The Indians are looking to get more production from the outfield this year. To do that they must stay healthy because of cast of players hasn't changed that much.
Chuck Crow, The Plain DealerShin-Soo Choo had back-to-back .300 seasons halted by an injury- and mishap-plagued 2011. The Indians' hopes for contention largely depend on his return to a productive No. 3 hitter.
(Editor's note: This is the fourth of a four-part preview of the Indians with spring training looming next month. Previously: The starting rotation, the bullpen and the infield.)
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- From an offensive standpoint, the Indians' outfield was below average last season. Make that way below average.
Sure it had something to do with starters Michael Brantley, Grady Sizemore and Shin-Soo Choo spending significant time on the disabled list. As painful as it was to lose them, the problem was compounded because the Indians didn't have anyone in the minors ready to step in and their only outside solution was Kosuke Fukudome, who played well, but certainly wasn't capable of sparking an offense that finished ninth in the American League in runs.
In five offensive categories -- runs, batting average, homers, RBI and OPS -- Indians outfielders ranked in the top half only twice in the 14-team AL. Tribe center fielders ranked sixth with 87 runs and seventh with 68 RBI.
Indians right fielders never finished higher than 11th in the five categories. The best the left fielders could do was a ninth-place finish with 74 runs.
Headed into spring training, the Indians are going to try and correct the problem with a similar cast of players. They feel they can be competitive if Brantley, Sizemore and Choo can stay healthy. Brantley suffered a broken hamate bone in his right hand. Sizemore has been hobbled by injuries for the last three years. Choo suffered a broken left thumb and strained oblique muscle.
GM Chris Antonetti tried to change the makeup by offering Carlos Beltran a two-year, $24 million contract. Beltran signed with St. Louis. He also tried to work a deal for the Yankees' Nick Swisher, but to date nothing has come of it.
In the place of a dominant hitter, the Indians are going with numbers. There will be at least eight outfielders in camp besides Brantley, Sizemore and Choo. Shelley Duncan, Ezequiel Carrera, Thomas Neal, Nick Weglarz and Aaron Cunningham are on the 40-man roster. Felix Pie, Fred Lewis, Chad Huffman and Ryan Spilborghs received spring-training invitations. Jason Donald, an infielder by trade, will get a look in center and left in an attempt to get his right-handed bat in the lineup more frequently.
If Brantley, Sizemore and Choo, all left-handed hitters, open the season in the starting lineup, look for the extra outfielder(s) to be right-handed hitters. That's one of the reasons Fukudome, another left-handed hitter, was not re-signed as a free agent.
Duncan, who can also play first base, has to be a leading candidate. He hit .260 (58-for-223) with 17 doubles, 11 homers and 47 RBI last year. Spilborghs, Cunningham, Neal, Huffman hit right-handed as well.
One benefit of having a lot of outfielders in camp is that it can create depth in the upper levels of the system. Duncan and Cunningham are out of options, but there's a chance that Pie, Lewis, Spilborghs or Huffman might accept an assignment to the minors if they don't make the club out of spring training. Neal, Carrera and Weglarz have options.
AP fileShelley Duncan had an impressive September for the Indians. Will he find a semi-regular role in left field or first base in 2012?
Here's a look at the outfield options for 2012 (with age, bats/throws, last season's average, homers and RBI):
• CF Sizemore, 29, L/L, .224, 10 HR, 32 RBI: Indians brought Sizemore back on a one-year, $5 million deal. Can he make the gamble worthwhile by staying healthy?
• LF Brantley, 24, L/L, .266, 7, 46: He's an non-traditional left fielder who is better suited for a center field/leadoff role.
• RF Choo, 29, L/L, .259, 8, 36: All he needs to do is stay healthy and play every day.
• OF Duncan, 32, R/R, .260, 11, 47: Hit seven homers and drove in 23 runs in September.
• OF Carrera, 24, L/L, .243, 0, 14: Good change-of-pace player, but he has to get on base more and his defense has to improve.
• OF Neal, 24, R/R, .289, 2, 26 at Class AAA Fresno (Giants) and Class AAA Columbus: Acquired from the Giants for Orlando Cabrera. Slowed last year by right shoulder injury.
• OF Weglarz, 24, L/L, .179, 3, 12 at Class AA Akron: Has power and discipline at the plate, but can't stay healthy.
• OF Cunningham, 25, R/R, .178, 3, 9: Appeared in 52 games for San Diego last year, playing 18 in right, 13 in left.
• OF Pie, 26, L/L, .220, 0, 7: Played 85 games with Baltimore last year including 67 in left, six in center and three in right.
• OF Huffman, 26, R/R, .246, 13, 58 at Columbus: Could help as an extra outfielder.
• OF Lewis, 31, L/R, .230, 3, 19: Played 81 games with the Reds last year. He was 2-for-7 in stolen base attempts, but he can run.
• OF Spilborghs, 32, R/R, .210, 3, 22: A valuable utility player for years with the Rockies, Spilborghs' 2011 season was hindered by plantar fasciitis. Has a career OPS vs. LHP of .799.
On Twitter: @hoynsie