(Re-posted from last April) First of a five-part series, with links to game stories, videos, etc. Not a ranking of the 100 best players drafted by Cleveland, but an estimation of the 100 best Browns' picks weighing contribution versus pick investment.
Plain Dealer file photoRunning back Leroy Hoard eludes the would-be tackle of New England's Maurice Hurst during the Browns' 20-13 wild card playoff win over the Patriots on Jan. 1, 1995 in Cleveland Municipal Stadium.
CLEVELAND, Ohio
(UPDATE: Re-post from last April, as the 2011 NFL draft approached. The other four installments will be posted daily, Tuesday through Friday)
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Today we begin our countdown of the Cleveland Browns' 100 best draft picks of all-time. Today, Nos. 100 through 81. Each of the next four days, we will count down the next 20 best.
This is not a ranking of the 100 best players drafted by Cleveland. Instead, it's an estimation of the 100 best Browns' picks in terms of value. Simply, a Player A taken by the Browns with, say, the 120th overall pick, turned out to be a better pick for value than did a Player B who might have contributed a little more but was a 55th overall pick.
Only players who played at least three seasons with the Browns after being picked by the team in the annual draft were considered.
Players acquired through a rare supplemental draft, such as Bernie Kosar, Kevin Mack and Mike Johnson, aren't included because the mechanics of the supplemental draft are not comparable to the regular draft.
Browns greats such as Otto Graham, Marion Motley, Lou Groza, Dante Lavelli, etc., aren't included, as they began their Browns' careers in the All-America Football Conference.
Performance with the Browns only is considered. For instance, future Hall of Famers Doug Atkins, Willie Davis, Henry Jordan and Dick LeBeau were Browns' draft picks from 1953-59. LeBeau was cut by the Browns before playing for them. The other three were traded by the Browns after just two seasons each as part-time players.
Playoff game performances were considered. Statistics are only for what a player did with the Browns. Statistical considerations in the rankings recognize that the game has become more pass-oriented in the last 30 years or so. Also, some players' values are enhanced by what the Browns eventually got for them in trades.
Only occasionally is it considered who the Browns didn't take. The value of 1976 picks Mike Pruitt (seventh) and Dave Logan (65th) shouldn't be diminished because they and no other team selected future Hall of Fame tackle Jackie Slater until the Los Angeles Rams took him 86th.
Positions: Offense -- QB, quarterback; RB, running back; FB, fullback; WR, wide receiver; TE, tight end; C, center; G, guard; T, tackle; PK, placekicker; P, punter; Rtn, kickoff and/or punt returner; LS, long snapper.
Defense -- E, end; T, tackle; NT, nose tackle; LB, linebacker; CB, cornerback; S, safety; DB, cornerback and safety.
Key: ranking number, player, position, year drafted, round/overall pick number, college, years with Browns:
100. Jim Copeland, G-C, 1967, 10/255, Virginia, 1967-74. Versatile backup played on five playoff teams and was an important contributor on four of them. A special teams standout.
99. Dave Puzzuoli, NT, 1983, 6/149, Pittsburgh, 1983-87. Played in every game except the three with "replacement players" during the 1987 strike. Provided strong inside pass rush, his landmark moment being the sack of John Elway that temporarily de-railed "The Drive."
98. Bobby Franklin, S-CB, 1960, 11/127, Mississippi, 1960-66. Started four years in the secondary. Held on place-kicks for the legendary Lou Groza. Excelled at the task during an era when place-kick execution was erratic for most NFL teams, but usually not for the Browns.
Video: Highlights of the 1964 Browns last two regular season games, and their 27-0 win over the Baltimore Colts in the NFL championship game. Six minutes into the video, Franklin (24) celebrates Lou Groza's field goal that gave the Browns a 3-0 lead over Baltimore (videos are from youtube.com):
Franklin's greatest game was on Dec. 11, 1960, when he intercepted three passes and ran back two of them for touchdowns during the Browns' 42-0 rout of the Chicago Bears at Cleveland Municipal Stadium. The Plain Dealer's Browns History Database includes PD game stories on every regular season and playoff game in Browns history. The late Chuck Heaton, The PD's longtime Browns beat writer, wrote about the big day for Franklin and the Browns.
97. Steve Everitt, C, 1993, 1/14, Michigan, 1993-95. Wasn't the dominating player the Browns hoped he would be, but was steady in the team's last three seasons before the move to Baltimore.
