Reflect on the news and commentary that developed as the Browns added a highly-rated pass rusher to their defense on Thursday.
Watch video
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Well, it might not have been sexy, but it was interesting.
After weeks of misdirection, obfuscation and just plain fibbing, the NFL Draft conducted its first round Thursday night. The Browns, drafting sixth, took Louisiana State defensive end/linebacker Barkevious Mingo, clearly reinforcing their plans to create a blitzing front seven that will presumably put serious pressure on opposing quarterbacks.
Rounds 2 and 3 take place Friday evening and the final four rounds begin at noon on Saturday. We'll continue to be with you every step of the way, getting reaction from our Plain Dealer writers, columnists and photographers as well as Cleveland.com personalities.
We'll also keep tabs on what is being said around the league, giving you as much information and insight into tonight's decisions as possible. Just keep refreshing your browser for the latest news.
As always, we invite you to take part in our comments section below. Just remember the rules of the road when the Browns are involved.
Thanks for a rousing conversation in the comments and we'll see you at 5:30 p.m. on Friday.
11:50 p.m.: News from Suzy Kolber on ESPN -- a disappointed Geno Smith isn't going to deal with waiting any more in the public eye. He left Radio City Music Hall and is headed back to West Virginia.
Smith and Manti Te'o aren't the only highly-rated players still waiting for the phone call. According to NFL.com, prospects who should go early in the second round include Florida International safety John Cyprien, Kansas State linebacker Arthur Brown, Kentucky guard Larry Warford and Mississippi State defensive end Damontre Moore.
Other players with "starter" grades on the website without a home yet are California receiver Keenan Allen, Boise St. cornerback Jamar Taylor, Alabama defensive tackle Jesse Williams, Florida State defensive end Cornelius Carradine, Texas DE Alex Okafor and FSU tackle Menelik Watson.
11:45 p.m.: The Ravens complete the opening round by finding the replacement for Ed Reed with Florida safety Matt Elam, who is the brother of former Browns defensive back Abe Elam.
Elam is a rarity among draft picks, as he has yet to acquire an agent.
11:42 p.m.: As we wait on Baltimore to close out the first round, a quick observation after spending the evening checking out the local sports talkers bouncing back and forth about the Browns' selection of Mingo.
Hey guys, the Browns had one pick tonight. One. Stop praising the addition of a pass rusher while simultaneously complaining that they didn't add a cornerback. Shy of being able to split into two players, it seems unlikely that it's really a fair criticism.
11:40 p.m.: Dallas gets offensive line help for Tony Romo, taking Wisconsin guard Travis Frederick.
11:31 p.m.: The Rams, using the No. 30 pick acquired when the Falcons moved up, pick up Georgia linebacker Alec Ogletree, who has more than a few issues, including a DUI during the pre-draft period and several run-ins on the campus in Athens.
Meanwhile, ESPN has video of Geno Smith walking quickly (storming?) out of the green room, as Chris Berman speculates he's heading back to the hotel. With Dallas and Baltimore left to draft, the realization of his second-round status has to be stunning.
11:23 p.m.: The Te'o story has briefly replaced the Geno Smith Tumble, but there was hope that he would now find a home when the Vikings traded back into the round. No such luck. The Vikings add offensive help for Christian Ponder with Tennessee WR Cordarrelle Patterson.
Patriots get No. 52, No. 83, No. 102 and No. 229 in exchange for No. 29.
11:13 p.m.: With the Broncos on the clock, word leaks that the Patriots -- as is Bill Belichick's wont -- have dealt down from the 29th spot and the Vikings have moved up. That could well be Te'o.
The Broncos, needing some defensive line help after the loss of Elvis Dumervil, pick up North Carolina DT Sylvester Williams.
11:09 p.m.: The Houston Texans, with former Buckeye DeVier Posey sidelined with a torn Achilles, could have found a replacement with Clemson's DeAndre Hopkins.
Before tonight, Hopkins' biggest splash leading up the draft was the admission that he was one of two players who trashed a hotel room in Indianapolis during the combine. But here's a case where a "character flaw" doesn't haunt the player.
Meanwhile, the Browns' Joe Haden doesn't seem too bummed to not have a new partner on the corner -- at least not yet.
10:58 p.m.: With the Packers on the clock, a quick look back at the draft so far reveals that all but one player was graded on the NFL.com site as at least an immediate starter for their new team. The exception? Buffalo QB E.J. Manuel.
The Packers, with clear needs on defense, grab UCLA defensive end Datone Jones.
10:54 p.m.: No love for Te'o yet, with Florida State cornerback Xavier Rhodes going to the Vikings with their second pick of the round.
