It's a near flood of questions that have reached Tony Grossi's mailbag.
AP fileSome Browns fans will never forgive the organization for not drafting Clay Matthews in 2009. Hey, Tony: Every time I watch Clay Matthews I get frustrated because it appears the Browns had two chances to draft him that year. He would have been a fan favorite plus his talent was apparent. What happened? -- Nancy Whitmire, Jacksonville, Fla.
Hey, Nancy: The previous regime liked Alex Mack better.
Hey, Tony: I know it didn't make a difference in the end, but wasn't Hue Jackson's decision to go for it on fourth down instead of kicking the chip-shot field goal one of the worst you've ever seen? How do you not make it a three-score game? Were the Raiders trying to run up the score? -- Jamie Vitonis, Boston
Hey, Jamie: Agree that that decision was a head-scratcher. Maybe it was out of Sebastian Janikowski's range. You know, too close?
Hey, Tony: Any reason why the Browns would not go after Brandon Lloyd? Our receivers are the worst in the league! Other than our 2012 draft picks and Atlanta's No. 1, do we have any other extra picks? -- Kris Kent, Canonsburg, Pa.
Hey, Kris: Lloyd is 30 and will be a free agent after the season. I would submit that the Rams' receivers are worse. Coincidentally, the Rams ultimately acquired Lloyd. The Browns own Atlanta's first- and fourth-round selections, and Denver's sixth.
Hey, Tony: It's becoming clearer that Colt McCoy is not the guy. His strengths were supposed to be football IQ and accuracy. Neither have been apparent in good-weather games against the softest portion of the schedule (and I don't believe the lack of experience excuse, he's played in 12 plus games over nearly 11/2 seasons). Things will get much worse in November/December when the weather will further limit the throws he's capable of making and playing four games against the Steelers and Ravens spells a lot of losing. My question is this: Projecting a 4-7 win season and a draft slot of 5-10, will the two 2012 first-round picks (guessing Atlanta's to be 15-20), the 2012 fourth from Atlanta, and a first from 2013 be enough for Andrew Luck? If not, how many additional picks would be required? Regardless of how people feel about McCoy, if you thought the next Peyton Manning was available, it would be stupid to not get him. -- Greg Cooper, Huntsville, Ala.
Hey, Greg: I would imagine three No. 1s and a No. 4 would be in the ballpark to move up for Luck. Would I do it? Without the slightest bit of hesitation.
Hey, Tony: Is the Browns' front office so out of touch with its fan base that it is playing games with the Peyton Hillis situation? That stadium will be empty next year if Hillis is not on the roster. I am a Browns Backer, work with 40 plus Browns fans, and friends and family combined agree on one thing: We finally have a nationally recognized hero in Peyton Hillis who makes these games watchable, sign him! If they don't I will be a fan of wherever Hillis lands. -- Gregg Juchum, Brunswick
Hey, Gregg: It takes two sides to make a deal. You are basically saying: Pay Hillis whatever it takes to keep him on the team. I'm sure Hillis appreciates the sentiment, but I don't think the Browns share it.
Hey, Tony: Why do teams and/or players negotiate contracts during the season when it becomes a distraction to the team and player? It seems it would make more sense to do this during the off-season. -- Joel Emrick, Sidney, Ohio
Hey, Joel: Good point. The problem was the owners' lockout shut down all NFL business for four months. When business resumed, there was so much to take care of that renegotiating contracts took a backseat. However, that didn't prevent new deals for Joe Thomas, Evan Moore, Chris Gocong and Ahtyba Rubin from happening.
Hey, Tony: With five games in the books, here is a draft question for you. In the 2012 draft do you take the best receiver available (Justin Blackmon) or the second-best QB (Landry Jones) since no way could they pry Luck loose from whoever drafts first? -- Terry T, Portland, Ore.
Hey, Terry: I haven't studied the players, or their backgrounds. Why commit to either until you have to? Let the season play out before worrying about the draft.
Hey, Tony: The question isn't about the Browns, but it is a football question. Who decided that the Dallas Cowboys should be known as "America's Team"? I just heard it again and it makes me crazy. They aren't my team and never will be. I root for whoever is playing against them. -- Jane Hilf, Cleveland
Hey, Jane: The term "America's Team" was coined by NFL Films, when it did one of those season highlight films on the Cowboys in the 1970s. Initially, the Cowboys didn't like the moniker, but they found it to be a lucrative promotional tool. The fact you root for whomever plays against them proves it is a rather effective slogan.
