Eagles coach Andy Reid had both new Browns offensive coordinator Brad Childress and coach Pat Shurmur on his staff for seven years in Philadelphia, and he knows they will be a great combo -- regardless of who calls the plays.
Bradley C. Bower, AP file photoEagles coach Andy Reid, left, with Brad Childress in 2004. BEREA, Ohio — Philadelphia Eagles coach Andy Reid collaborated on a lot of play-calling over the years with new Browns offensive coordinator Brad Childress and coach Pat Shurmur, and he's confident they'll be successful together regardless of who handles that chore.
"Pat's a heck of a play-caller, and Brad's a heck of a play-caller, and I think that's a heck of a combination," Reid told The Plain Dealer. "Both of them can bounce things off of each other. That's what Brad did here with me, and that's what Pat did here with me. So, whether I was calling the plays or they were calling the plays, we had an open communication where we could talk and make the best of whatever situation there was."
Childress, a former Minnesota Vikings head coach, was hired by the Browns on Friday to be the first offensive coordinator under Shurmur, who called his own plays last season. Shurmur and Childress spent seven years together under Reid in Philadelphia, going 70-42 in those years with four trips to the NFC Championship Game and one appearance in the Super Bowl, a loss to New England.
Shurmur will retain play-calling duties for now, but the two will have plenty of discussions about that, and nothing has been finalized yet, an NFL source said. Shurmur said during his season-ending news conference that he'd relinquish the play-calling duties if the right person came along.
"They were a great combo for me here, and we sure won a lot of games with those two at the helm of my offense here, and so I wouldn't expect anything different," said Reid, who ran the same West Coast offense the Browns have in place. "They work very well together, and it's a great fit. The Cleveland Browns are getting a great person, No. 1, and a tremendous football coach. He's got a great football mind, and he has a great relationship with Pat. It's a win-win all the way around."
Reid cited the tremendous job Childress and Shurmur did with quarterback Donovan McNabb, who went to three Pro Bowls with Childress as quarterbacks coach and three more with Shurmur in that capacity.
"They did a phenomenal job with Donovan," said Reid. "Brad had Donovan when he was young, and Pat had him when he was a little older, and Brad never lost his relationship with Donovan when he became the coordinator. The two of them developed him very well. He was a great player, but they did a heck of a job with him."
Reid is confident they'll have the same impact on quarterback Colt McCoy, if the Browns decide to stick with him.
"Both of them understand it takes four years for a quarterback to fully mature or get close to full maturing in the NFL," said Reid. "It's not a bang-bang thing that happens overnight. They understand how to go through that process and how to teach quarterbacks and when to be a little tough on them and when you need to back off. They both have a great feel for that."
Reid said he was lucky to work with both Shurmur and Childress and that the Browns are in good hands.
"You hire guys that are driven and smart, and both of them fall under that category," he said. "Both of them have a great work ethic, and they understand the game, and they have a whole lot of football smarts. They're smart guys away from the football field, too, but they really know the game."
The Browns were unavailable for comment Friday, but a source told The Plain Dealer on Thursday that the team had narrowed its choices to Childress and former Green Bay Packers coach Mike Sherman, who was named Miami Dolphins offensive coordinator Friday night. Both men are clients of agent Bob LaMonte, who also represents Browns President Mike Holmgren, GM Tom Heckert and Shurmur.
Childress, 55, and Sherman, 57, also both interviewed for the Tampa Bay head coach job, which went to Rutgers coach Greg Schiano.
Despite his four seasons as a coordinator and four-plus as a head coach, Childress has called plays for only one season -- his first as Vikings head coach in 2006. That year, the Vikings finished 23rd in yards and 26th in points, and Childress handed the play-calling duties over to offensive coordinator Darrell Bevell.
The Vikings went on to improve steadily under Childress, winning consecutive division titles in 2008 and 2009, and reaching the NFC Championship Game in 2009 behind a fabulous year by quarterback Brett Favre, who led the team to a 12-4 mark with his 33 touchdown passes.
But it all unraveled in 2010 when Favre struggled and the Vikings lost three of their first four games. Things got ugly after Childress criticized Favre's decision-making, and receiver Randy Moss later criticized Childress. Childress ultimately released Moss without consulting owner Zygi Wilf, which contributed to his demise.
Childress sat out of football last year and wasn't interviewed for the Browns' offensive coordinator position. In Philadelphia, he was quarterbacks coach from 1999 to 2001 and coordinator from 2002 to '05. Shurmur was Eagles tight ends/offensive line coach from 1999 to 2001 and quarterbacks coach from 2002 to '08.
At his season-ending news conference Jan. 3, he said of Childress: "I know Brad very well. He and I worked together for a long time. I think he's a terrific coach."
Childress takes over an offense that finished 29th in total yards last season (288.8) and 30th in points per game (13.6). The Browns, with Shurmur as play-caller and the Browns down to their fourth and fifth running backs, scored 218 points -- one more than the expansion Browns of 1999.
Childress will help the Browns make key decisions such as whether or not McCoy can be their starter, whether or not to re-sign Peyton Hillis and what to do with the No. 4 and No. 22 picks in the first round. He'll be critical in the evaluation of quarterback prospects such as Baylor's Robert Griffin III and Texas A&M's Ryan Tannehill, who was coached by Sherman in college.
Childress has 33 years' coaching experience at the college and pro levels, including 13 in the NFL. His hiring gives the Browns two coordinators, including defensive coordinator Dick Jauron, with head coaching experience.