10:49 p.m.: The Colts, needing help on the defensive line, take Florida State's Bjoern Werner at 24.
That brings the Vikings back on the clock at 25 ... and renews the Te'o watch. Meanwhile, there just don't seem to be any likely takers at the bottom of the round for Geno Smith unless someone trades back up.
10:45 p.m.: Sharrif Floyd's fall ends at No. 23, as he's taken by the Minnesota Vikings. The Vikes were the second team thought to have an interest in Manti Te'o but went in another direction.
"I have more than a chip on my shoulder. I have a whole bag of Lays." - Floyd.
10:42 p.m.: Sports Illustrated's Chris Burke gives the Browns a B+ grade for taking Mingo.
The Cleveland Browns’ move from a 4-3 to a 3-4 defense left them badly in need of another dynamic pass rusher or two. Consider them a step closer to where they want to be after their Round 1 selection of LSU DE/OLB Barkevious Mingo.
Like Ziggy Ansah, who went just above him, Mingo is a bit of a work in progress — his production last season was disappointing (4.5 sacks), but he’s now headed into a defense that should fit his abilities better than the LSU one did. Combine him with new addition Paul Kruger and incumbent Jabaal Sheard at OLB in the Browns’ defense, and suddenly, that’s a pretty ferocious pass rush.
CBS Sports' Pete Prisco isn't as bullish, giving the Browns a C-.
Mingo has raw ability, but I just didn't see enough from him last season. I wanted more. And do the Browns have a need there?
10:38 p.m.: The picks coming quickly now. The Falcons deal with St. Louis for the 22nd pick and grab Washington cornerback Desmond Trufant.
The Rams pick up a late third-round pick (92nd) and a sixth rounder, while the Falcons move up and get a seventh rounder in 2015.
10:34 p.m.: Cincinnati is one of the few teams boosting its offense in the first round, grabbing Notre Dame tight end Tyler Eifert.
10:28 p.m.: Chicago was considered the first stop available for Manti Te'o, but the Notre Dame linebacker is bypassed for the son of Oakland Raiders Hall of Famer Howie Long, Oregon guard Kyle Long.
Long is quite the reclamation story, overcoming a substance-abuse addiction.
10:21 p.m.: The Giants, with the 19th pick, take Syracuse guard Justin Pugh. The race is now officially on between Geno Smith and Florida defensive tackle Sharrif Floyd for the tumbler of the night. While Smith attracted plenty of criticism during the last month, but Floyd was highly considered by pretty much every "reputable" mocker.
10:15 p.m.: San Francisco trades up to the 18th spot with Dallas. The Cowboys get an extra third-round pick, while the 49ers get LSU safety Eric Reid.
10:10 p.m.: With the worst-kept secret of the draft, the Steelers grab Georgia sack master Jarvis Jones -- his spinal stenosis irregardless. This is a case of letting the game tape speak ... his 28 sacks in two seasons dwarfs the pass rushers taken ahead of him.
10:04 p.m.: Geno Smith's night just got exponentially worse, as the first QB off the board is ... E.J. Manuel of Florida State to Buffalo.
9:58 p.m.: The New Orleans Saints, with one of the weakest defenses -- bounties or otherwise -- in the league, take Texas safety Kenny Vaccaro.
9:52 p.m.: Utah defensive tackle Star Lotulelei goes 14th to Carolina.
Meanwhile, asked if there was a chance if the Browns might deal back into the first round, Banner generated some laughter with his response.
"We're going to sleep."
9:48 p.m.: Some reports had the Jets taking Geno Smith, but they go defense again, taking powerful defensive tackle Sheldon Richardson from Missouri.
9:44 p.m.: Joe Banner tells reporters that Mingo was the player they wanted. "We just feel that building with character and speed and quickness that this was the player we wanted."
Rob Chudzinski praised the conversation the team had with Mingo, and was a "unanimous type of person" when it came to recommendations by the scouting department. He added that the coaching staff has been impressed with the work of Jabaal Sheard in his new role as outside linebacker/pass rusher.
Banner said the team would have likely traded down if Mingo was not available, but would not elaborate beyond that.
9:38 p.m.: Geno Smith's slide is continuing, as an early report that he was going to Oakland proves erroneous. The Raiders take cornerback D.J. Hayden -- leaving the front-runner for the QB job former OSU star Terrelle Pryor.
Hayden was quickly referred to as a medical miracle by Suzy Kolber, and with good reason. He nearly died after a practice collision when a major artery to the heart tore.
9:31 p.m.: While Mingo spoke to the media, another SEC star -- Alabama guard Chance Warmack -- was selection 10th by Tennessee, followed by San Diego's choice of the Crimson Tide's mountainous offensive tackle D.J. Fluker.