Joshua Gunter, The Plain DealerSure, Browns fans want more from Colt McCoy ... then again, it's kinda hard to throw touchdown passes from this position. Hey, Tony: After watching the Raiders D put a smack-down on Colt McCoy and the Browns' offense, how much longer is it going to take for Mike Holmgren to realize McCoy doesn't possess the skills to be an effective NFL starter and put Seneca Wallace in there? Lastly, are the Browns ever going to wear their Brown jerseys again? I ask because changing jerseys could be the one thing to get McCoy and the Browns' offense over the hump. -- Doug Furtado, Vermilion
Hey, Doug: There is no sentiment within the organization to play Wallace ahead of McCoy. This season was dedicated to finding out whether McCoy can be the franchise quarterback. It will take 16 games to make a viable evaluation. Your assumption about changing jerseys to change McCoy's luck is one reason I have re-instituted my moratorium on uniform questions. I am sure you realize there is no correlation and you are just trying to get under my skin.
Hey, Tony: I was not a Eric Mangini fan but I can say without a question the team was better prepared on game day. The team is putting Colt at a disadvantage and he will never make it the whole season. We give a team 14 points on special teams? You've got to be kidding me. At this point do you feel the only other opportunity for a win will be against the Rams? Do you think 3-13 is the best they can do? They are regressing each week. -- Joe Maloney, Woodland, Calif.
Hey, Joe: I don't know exactly if Woodland, Calif., is in the north or south of the state. Regardless, please stay off the Golden Gate Bridge.
Hey, Tony: I am finished. ... I am 57 and grew up with good Browns football with my dad. This is another joke. Twelve years is too much. They should have stayed away. I guess I'll go back to the Packers, who were my team when the Browns moved. I mean ... it's so sad and embarrassing to watch. Don't you agree? -- Brian Principe, Lakewood
Hey, Brian: Stay off the I-480 bridge.
Hey, Tony: I expected much better Sunday in Oakland coming off the bye week. The offense and special teams are major disappointments. Are my expectations too high? -- Stan Maziejka, Saratoga Springs, N.Y.
Hey, Stan: Yes. They are five games into a totally new program.
Hey, Tony: What has happened to Colt McCoy? Or is he not the guy? -- Lou Kovach, Cary, N.C.
Hey, Lou: McCoy has 11 games to prove he is the guy. The defenses he'll oppose don't get any easier in the second half of the schedule.
Hey, Tony: Will the Browns realize the dismal state of affairs that exists in Berea (as they have so often done in the past) and actually do something about it? Where was Hillis? Is McCoy the real deal? Is Shurmur the answer? Come on, Holmgren, enough of the excuses! I can't take anymore of this ineptitude! I spent $330 for NFL Ticket for this? -- Martin Micco, Kamuela, Hawaii
Hey, Martin: Why do fans assume that teams coming off a bye automatically have some type of strategic edge? It's an assumption that is totally unsubstantiated.
Hey, Tony: We're going to put the ball in our playmakers hands. That's what Shurmur said. My question is, "What playmakers?" The offence is pathetic (same as last year) the defense can't stop anybody (same as last year). Is there any hope that the Browns will be even mediocre this year? It [stinks] living down here by Cincinnati and hearing about the 4-2 Bengals when the Browns should be the improving team. Talk me in from the ledge. -- Ralph Reis, Fort Mitchell, Ky.
Hey, Ralph: Two things about Cincinnati: The Bengals have more talent. The Bengals provided their young quarterback with a stud young receiver. Brilliant, no?
John Kuntz, The Plain DealerPeyton Hillis has found that getting yards against NFL defenses is easier -- when healthy -- than finding an agreement with management over a new contract. Hey, Tony: OK. The whole Hillis situation is just plain weird. It's the coach's decision to pull him out, then it's a hamstring, then magically he's healed and playing. I have not read from any writer exactly what Hillis is asking for and exactly what the Browns are willing to pay. Or even, how far apart are they? How about some details? -- Ernie Logothetides, Lyndhurst
Hey, Ernie: I only have theories because the sides are not talking. I've heard the Hillis camp is asking in the $8 million-a-year range. I've heard the Browns are in the $4 million-a-year range. Quite a wide gap, if those figures are in the ballpark.