96. Eric Wright, CB, 2007, 2/53, UNLV, 2007-10. A surprisingly poor 2010 season, when he was picked on by opponents, followed three solid campaigns.
95. Brodney Pool, S, 2005, 2/34, Oklahoma, 2005-09. Good enough at coverage that he played some cornerback early in his Browns career. Suffered four concussions as a Brown.
94. Jim Shofner, CB, 1958, 1/11, Texas Christian, 1958-63. A reliable starter his last five seasons, he intercepted 20 passes and recovered seven fumbles. Was 1-6 as Browns' interim coach in 1990.
Plain Dealer Browns beat writer Mary Kay Cabot's game story on Shofner's debut as the Browns coach.
93. Ken Carpenter, RB-Rtn, 1950, 1/13, Oregon State, 1950-53. As a young player on a star-studded veteran roster, didn't get an abundance of touches -- 8.3 per game -- but was productive when he got them.
92. Rickey Bolden, T-G-TE, 1984, 4/96, Southern Methodist, 1984-89. Missed 34 games with injuries. His talent was evident, usually lining up at left tackle as Bernie Kosar's chief pass protector.
91. Fair Hooker, WR, 1969, 5/124, Arizona State. Made clutch catches to help aging Browns' teams in 1971 and 1972 make the playoffs. In a 1972 playoff game at Miami, caught a 27-yard fourth-quarter touchdown pass from Mike Phipps to give Cleveland a 14-13 lead. Dolphins followed with a season-saving touchdown drive, and went on to become Super Bowl champs with the only perfect season in NFL history. Chuck Heaton wrote about the Browns' 20-14 loss to the Dolphins on Dec. 24, 1972.
Video: Fair Hooker (No. 43) catches some passes from Bill Nelsen in Part 1 of the 1971 Browns highlight film:
90. Scott Nicolas, LB-LS, 1982, 12/310, Miami (Fla.), 1982-86. Didn't miss a game, made eight starts one season at LB, and was a special teams standout -- including as the long snapper.
89. Larry Williams, G, 1985, 10/259, Notre Dame, 1986-88. Good enough to make 33 starts for a diversified Browns' offense that featured a veteran line.
88. Henry Sheppard, G-T, 1976, 5/130, Southern Methodist, 1976-81. Missed just three games. Started 42 games at left guard and 16 at right tackle from 1977-80, helping the "Kardiac Kids" of 1979-80 to many improbable comeback wins.
87. Dennis Northcutt, WR-Rtn, 2000, 2/32, Arizona, 2000-06. Caught 276 passes. Finished among the NFL's top five in yards per punt return in four seasons.
86. Preston Carpenter, WR-RB, 1956, 1/13, Arkanasas, 1956-59. Had a big rookie season as a running back and kickoff returner. Along came Jim Brown, though, and Carpenter made a successful transition to wide receiver.
85. James A. Jones, DT, 1991, 3/57, Northern Iowa, 1991-94. Didn't miss a game and made 49 starts. Scored touchdowns on an interception return, and when coach Bill Belichick called his number for a 1-yard TD run and a 1-yard TD reception.
84. Leroy Hoard, RB, 1990, 2/45, Michigan, 1990-95. Made the 1994 Pro Bowl team with 890 rushing yards and 445 receiving yards. Then had a fine game in the Browns' 20-13 wild card playoff win over New England -- Cleveland's only postseason win since 1989.
Video: Immediately in this video of the 1989 season Rose Bowl game between Michigan and USC, Leroy Hoard makes plays that had to impress NFL scouts:
83. Bob McKay, T-G, 1970, 1/21, Texas, 1970-75. Missed 17 games with injuries, but was an above-average blocker when healthy. Traded to New England for established cornerback Ron Bolton, who gave the Browns several good seasons.
Joshua Gunter, PDSean Jones (26) and Andra Davis during a 2008 training camp practice.
82. Sean Jones, S, 2004, 2/59, Georgia, 2004-08. Bounced back from a knee injury that cost him his rookie season. Intercepted 14 passes in his three seasons as a starter.
81. Daylon McCutcheon, CB, 1999, 3/62, USC, 1999-2005. Developed into a pretty good cover corner and was one of the team's best tacklers. Started 96 games, but couldn't get back on the field after having microfracture knee surgery