Barkevious Mingo was rocking some brown and orange at the NFL Draft Thursday night, but said it was just a coincidence.MCT photo 9:27 p.m.: In a conference call with Cleveland media, Barkevious Mingo said he talked with defensive coordinator Ray Horton in his visit with the team. "They need pass rushers. They needed someone to get to the quarterback and help the defense."
Mingo said adding some weight isn't a concern. He said his draft ensemble (in brown and orange) wasn't advance knowledge, but a choice by those who picked out his clothing.
"I'm very excited. I'm a National Football League player and playing for a (city) that loves football."
More on Mingo from Mary Kay Cabot.
A quick analysis of the pick by Yahoo! and National Football Post: "While some considered the Browns to be in the market for a cornerback, the move to select Mingo is the right one for their defense. He has the mobility to pressure the quarterback and immediately improves their newly installed 3-4 defense."
9:16 p.m.: Likely frustrated by the Rams' move to grab Tavon Austin, the Jets address defense with Alabama cornerback Dee Milliner.
Pro Football Talk is feeling more sympathy than enthusiasm for the Jets' selection. "Potential disaster for the Jets and Dee Milliner. He'll never get out of the Revis shadow."
9:09 p.m.: The Rams didn't make a deal with the Browns, but they found a partner with Buffalo, moving up to the No. 8 spot to take West Virginia's mercurial slotback Tavon Austin.
Bills receive No. 16, No. 46, No. 78 and No. 222. Rams receive Austin, No. 71.
9:03 p.m.: The Arizona Cardinals take offensive guard Jonathan Cooper from North Carolina.
8:55 p.m.: The Browns take Barkevious Mingo to beef up the rush linebacker position.
From STATS inc.: "He started 10 of 13 games as a junior, earning second-team All-SEC honors and finishing with 8.5 tackles for loss and 4.5 sacks. Those numbers were down after he had 8.0 sacks and 15.0 tackles for loss as a sophomore in mostly a reserve role. Known by his nickname KeKe (pronounced Key-Key), Mingo solidified his draft status at the combine. Among defensive linemen, his 4.58 40-yard dash time ranked second and his 37-inch vertical leap tied for second. Mingo turned in a broad jump of 128 inches and showcased his agility with a time of 6.84 seconds in the 3-cone drill, cementing his status as a freakish athlete."
8:50 p.m.: Detroit, with defensive needs across the board, selects Brigham Young's Ziggy Ansah.
Mingo or Milliner? Milliner or Mingo?
8:48 p.m.: With Ziggy Ansah, Dee Milliner and Barkevious Mingo still on the board, there seems little reason for the Browns to trade down.
NFL Draft 2013
- What: 78th annual NFL Player Selection Meeting.
- When: Today, Round 1, 8 p.m.; Friday, Rounds 2-3, 6:30 p.m.; Saturday, Rounds 4-7, noon.Â
- Where: Radio City Music Hall, New York City.
- TV: NFL Network and ESPN.
- Time limits: Teams have a 10-minute time limit per selection in the first round, seven minutes in the second round, and five minutes in rounds 3-7.
- Selections: There will be 254 selections, including 32 compensatory picks awarded to 16 teams for free agency losses.
- Browns picks: Round 1, No. 6. Round 3, No. 6, 68th overall. Round 4, No. 7, 104th overall. Round 5, No. 6, 139th overall, and No. 31, 164th overall (from San Francisco). Round 6, No. 7, 175th overall. Round 7, No. 21, 227th overall (from Cincinnati, through San Francisco).
Related stories
8:42 p.m.: The Eagles needed offensive line help, which gives them the chance to draft Oklahoma's Lane Johnson to become the new left tackle.
8:34 p.m.: The Oakland Raiders, considered to be the great unknown at the top of the draft (and Al Davis), traded down with Miami, who took the favorite of Browns fans, Oregon defensive end Dion Jordan.
Jon Gruden is "shocked." The Raiders will get the No. 12 pick and the 10th pick in the second round, the 42nd overall.
8:30 p.m.: There's been talk that the Rams -- who want Tavon Austin and are at 16 -- might be interested in dealing with the Browns. But not everyone is buying that as a good matchup of interests.
8:25 p.m.: Jacksonville takes Texas A&M offensive tackle Luke Joeckel.
That figures to cut into the Browns' trade opportunities, and the possibility of Dion Jordan to the Browns is growing significantly, assuming he doesn't go to Philadelphia.
8:16 p.m.: Kansas City takes, as expected, Central Michigan offensive tackle Eric Fisher. They used most of their 10 minutes, presumably to make sure no stunning trade offers materialize.