Hey, Tony: You knew I was gonna bring up the special teams debacle (being I'm a big supporter of Eric Mangini). Maybe Mangini (the new Cleveland Bill Belichick) was onto something with the special teams play being an important part of the game. It just cost us a game this week. -- Rick DelPrado, Middletown, Conn.
Hey, Rick: Took this long for somebody to bring up special teams?
Hey, Tony: The Lions go from zero wins to a strong team with a 5-1 record in three years. The 49ers put in place a new coach and a new offense without an off-season and they are sitting at a very relevant 4-2. Quarterbacks such as Matt Ryan, Joe Flacco, and Cam Newton play well as rookies. The Browns are stuck in the mud, again. What will the spark be that finally turns this team around? Other than Peyton Hillis as mayor of Elyria, of course. -- Jared Pelcic, Elyria
Hey, Jared: A good quarterback makes geniuses of a lot of people. New Orleans was the worst franchise in the NFL until Drew Brees rescued it. Matthew Stafford is doing the same for Detroit.
Hey, Tony: Where is Lawrence Vickers? Why is a rookie fullback being relied upon to take over that monumental task of making his running backs look good? -- Matthew Loar, Muncie, Ind.
Hey, Matthew: Vickers is riding the bench in Houston. Simply put, the Browns did not like Vickers. I've heard it was more a personality thing than a football decision.
Hey, Tony: McCoy and the Browns have played five games this year and to be honest, McCoy has looked below average to poor. The only times he has looked good have been when he ran the two-minute offense vs. Miami to win the game and the second-to-last drive vs. Oakland. Can you explain why the Browns won't go no-huddle in the middle of games to keep the defense honest? So far our offense has looked horrendous outside of those two drives. Why not mix in what works every once in a while? -- Greg Johnson, Chardon
Hey, Greg: When we ask those questions we do not get definitive answers. Perhaps they are working on it behind closed doors.
Hey, Tony: I watched a little of the Lions game and was amazed to see a QB who could throw and receivers who could catch. I was so envious. I wouldn't mind if the Browns would just show up, but they are unprepared, seem to have no game plan and no discipline. I am 63 years old, have been a life-long fan and people who know me know I love the Browns. But I am worn out. Any advice for a truly depressed fan? -- Debbie Badonsky, Kettering, Ohio
Hey, Debbie: The Browns are 2-3. Two years ago, they started out 1-11. It was worse then, believe me.
Hey, Tony: What are the chances the front office is second-guessing their decision on Shurmur? His offense is the second-worst in the NFL, his play-calling does not even come close to playing to the strengths of what "talent" he does have, he stubbornly sticks with rookie guards when they have made mistake after mistake, his inconsistent lineups have ticked off or alienated Hillis and Cribbs, the team's two best (only two) playmakers, and his love affair with Hardesty has left a "Braylon Edwards" amount of drops snuffing out drives. -- Chris Zanon, Canton
Hey, Chris: I didn't sense this panic when the Browns started 1-4 under the previous coach.
Hey, Tony: On paper it looked as if they had two weeks to prepare for the Raiders but on the field it looked like everybody took the two weeks off. The new, no pads, no hitting during the week walk-through practice sessions don't seem to be helping anyone get into a rhythm for game day and I can't see this team getting any better during the season without dedicated, intense practices during the week. If teams like Alabama, LSU, and Oklahoma practiced like the Browns do, it wouldn't matter what their recruiting classes were like, they would look like the Browns on game day. I think how you play is a reflection of how you practice. The 49ers are in a similar situation to the Browns with new coaches, new systems and new players. Do you think because Jim Harbaugh is an intense coach that the 49ers are having more intense practices and that is why they are improving or seem to be improving every week? -- Jan Bilson, Bradenton, Fla.
