The Ubaldo Jimenez trade was celebrated for its boldness but now even that is questionable, Bud Shaw writes in his Spin column.
Chuck Crow, The Plain DealerUbaldo Jimenez was supposed to be the sign that the Indians were serious about contending -- in 2011, and for the next couple of years after that. Today, that sign looks like a "Wrong Way" warning, says Bud Shaw. CLEVELAND, Ohio -- When treading water gives you a sinking feeling...
Monday was the one-year anniversary of the Ubaldo Jimenez trade. Miss Manners says the appropriate gift for such an occasion is paper. In this case, the Indians have inadvertently asked for a "Dear John" letter from their fan base.
The worst move would've been to become sellers at the trade deadline a year after dealing their two top prospects to Colorado and declaring a two-year window open to them. They didn't do that. The second worst was doing nothing at the deadline after doing next to nothing over the winter and as little as possible with the signing of Johnny Damon.
The Jimenez trade became even more of a muddled statement when the Indians failed to add to the playoff chase again in 2012.
The rich teams can cover the mistakes they make in the free-wheeling signing of free agents. The poor teams bottom feed in free agency. That's not often a killer (or a huge help). What is a killer is missing on maximizing big trades (Cliff Lee, C.C. Sabathia).
Where does the Jimenez trade fit? Did it make them gun-shy this time around? Or just reduce the bait they had to make a deal?
You'd say it's not quite a complete disaster based on what pitchers Drew Pomeranz and Alex White have done in Colorado. But not having one or both of those prospects to either help a bad rotation or to bolster a pennant chase this season has contributed to the status quo heading into August.
A year later, Jimenez is part of an under-performing starting rotation that in the short term turns to Columbus (Corey Kluber) for resuscitation and in the longer term needs Roberto Hernandez to pitch like Fausto Carmona of 2007.
PD fileNot all of the Indians' woes in 2012 fall on Chris Antonetti (with manager Manny Acta), but it's clear that there weren't a lot of successful personnel decisions made since the end of the 2011 campaign. Not everything falls on the head of GM Chris Antonetti. To say things didn't go according to plan is like saying Damon doesn't have a gun for an arm. Zach McAllister is the Indians' best pitcher. Michael Brantley is the cleanup hitter.
That's great news if you're the Columbus Clippers. Jose Lopez was the cleanup hitter, three weeks after he was designated for assignment.
By the time this trade deadline rolled around, the Indians had too many needs to fill and not enough trade pieces to fill them without giving up core players.
Some of that was under-performance. But Antonetti shares the blame for not landing Josh Willingham in the off-season and betting instead on Grady Sizemore. While he made the right kind of deal last year in obtaining Jimenez, all indications are it was for the wrong guy. The Jimenez trade only made sense if the front office and ownership agreed the playoff chase was on, even at the risk of deficit spending, through 2014.
Antonetti is dealing with legitimate constraints for sure. These windows of contention seem tighter fits as the years go by.
And there remains the issue of a fan base that seems ever closer to throwing open its own window and screaming that it's not going to take it anymore.
SPINOFFS
Eight Olympic badminton players were sent home from London for trying to lose to get a better draw in the next round. They let the shuttlecock fall in front of them. They deliberately served it out of bounds.
Presumably because they thought wearing flip flops and holding a beer cozy would look too obvious. ...
AP fileWhen it comes to all-time greatest Olympians, Bud Shaw would prefer a high-flying Carl Lewis -- or Jesse Owens, for that matter -- over Michael Phelps. Michael Phelps winning his 19th medal doesn't make him the greatest Olympian in history. It makes him the winningest Olympian in history.
Remember when British decathlete Daley Thompson won the gold in 1984 and wore a T-shirt questioning Carl Lewis' sexuality to the post-event press conference? It read, "Is the world's second greatest athlete gay?"
Lewis would rank ahead of Phelps in my book, as would Jesse Owens. I don't care about anyone's sexuality. I'm just pretty sure the world's greatest Olympian isn't a swimmer. ...