Before the pick, Jon Gruden points out that the Chiefs had six players in the last Pro Bowl, then added "I'm not sure about the Pro Bowl."
8:05 p.m.: Roger Goodell opens the draft with words of tribute to the first responders in Boston and West Texas, earning loud applause from the fans, and some "U-S-A" chants.
8 p.m.: From Mary Kay Cabot, perhaps reflecting momentum that has been building throughout the afternoon.
CBS Sports' Jason LaConfora decided to really work hard in the last hour, and pounded out one last mock draft ... giving the Browns Oregon's Dion Jordan with the sixth pick.
7:54 p.m.: From ESPN's Adam Schefter ...
7:53 p.m.: Yes, the rumors and Twitter have quieted ... everyone is finally waiting for the Chiefs and the real news of the day to occur.
7:44 p.m.: It's easy to consider the players tonight as simple commodities, but Yahoo! has a pretty sweet little video story on Ziggy Ansah, who is having quite a day.
From the Deseret News in Salt Lake City: "Ansah would love to be an ambassador for the NFL someday, promoting football in his homeland of Ghana, where, for now, there is little interest in the sport."
"'That's what I want to do,' Ansah said. 'It's something I want to try to do after I'm done playing — take it back to Africa and help the little kids with it.'"
For an athlete who has a life story certainly unlike anyone who will be cheering him this fall, it's pretty impressive. Congrats to him.
7:39 p.m.: The NFL is currently running all of the prospects who are present at Radio City Music Hall out on the stage for a group picture. No truth to the rumor that fans in attendance are being asked who will be stuck in the green room until midnight.
7:35 p.m.: This Tweet on Mike Mayock's favorite cornerback sparked a flurry of interest from Browns fans.
In the WFNY's mock draft spreadsheet, the soonest that anyone speculated on Hayden's selection was at No. 11.
7:21 p.m.: A tip of the hat to Wait For Next Year's Jacob Rosen, who culled all the various "serious" mocks around the blogosphere, and did a consensus draft this week that -- at the very least -- delivers a pretty sane scenario for all the teams.
Then again, who ever said the NFL Draft was a sane experience?
7:15 p.m.: Just a thought after a long day of listening to local sports talk ... some guys really, truly seem to have a QB fetish. Just saying.
7:11 p.m.: It takes a fair amount of nerve, but a few draftniks around the country were willing to project a seven-round mock draft (yes, we know ... emphasis on mock). For those of us interested in names beyond the first round, it offers some grist for the fans' mill.
Here's a few.
Chris Fedor, Cleveland.com: 1. CB Dee Milliner, Alabama. 3. DE/OLB Quanterus Smith, Western Kentucky. 4. QB Tyler Bray, Tennessee. 5. WR Josh Boyce, TCU; S Josh Evans, Florida. 6. CB Nickell Robey, USC. 7. OLB Walter Stewart, Cincinnati.
Sporting News: 1. CB Dee Milliner, Alabama. 3. QB Tyler Bray, Tennessee. 4. WR Trey Boyce, TCU. 5. TE Chris Cragg, Arkansas; S J.J. Wilcox, Georgia Southern. 6. ILB Christian Robinson, Georgia. 7. RB Chris Thompson, Florida State.
Charlie Campbell (Walterfootball.com): 1. Trade down or CB Dee Milliner, Alabama. 3. TE Nick Kasa, Colorado. 4. WR Kenny Stills, Oklahoma. 5. OG Brian Winters, Kent State; RB Joseph Randle, Oklahoma State; 6. DT Josh Boyd, Mississippi State; 7. CB Trey Wilson, Vanderbilt.
Drafttek.com: 1. DE Barkevious Mingo. 3. CB Logan Ryan, Rutgers. 4. TE Vance McDonald, Rice. 5. SS Duke Williams, Nevada; DE William Campbell, Michigan. 6. K Caleb Sturgis, Florida. 7. FB Tommy Bohanon, Wake Forest.
Josh Norris, NFL.com: 1. CB Dee Milliner. 3. LB Sio Moore, Connecticut. 4. QB Tyler Bray, Tennessee. 5. WR Denard Robinson, Michigan; Joseph Randle, RB, Oklahoma State. 6. S T.J. McDonald, USC. 7. DT. T.J. Barnes, Georgia Tech.
Behind the Steel Curtain, SB Nation: 1. (trade down) DE Barkevious Mingo, LSU. 2. OG Larry Warmack, Kentucky. 3. QB Matt Barkley, USC. 4. CB Logan Ryan, Rutgers. 5. WR Kenny Stills, Oklahoma; ILB A.J. Klein, Iowa State. 6. DE/OLB Walter Stewart, Cincinnati. 7. SS Don Jones, Arkansas State.