Hey, Jan: Apparently, you have been privy to the Browns' practices. I, as a member of the media, only get to view the first 30 minutes. So you are telling me something I didn't know. I am sure that hard-practicing Alabama, LSU and Oklahoma would compete well against the likes of NFL teams Oakland, Tennessee and Cinicinnati. Yes, Harbaugh is an intense coach and the 49ers are doing well. Bartender, I'll have a double, please.
Hey, Tony: 1) Where does the root of the offensive struggles lie, with McCoy or Shurmur? 2) If the season ended today and the Browns had to prepare for the draft, and you were in charge, would a QB be a priority? 3) Aside from Andrew Luck, who are the other key QBs expected to enter the draft? -- Sean S, Chandler, Ariz.
Hey, Sean: 1. McCoy. 2. Yes. 3. Landry Jones of Oklahoma is considered the next-best QB.
Hey, Tony: Why aren't the Browns not wearing their home colors (brown and orange)? If you look around the stadium you will see brown and orange, not white. We love to see our home team in their colors. -- Doyle Miller, Cleveland
Hey, Doyle: Crickets.
Hey, Tony: I am listening to your podcast today. I am retired in Florida and don't get real good info on what is happening with the Browns. It sounds as if the offense is not clicking and Shurmur is the OC. Any talk on GM or Mike Holmgren getting concerned about Shurmur's play calling? -- Rich Shawbell, West Palm Beach, Fla.
Hey, Rich: As a former coach, Holmgren knows that his West Coast offense needs time for everyone to function with the precise timing needed to make it work right.
Hey, Tony: Why isn't Cribbs returning kicks and punts? In Chicago I see Devin Hester doing a great job on special teams and serving as an effective second or third wide receiver. If Cribbs had become an elite No. 1 receiver I'd get it, but that's hardly the case. -- Doug Shaffer, Orange, Calif.
Hey, Doug: OK, folks, time to start watching the games before submitting questions. Cribbs is returning kickoffs and punts. It's just that most of the kickoffs against the Browns have been blasted out of the end zone as a result of the dumb new kickoff rule.
Hey, Tony: At the beginning of the season we were treated to a flurry of stories about the players delight with Shurmur "treating them like men," etc., after their treatment under the previous coach. Now that we are hearing of the complaining and squabbling, are we returning to the Crennel days of the inmates running the asylum? -- David King, Joelton, Tenn.
Hey, David: Just because a couple guys are frustrated with their playing time doesn't mean the inmates are running the asylum.
Hey, Tony: When your best offensive weapon this year is a TE (Ben Watson) and you don't really have any WRs that keep defensive coordinators up at night, can you tell me why in the world the Browns didn't pursue Brandon Lloyd for the bargain-basement price of a low draft pick in 2012? -- Jeff Biletnikoff, Erie, Pa.
Hey, Jeff: It should be obvious to any Browns fan that the club committed the 2011 season to seeing what they had in their present WR corps.
Hey, Tony: I have heard you and others identify the lack of quality wide receivers being one of the problems with this year's team. I agree but feel the lack of a true No. 1 receiver is impacting every play the offense runs. The Browns face seven- and eight-man fronts most of the time, which makes it hard to run and brings more pressure than the line can block when we try to pass. Do you agree with this assessment? -- Fred Burke, Richmond, Va.
Hey, Fred: It's one reason I was against trading the No. 6 pick and falling 21 spots and not taking the second-best receiver.
Hey, Tony: I have heard and read many theories about why the Browns' offense has looked so stagnant. Watch the Browns games with a stop watch in your hand and see how long it takes for Colt to get rid of the ball! Not only does he take well over four seconds to make a decision but he never makes all of his reads, either. My question is what has this coaching staff done to him? -- Gary Alfrey, Medina
Hey, Gary: McCoy was a mystery to opponents last year. Now they have a book on him. I know that after four of the five games, he has expressed the point that he saw things on defense that he did not expect. Overall, McCoy is getting much better coaching in his second season.
Joshua Gunter, The Plain DealerJosh Cribbs has improved as a receiver this season, says Tony Grossi. Hey, Tony: What do you think of Cribbs' reaction to your question concerning special teams at the end of the game? I'm wondering if part of his frustration was a byproduct of apparently not being where he was supposed to be on a deep throw in the first half. It brings up the $60 million question once again: Are the receivers not getting open and/or are they not sure where to be, or is McCoy just throwing inaccurately and/or not reading the defenses correctly? -- John Neiswander, Berthoud, Colo.
