The mailbag is overflowing (of course), but Tony Grossi keeps providing answers to demanding Browns fans.
John Kuntz, The Plain DealerWhile the Browns aren't spending a lot of their cap money on free agents, they will certainly be looking to extend the contracts of their most valuable veterans, including Pro Bowl tackle Joe Thomas. Hey, Tony: Reports have the Browns at somewhere around $30 million under the new salary floor. Any word on how they are going to get to the minimum, since they aren't giving out any big-time contracts in free agency? Joe Thomas and some other key guys could use a big extension. -- Chris Wenning, Canton
Hey, Chris: There has been a lot of confusion about the so-called salary floor. The team-by-team minimum spending floor does not take effect until 2013. Over the 2011-12 seasons, the league as a whole has to spend 99 percent of the entire cap on player contracts. The spending must take place by the end of the seasons. That said, I would consider the following players potentially in line for contract extensions: Thomas, Peyton Hillis, Ahtyba Rubin, D'Qwell Jackson, Evan Moore and Colt McCoy.
Hey, Tony: Could you tell me why the Cleveland Browns are not practicing twice a day like they used to do? They have a new offense and a new defense they need the practice. The new CBA isn't totally ratified yet, so why not get the practice they need? -- Frederick Blosser, Sylvania, Ohio
Hey, Frederick: The league set the rules. The Browns can't violate them just because they're installing new systems.
Hey, Tony: Why the canceled practice in the very first week of camp? Did any other teams do this? -- Tom Bateman, Charlottesville, Va.
Hey, Tom: The practice wasn't canceled. The new CBA rules call for one off day per week in training camp. Pat Shurmur chooses which day to give the players off. Some NFL executives believe the training camp rules will be revised next year.
Hey, Tony: I will admit that I was a believer in Eric Mangini and his program. However, as a Browns fan first, I want what's best for the team and that chapter has been closed. I am not here to debate his tenure. While I was pleased that Mike Holmgren originally gave Mangini another season in 2010, it is apparent that the relationship was never going to work, and Holmgren knew it. I found it very interesting in your recent article concerning Jayme Mitchell, and how he was reassured by Browns management that changes were in the works. To me, if changes were inevitable, then Holmgren should have changed coaches as soon as he came in as team president after the 2009 season. I think that we would be much better off this year if we had a our transition year in 2010 and had our new systems in place. I feel that our program was put back at least another season, if not two because of the timing with the lockout. -- Scott MacKenna, Sarasota, Fla.
Hey, Scott: For the most part, I agree.
Hey, Tony: What's the deal with Coye Francies? I saw him a few preseasons ago and he appeared to be a hitter but that was under the Eric Mangini regime. Any chance he could make the roster and contribute? What's the scouting report on him? -- Mike Mucha, Marion, Va.
Hey, Mike: The Browns would like nothing better than for Francies to earn a roster spot and contribute. I'm not sure what the problem is, but he seemed more into the flow as a rookie than now.
Hey, Tony: I believe Tom Heckert said the team wants to invest in the Browns' existing young players instead of free agents. Sounds great. Shouldn't they lock up Joe Thomas for the rest of his career and front load his new contract with money from this year's salary cap since they have so much room? -- Scott, Brunswick
Hey, Scott: I'm sure Thomas appreciates your concern. I'm also sure it will be taken care of during the season. It's not an issue right now.
Joshua Gunter, The Plain DealerThe loud minority of Steelers fans in Northeast Ohio baffles one long-range observer ... but only winning will change that situation. Hey, Tony: I just visited Ohio to see the Browns' training camp, the Rock Hall, etc. I noticed a lot of cars with Ohio plates carrying Steelers stickers. Is it possible that because the Browns have been so awful for so long that some Browns fans have turned to the dark side? Makes me sick and I'm not even from Ohio. -- Ted Hebert, Longmeadow, Mass.
Hey, Ted: These things run in cycles. Some day the Browns will be on top and cars with Pennsylvania plates will sport Browns stickers.
Hey, Tony: First, who are the backup tackles behind Joe Thomas and Tony Pashos? Feels like we are thin in that area. Second, is Brian Robiskie showing anything in this camp? Third, have any of the undrafted rookies stood out in a good way? -- Matt Alsip, Towson, Md.
Hey, Matt: The top backup tackles are Branndon Braxton and Phil Trautwein. Braxton has opened some eyes early on. Robiskie, like the other receivers, has struggled a bit, I believe, with the intricacies of the new offense. He's not dropping balls, though. I wouldn't panic. The loss of the off-season would hurt any team transitioning to the West Coast offense. As for the undrafted rookies, receiver Chris Matthews passes the eyeball test. He's 6-5 and, wearing No. 17, strikes a close resemblance to Braylon Edwards -- at least lining up.