7 p.m.: So far, the expectation is that Central Michigan tackle Eric Fisher will be the first player off the board to Kansas City, beating out Texas A&M's Luke Joeckel for the honor.
If true, that puts Jacksonville at No. 2 in the driver's seat in potentially spoiling the Browns' trade-down plans. The Jaguars weren't believed to be that high on Fisher, but supposedly are more than willing to take Joeckel at No. 2. Since most pre-draft Browns trade scenarios require Oklahoma's Lane Johnson to be available when the Browns go on the clock, that requires Oakland, Philadelphia and Detroit to go in other directions. Both the Eagles and Lions could well want a potential left tackle.
But hey, it's just the latest bunch of rumors.
Latest on the Browns ... the Ryan Mallett rumors have quieted and Wednesday's hot report that they might want to move up has been quashed.
The NFL Network continues to suggest an interest in Geno Smith (Mayock) or E.J. Manuel (Wilcots), but pretty much everyone else has backed off.
Meanwhile, with 60 minutes remaining before Roger Goodell accepts the obligatory boos in New York, let's take a quick look at how the NFL's own website analyzes the top of the talent pool.
First of all, the league's ratings are based on a scale of 20 to 100, broken down this way.
96-100 / Future Hall of Famer: A once-in-a-generation type prospect who could change how his position is played.
85-95 / Immediate Starter: An impact player with the ability/intangibles to become a Pro Bowl player. Expect to start immediately except in a unique situation (i.e. behind a veteran starter).
70-84 / Eventual Starter: A quality player who will contribute to the team early on and is expected to develop into a starter. A reliable player who brings value to the position.
50-69 / Draftable Player: A prospect with the ability to make team as a backup/role player. Needs to be a special teams contributor at applicable positions. Players in the high range of this category might have long-term potential.
20-49 / Free Agent: A player with solid measurables, intangibles, college achievements, or a developing skill that warrants an opportunity in an NFL camp. In the right situation, he could earn a place on a 53-man roster, but most likely will be a practice squad player or a camp body.
And here we have our first grain of salt warning of the night. Last year, a player graded in the mid-40s -- a fill-out the roster kind of guy, according to the NFL's own rating -- was Washington Redskins rookie running back Alfred Morris. Don't think Mike Shanahan is regretting that sixth-round selection.
So yes, even the league's own ratings aren't exactly gospel. Keep that in mind when you're dumbfounded by a selection that doesn't match the draft guide in your hand or talk radio's expectations.
Here are the 29 players listed by the NFL Thursday afternoon as at least immediate starters for their new teams.
Offensive line: OG Chance Warmack, Alabama, 93.9; OT Luke Joeckel, Texas A&M, 95.3; OT Eric Fisher, Central Michigan, 94.0; OT Lane Johnson, Oklahoma, 92.9; OG Larry Warford, Kentucky, 88.3; OG Jonathan Cooper, North Carolina, 86.9; OT D.J. Fluker, Alabama, 85.5; OT Menelik Watson, Florida St., 85.0
Defensive line: DT Sharrif Floyd, Florida, 94.2; DE Dion Jordan, Oregon, 93.5; DE Barkevious Mingo, LSU, 92.8; DT Star Lotulelei, Utah, 92.0; DE Ziggy Ansah, BYU, 91.3; DT Sheldon Richardson, Missouri, 90.7; DE Bjoern Werner, Florida St., 88.2; DE Damontre Moore, Texas A&M, 87.9; DE Datone Jones, UCLA, 85.6; DT Jesse Williams, Alabama, 85.5; DE Cornellius Carradine, Florida St., 85.4; DE Alex Okafor, Texas, 85.2
Cornerback: Dee Milliner, Alabama, 93.2; Xavier Rhodes, Florida St., 86.2; CB Jamar Taylor, Boise St., 85.5
Receiver/tight end: WR Tavon Austin, West Virginia, 91.4; WR Cordarrelle Patterson, Tennessee, 90.6; WR DeAndre Hopkins, Clemson, 87.8; WR Keenan Allen, California, 86.3
Safety: FS John Cyprien, Florida International, 90.6; SS Kenny Vaccaro, Texas, 87.7
Linebacker: ILB Arthur Brown, Kansas St., 90.3; OLB Jarvis Jones, Georgia, 88.8; ILB Manti Te'o, Notre Dame, 87.5
Quarterback: Geno Smith, West Virginia, 88.0
A word to the wise by a savvy ESPN sports business reporter.