Hey, John: The weird thing is I think Cribbs is better as a WR than he's ever been. As for the chicken-and-egg question regarding the passing game, I will say this: When a quarterback is averaging 19 incompletions a game, it can't be all on the receivers.
Hey, Tony: With the lack of development at the QB position, what's a plausible root cause? 1. Colt isn't a player capable of development? or 2. Shurmur is not capable of developing the position given his current role as head coach? -- Michael Cosgray, Cincinnati
Hey, Michael: You're not even considering that five games is too little of a sample for making conclusions on McCoy or Shumur.
Hey, Tony: There was a feature interview with Paul Warfield in the USA Today last week. Warfield stated that Art Modell was left with little choice regarding the move after voters rejected a plan to renovate Municipal Stadium. I don't remember that vote. More fantasy from the mind of Paul Warfield? -- Matt Dennis, Cleveland
Hey, Matt: Voters passed the half-baked stadium renovation plan by a 60-40 margin. The fact is Modell already had agreed to take the Maryland money and stadium deal.
Hey, Tony: Now that Patricia Modell has passed and Art is in poor health, why not lighten up and let Art join the NFL Hall of Fame. Perhaps it would even be a good omen for the new Browns to move upward. The Modells were good for Cleveland when they lived there and your block is starting to look far too vindictive. -- Jay Lenrow, Baltimore, Md.
Hey, Jay: I think it's time to consider Robert Irsay for the Ravens Ring of Honor.
Hey, Tony: We're playing worse this year with more talent. And an easier schedule. And no rotation at quarterback. And Hardesty is back. Mangini wasn't perfect, but good god, he was better than what we got now. Sheesh. -- John Baughman, Lorain
Hey, John: Mangini wasn't perfect? Don't be so hard on him. He won five games two years in a row, for crying out loud.
Hey, Tony: I've had enough about folks saying because of the lockout McCoy stinks (new offense, etc.). How is it that the Bengals have a rookie QB and a new offense and are strides ahead of the Browns? Is it that Dalton is that much better than McCoy, more playmakers in Cincinnati? -- Craig L, Tinley Park, Ill.
Hey, Craig: It's an interesting dynamic going on in Cincinnati. I'll be very interested to see the Dalton Gang vs. the Browns on Nov. 27 in Cincinnati. My hunch is that Dalton is benefiting from a better running game and a true No. 1 receiver.
Hey, Tony: Shurmur seems to be avoiding doing things that were successful last year to do it his way. Is this more about his ego or more about trying to get the team to do it his way? Or a little of both? -- Bill Dragon, Mount Vernon, Iowa
Hey, Bill: If you're referring to the way the Browns ran the ball last year -- lining up two tight ends, a fullback and Peyton Hillis and handing off play after play -- Holmgren and Shurmur are in agreement that to win games you need to throw successfully and run when you want to run. To run the ball simply to be able to say, "We're in the top 10 in running the ball" doesn't make sense if you win five games and are incapable of throwing it. So the Browns are trying to develop their passing game. I think we can all agree that it takes more than five games to implement a completely new offensive system.
Hey, Tony: There has been a lot of talk about Al Davis but no talk I have seen about who is taking over ownership of the Raiders. Does he have a wife? Family? Partners? Who gets the keys to the car?-- Bill Dragon, Mount Vernon, Iowa
Hey, Bill: Wife Carol Davis and son Mark assume ownership of the Raiders.
Hey, Tony: Why is it so difficult to get the ball into Josh Cribbs' hands? They threw him one screen pass that went for 23 yards. Why isn't there more of this? Until they can get Cribbs the ball in space so he can make plays, I believe he is insignificant on offense. -- David Fain, Macon, Ga.
Hey, David: I am in total agreement.
Hey, Tony: Unless I miscounted the wins and losses, aren't the numbers of Bernie Kosar and McCoy very similiar during the same number of rookie starts? Also, what were some of the concerns during Kosar's rookie year and do you see the same concerns with McCoy? -- Rich Salois, Missoula, Mont.
