(Re-posted from last April) Second of a five-part series, with links to game stories, videos, etc. Not a ranking of the 100 best players drafted by Cleveland, but an estimation of the 100 best Browns' picks weighing contribution versus pick investment.
Plain Dealer file photoBrowns running back Bo Scott (35, right) follows the blocking of center Bob DeMarco (left Browns blocker) and Hall of Fame guard Gene Hickerson (right Browns blocker).
CLEVELAND, Ohio
(UPDATE: Re-post from last April, as the 2011 NFL draft approached)
Today we continue our countdown of the Cleveland Browns' 100 best draft picks of all time, with picks Nos. 80-61.
Browns best all-time picks Nos. 100-81 were posted on Monday. Nos. 60-41, 40-21 and 20-1 will be posted Wednesday through Friday.
This is not a ranking of the 100 best players drafted by Cleveland. Instead, it's an estimation of the 100 best Browns' picks in terms of value. Simply, a Player A taken by the Browns with, say, the 120th overall pick, turned out to be a better pick for value than did a Player B who might have contributed a little more but was a 55th overall pick.
Only players who played at least three seasons with the Browns after being picked by the team in the annual draft were considered.
Players acquired through a rare supplemental draft, such as Bernie Kosar, Kevin Mack and Mike Johnson, aren't included because the mechanics of the supplemental draft are not comparable to the regular draft.
Browns greats such as Otto Graham, Marion Motley, Lou Groza, Dante Lavelli, etc., aren't included, as they began their Browns' careers in the All-America Football Conference.
Performance with the Browns only is considered. For instance, future Hall of Famers Doug Atkins, Willie Davis, Henry Jordan and Dick LeBeau were Browns' draft picks from 1953-59. LeBeau was cut by the Browns before playing for them. The other three were traded by the Browns after just two seasons each as part-time players.
Playoff game performances were considered. Statistics are only for what a player did with the Browns. Statistical considerations in the rankings recognize that the game has become more pass-oriented in the last 30 years or so. Also, some players' values are enhanced by what the Browns eventually got for them in trades.
Only occasionally is it considered who the Browns didn't take. The value of 1976 picks Mike Pruitt (seventh) and Dave Logan (65th) shouldn't be diminished because they and no other team selected future Hall of Fame tackle Jackie Slater until the Los Angeles Rams took him 86th.
Positions: Offense -- QB, quarterback; RB, running back; FB, fullback; WR, wide receiver; TE, tight end; C, center; G, guard; T, tackle; PK, placekicker; P, punter; Rtn, kickoff and/or punt returner; LS, long snapper.
Defense -- E, end; T, tackle; NT, nose tackle; LB, linebacker; CB, cornerback; S, safety; DB, cornerback and safety.
Key: ranking number, player, position, year drafted, round/overall pick number, college, years with Browns:
80. Clinton Burrell, CB-S, 1979, 6/151, Louisiana State, 1979-84. Won a starting cornerback job for two seasons -- though one was shortened by injury -- and started at strong safety another two years. Came up with 10 turnovers in 24 games during the Browns' 1980 and 1982 playoff seasons.
79. Jeff Faine, C, 2003, 1/21, Notre Dame, 2003-05. A solid player on mediocre, at best, offensive lines. Traded to New Orleans for the pick used to take D'Qwell Jackson. The Browns had just signed the Saints' star center, Cleveland native LeCharles Bentley, as a free agent. Bentley never played again, suffering what turned out to be a career-ending knee injury at the start of Browns training camp.
78. D'Qwell Jackson, LB, 2006, 2/34, Maryland, 2006-10. Has played 49 games, all as a starter, and missed 31 -- including 26 in the last two years -- with injuries. Seemed headed for stardom when his 188 tackles in 2008 led the NFL. Still, at age 27, has a chance. (Ranking made prior to the 2011 season)
Video: D'Qwell Jackson as a linebacker at Maryland (videos are from youtube.com):
77. Bo Scott, RB-Rtn, 1965, 3/32, Ohio State, 1969-74. Delayed his NFL career four years by playing in the Canadian Football League. Averaged 28.9 yards on 25 kickoff returns in his first Browns season. The next three years, he probably made as many big plays as any skill position player on the team.
The Plain Dealer's Browns History Database includes the PD game stories on every regular season and playoff game in Browns history. Bo Scott had two short touchdown runs in the Browns' 38-14 romp over the Cowboys in a 1969 playoff game at Dallas. The late Chuck Heaton, The PD's longtime Browns beat writer, wrote the game story. Unfortunately, the Browns have not won a playoff game on the road since.
