All of the sacks of Brady – Paul Kruger (2), Barkevious Mingo, Sheard – came out of four-man rushes. Browns coach Rob Chudzinski said four-man rushes have been a point of emphasis in practice, and for good reason: The Browns need the extra help covering the scatbacks and tight ends.
Perhaps the most surprising reality of the Browns’ defense this season is how relatively ineffective the blitz has been at getting the quarterback to the ground, or at least altering his throws. The Browns have not notched a sack with five or more rushers at the time of the sack since the fourth quarter in Week 9 against Baltimore. The Browns had zero sacks in Week 11 at Cincinnati, zero in Week 12 against Pittsburgh and two with four-man rushes in Week 13 against Jacksonville.
Locked in: Kruger, who has been quiet more often than he has been loud this season, played his best game as a Brown. In addition to the two sacks, he rejected a Brady screen attempt and altered another trajectory to force an incompletion.
Finally: The Browns’ defense has given up 33 touchdowns in 13 games. Let it marinate.
Defense overall grade: D -
How to use the database:
Below is a breakdown of the Patriots' pass plays upon DVR review of the CBS telecast, and what role the Browns’ rush played in each. In the chart, "Showed is how many Browns were on the line and at least presented themselves as rushers; "RTOP" is rushers at time of pass, which includes those who came from the second level or defensive backfield and subtracts those who dropped into coverage.
• View week-by-week defensive report card in a new window or mobile device »