With baseball and softball gone from the Olympics, any sport routinely played at a picnic should also be under consideration for expulsion. I know that's not what officials with the U.S. Cornhole and Jarts Association wants to hear. ...
The worst Olympic sport since doubles luge: synchronized diving. Whatever the arguments on its behalf, they stall on one critical cross-examination question: Why stop at two? ...
Chinese swimmer Ye Shiwen was asked about the doping suspicions following her after she swam much faster than her previous personal best -- including swimming her final 50 in the 400 IM faster than U.S. men's star Ryan Lochte did in his event.
"It's a little unfair," she said, in what has to be the strongest denial since Jerry Sandusky agreed to that interview with Bob Costas. ...
NBC paid $1.18 billion for the TV rights. And critics want them to put the Games on live at noon? Spoiler alert: That's not going to happen...
I fully expect that when I die I'll see a white light drawing me to heaven and hear a continuous loop of ESPN analysts discussing the dynamics of a Mark Sanchez-Tim Tebow quarterback tandem coming from the opposite direction. ...
Players at the New Orleans' Saints practice facility walked in to find a 30 x 30 banner of suspended coach Sean Payton looking agitated. The message: "Do Your Job."
That's a change from last year's picture of Dog The Bounty Hunter. ...
Lars Anderson, the Tribe's newest acquisition is said to have "plate discipline and gap power." What were the chances it would be left-handed gap power? ...
If you can get interested -- let alone excited -- watching the U.S. men's Olympic basketball play Tunisia, you probably swat flies with a wrecking ball. ...
So if the Chicago Cubs were willing to pick up so much of Alfonso Soriano's salary as everyone kept saying, why didn't any team take him? ...
Braylon Edwards, coming off his poorest season, signed with the Seattle Seahawks. Not sure if he has a "Seattle essence" or if that's Eau de Desperation we smell on him at this point of his career. ...
Bovada is supplying new World Series odds to reflect the deals made at the trade deadline. The Indians are now listed at 75-1, same as the Phillies -- who are 15 1/2 games out of first and just traded Hunter Pence and Shane Victorino.
And, as Charlie Manuel would say, things of that sort. ...
HE SAID IT
"They need to change this now. People who are watching right now will be turning off in droves and losing even more interest." -- John McEnroe, not on the Indians' season but instead on Olympic badminton teams throwing games to improve their draws in the next round.
YOU SAID IT
(The Expanded Midweek Edition)
"Hey Bud:
"Ubaldo Jimenez said that the trade rumors were unnerving last year. Did you find it unnerving having Shaw's Spin banished to page C10 on Sunday?" -- Doug, Westlake
I'm just happy when I wake up and it hasn't been optioned to the Columbus Dispatch.
"Hey Bud:
"What if the Indians spent a lot to get a really good free agent in the off-season? What if we spent the money to keep really good players from leaving? What if we signed players who are not injured?" -- Amy, University Heights
As if.
"Bud:
"Is 'Lars' Norwegian for 'Can't Hit Curveball'?" -- Jim Corrigan
That's a common error in translation. It's actually Norwegian for Matt.
"Bud:
"If a Browns player becomes disoriented after scoring a touchdown, can that be called a Happy Daze?" -- James D, Richmond Heights
What's this "touchdown" thing you speak of?
"Hey Bud:
"With the great response you've received, have you ever thought of going big time with an Awards Program like The Spinnies?" -- Russ
No. I would need to rent out an appropriately-sized venue and you just can't find a telephone booth these days.
"Bud:
"Did I read correctly? The Indians traded a comedian to the Red Sox for the Metallica drummer?" -- Tom Goodsite, Kirksville, Mo.
First-time "You Said It" winners receive a T-shirt from the Mental Floss collection.
"Dear Bud:
"Was it Abraham Lincoln who said, 'Better to remain trade-less and be thought a fool than to make a trade and remove all doubt'?" -- Vince G., Cincinnati
Repeat winners get a T-shirt in four score and seven years.
"Bud:
"I thought they took the slides out of Progressive Field?" -- Peggy Good
Repeat winners get snowed.
On Twitter: @budshaw