Video: Early in this segment from the Browns' 31-21 win over the New York Jets on Sept. 21, 1970 -- the first game as ABC kicked off its famed Monday Night Football series (Chuck Heaton's game story) -- Bo Scott scampers around left end for a touchdown:
76. Ryan Pontbriand, LS, 2003, 5/142, Rice, 2003-10. Has a strictly defined but very important role, and seldom makes a mistake. Made the Pro Bowl teams for his work in the 2007 and 2008 seasons. (Ranking made prior to the 2011 season)
75. Reggie Camp, DE, 1983, 3/68, California, 1983-87. Totaled 35 sacks, including 34 in his first four seasons, when he started every game.
74. Kevin Johnson, WR, 1999, 2/32, Syracuse, 1999-2003. Browns offense struggled during most of his 4 1/2 seasons, but he was tough and productive, with 315 receptions for 3,836 yards and 23 touchdowns.
73. Gerry Sullivan, T-C-LS, 1974, 7/171, Illinois, 1974-81. Missed one game in his career. Made just 26 starts, but he was reliably effective and on the field much more than that number indicates.
72. Kamerion Wimbley, LB, 2006, 1/13, Florida State, 2006-09. The team's best pass rusher during much of his time with the Browns, but wasn't very consistent after an outstanding rookie season. Browns had reportedly debated whether to draft Wimbley or current Ravens star Haloti Ngata at No. 12, then flipped picks with Baltimore and got a sixth-round pick from the Ravens, who selected Ngata. Four years later, some observers thought the Browns under-valued Wimbley when they traded him to Oakland for a third-round pick.
71. Ahtyba Rubin, DT, 2008, 6/190, Iowa State, 2008-10. Based on how he played the last 1 1/2 seasons, Rubin could become a star if he can make the transition from playing in a 3-4 defense to playing in a 4-3. (Ranking made prior to the 2011 season)
70. Junior Wren, S, 1952, 24/288, Missouri, 1956-59. Started his last three seasons and played well, helping the Browns cope with the gradual loss to age of what had been one of the game's all-time great secondaries.
69. Tony Peters, CB-S, 1975, 4/82, Oklahoma, 1975-78. Played all 58 games and made 51 starts, before the Browns traded him to Washington -- where he excelled -- for fourth-, fifth- and 10th-round picks.
68. Walt Sumner, CB-S, 1969, 7/176, Florida State, 1969-74. A starter during almost all of his six seasons, he helped the Browns go 43-24-3 his first five seasons, before enduring a then-franchise worst 4-10 1974 camapaign.
Video: Highlights of the Browns' 38-14 rout of the Cowboys in a 1969 season divisional playoff game in Dallas. Walt Sumner intercepted a Craig Morton pass and returned it 88 yards for a touchdown and the Browns' final score.
67. Carlton Massey, DE, 1953, 8/95, Texas, 1954-56. Made one Pro Bowl team. Helped a dominating Browns defense hold the powerful Lions' and Rams' offenses to 10 and 14 points, respectively, as the Browns won the 1954 and 1955 championship games.
66. Jim Kanicki, DT, 1963, 2/23, Michigan State, 1963-69. A solid starter his last six seasons with the Browns. Played a great game in the Browns' 27-0 championship win over the Colts in 1964.
65. Ross Fichtner, S, 1960, 3/33, Purdue, 1960-67. Intercepted 27 passes and returned three for touchdowns. A second-team all-NFL pick in 1966.
Fichtner intercepted three passes and returned them for 98 yards in the Browns' 30-21 win over the Cowboys on Oct. 23, 1966. Chuck Heaton wrote the game story for The Plain Dealer.
64. Anthony Henry, CB, 2001, 4/97, South Florida, 2001-04. Led the NFL with 10 interceptions as a rookie, and totaled 17 as a Brown. Left for the Cowboys as a free agent after four seasons.
63. Andra Davis, LB, 2002, 5/141, Florida, 2002-08. Played middle linebacker in the 4-3 and left inside LB in the 3-4. Had seasons of 149 and 138 tackles. Started 87 games in his last six Browns seasons.
62. Dale Lindsey, LB, 1965, 7/97, Western Kentucky, 1965-72. A starter for seven seasons, sometimes at middle linebacker, sometimes on the outside. A year too late for the 1964 title team, but he was a steady key to the Browns going 75-36-1 during his career.
Video: Highlights of the Browns' 31-20 upset win over the Cowboys in a 1968 playoff game at Cleveland Stadium. Dale Lindsey (51) intercepted a Don Meredith pass early in the third quarter and returned it for a touchdown and a 17-10 Browns lead. They led the rest of the way.
Plain Dealer Browns beat writer Chuck Heaton wrote the game story about the 31-20 Browns win.
61. Charlie Hall, LB, 1971, 3/68, Houston, 1971-80. Played all 146 games during his steady career, and started all 132 after his rookie campaign. Always played outside with his solid pass coverage