Hey, Rich: It's a fair discussion, though the teams were at different stages of development with different levels of talent. Kosar and McCoy also were two distinctly different quarterbacks with different skill sets. One obvious difference is that Kosar knew how to beat a blitz as a rookie.
Hey, Tony: On Tuesday, after the Oakland loss, USA Today reported that "TV cameras at one point appeared to show Browns running backs coach Gary Brown telling Hillis to get away from him on the sidelines" sometime in the late second or early third quarter. To my knowledge, the MRI results for Hillis haven't been announced yet, leading me to believe this might be a concerted effort to depress his numbers, and by proxy his "value," when a new contract is finally negotiated. What do you make of this entire situation? -- Tim, Winter Haven, Fla.
Hey, Tim: Hillis suffered a hamstring injury in the first quarter. For whatever reason, the Browns' PR staff failed to deliver this information in a timely fashion. A perfect storm of miscommunication, confusion and lack of accountability created the erroneous impression that Hillis was benched by the coach. How this can happen at the NFL level is an issue the club should investigate and correct.
Hey, Tony: I have a few questions. First, I haven't heard much about staph infections. Has this problem been resolved? Second, what is the status of Joe Jurevicius' lawsuit against the Browns? Does Colt McCoy remind you of Charlie Frye? -- Mark Patti, Hartville, Ohio
Hey, Mark: 1. Yes. 2. Jurevicius came to an undisclosed settlement. 3. To be honest, at times he does.
Hey, Tony: After the loss to the Titans I have to admit I was wrong about McCoy, as clearly he is substandard. Ergo, do you think Holmgren has lost faith as well and would we offer our first-round picks in 2012 and our first in 2013 to move up to No. 1 overall for Luck? Finally, if Jim Harbaugh was our coach, don't you think we would be at least 3-2 vs. 2-3? -- Mark Tucker, Boston
Hey, Mark: It would take more than three No. 1s to move up for Luck. I think Holmgren still has faith in McCoy. Speculating on the Browns' record with Harbaugh is a waste of energy.
Hey, Tony: The no-huddle offense we see McCoy run at the end of games seems to have some success, but hasn't it performed well enough to deserve more of a look? -- Josh Weaver, Lancaster, Pa.
Hey, Josh: The Dolphins played soft zone coverage at the end of their game, giving McCoy short passes to avoid getting beat deep. Ultimately, they played not to lose and lost. Defenses play differently at other points of the game. That said, I would like to see the Browns try a no-huddle attack earlier in games.
Hey, Tony: Since the Browns' braintrust has totally blown up the team for younger, inexperienced and average talented players, by the time there is a competitive team on the field will Shurmur still be the Browns head coach? -- Rex Hamlett, The Villages, Fla.
Hey, Rex: Yes.
Hey, Tony: I took a hard game-by-game look at the 2010 St. Louis Rams to try to make sense of what is happening to our Browns. What was evident was that the same exact problems that McCoy is having now happened to Sam Bradford in 2010. Blogs were screaming about the inept play-calling by Shurmur, Bradford's inaccuracy, that they never threw the ball down field and never used Stephen Jackson. For 2010 Bradford had an average per attempt of only 5.95 yards. You have been very critical of McCoy and that he is the sole reason for our problems but based on everything considered I believe Pat Shurmur is in way over his head and McCoy will continue to struggle and be blamed. -- George Schmidt, Cleveland
Hey, George: Some thoughts: 1. Bradford was a rookie. McCoy is a veritable rookie. Rookie QBs struggle no matter the offensive system. 2. Jackson had more than 300 carries last year and more than 1,200 yards. 3. The Rams dropped seven passes in the deciding final game against Seattle.
Hey, Tony: I see Shurmur as the real issue this year for the Browns, do you agree? The man is predictable and it seems he has not a ounce of faith in his players. -- Dustin Fox, Lakewood
Hey, Dustin: Don't agree. Predictable? Passes on third-and-1? A pitchout to the No. 3 halfback on fourth-and-1? No faith in his players? Don't agree.
Hey, Tony: Any thoughts about having Kellen Winslow Jr. come in at the beginning of training camp to talk to the players about proper motorcycle use? -- Paul Thiel, Crescent Springs, Ky.
Hey, Paul: He'd be the last guy to give such a talk.
-- Tony