Hey, Tony: It's obvious that you are not a big fan of the Browns trading down in the NFL Draft. While I think Julio Jones will be a good player, don't you think if the Browns had drafted him he would have ended up being a very talented player on a very untalented team? Even if we did draft Jones, I don't think he adds or subtracts any more wins for the Browns then Phil Taylor because the team is so young and lacking talented depth. What do you think? -- Bo Mueller, North Ridgeville
Hey, Bo: How does an untalented team become talented? By drafting talented players. When you bypass talented players for the express purpose of collecting bodies to fill out roster spots, I don't see how that is making your team better. I have stated my objection to the trade in 2011. I am being consistent with my criticism of the trade-down in 2009. You cannot keep trading out of the top 10 of the draft and expect to get better by selecting centers and nose tackles. No disrespect to those positions. The sport is now a game of speed. The priority should be on playmakers, not space-eaters, in my opinion.
Hey, Tony: Now that the scale is in place and rookies won't be able to hold out too much, would you predict that there will be a lot of holdouts in the second or third year of a contract? For example, if Cam Newton has a great rookie year, do you think he could hold out next year to get something close to what Sam Bradford got last year? Secondly, on the way the wage scale is slotted -- the way that I understood it, each pick in the first round has a certain dollar amount attached. So for example, if a linebacker or defensive tackle had been the first pick instead of Newton, would they be slotted to ink the same deal that he got for his rookie contract? -- Brad Eckenfels, Austin, Texas
Hey, Brad: Holdouts in the second or third year of contracts are a potential hazard of the new rookie wage scale. They can be avoided by teams proactively redoing contracts for players clearly outperforming them. The slotted figures allotted for the first round do take into account the positions played by the drafted players.
Hey, Tony: Adam Schefter speculated that the Browns are not active in free agency because of all the money they are paying former coaches and GMs. Doesn't it have to be either that or Heckert, et al do not believe the team is close enough to warrant big bucks on a player or two just to fill holes? They are 35 million under the cap, after all. -- Toby Godfrey, Austin, Texas
Hey, Toby: Adam's point is certainly plausible. The dead money being paid former coaches and executives such as Phil Savage, Romeo Crennel, George Kokinis and Eric Mangini does not affect the salary cap, of course, but it may contribute to a cash crunch that has resulted in the current "don't spend" philosophy. I appreciate that Heckert is not a fan of free agency, but something is fishy about the team's approach this off-season.
Hey, Tony: I noticed Phil Taylor got a full four-year guarantee on his rookie contract. Is this a new development in contract negotiations due to the recent CBA or a change in philosophy by the front office? Are fully guaranteed deals good for the game or is the NFL headed for an NBA/MLB-type player motivation problem? -- Steve Cornelius, Avon Lake
Hey, Steve: One report indicated Taylor's fourth year is only partially guaranteed. Nevertheless, the league is moving indefatigably toward fully guaranteed contracts. That trend certainly is good for the players. I don't know if it's good for the game.
Hey, Tony: Any interest in Bills safety Donte Whitner? -- Gary Putz, Rochester, N.Y.
Hey, Gary: Whitner signed with San Francisco on Thursday. Prior to that, the Browns showed no interest in signing him.
Hey, Tony: Why haven't the Browns already picked up Ryan Donahue (P), Iowa? -- TL Davis, Bowling Green, Ky.
Hey, TL: Because they signed Richmond McGee, who had experience with GM Tom Heckert in Philadelphia and special teams coach Chris Tabor in Chicago.
Hey, Tony: The Browns have a few holes to fill and lack depth in most groups. Only two other teams have more cap space, yet they are not picking up the free agents they need. My question is this. Do you see any similarities between this year vs. the year before the Browns moved to Baltimore? -- Gary Wetherald, Peoria, Ill.
Hey, Gary: No. The owner of the team in 1995 was heading toward bankruptcy. The owner of the team in 2011 is a billionaire.
Lisa DeJong, The Plain DealerMike Holmgren is keeping a close watch on his investments ... but many Browns fans are wondering if the roster is being built on the cheap. Hey, Tony: As you watch the Browns progress in this year's training camp, do you get a sense the combination of Mike Holmgren and Tom Heckert are putting together a more talented and athletic football team than what Browns fans have seen since coming back in '99? -- Greg Dineen, Middletown, Ohio
Hey, Greg: The 2002 Browns of Butch Davis made the playoffs. I'm waiting for another regime to at least match that feat.
Hey, Tony: I remember the Browns extended a second-round tender to Eric Wright. Now that he signed with Detroit, don't we get their second round pick in 2012? I'm not sure if that's correct with the new CBA. -- Karl Dietz, Pepper Pike
Hey, Karl: The Browns receive no compensation for losing Wright. The new CBA made Wright an unrestricted free agent and voided the second-round tender. Only restricted free agents bring compensation in return. Now, the Browns may be eligible for a compensatory pick in the 2012 draft, but that would be based on the net of free-agent losses vs. free-agent signings.
Hey, Tony: Did anyone verify that Brodrick Bunkley actually was in Cleveland and did not pass his physical? The whole situation, including Mary Kay Cabot's unnamed source, leaves me wondering. Heckert telling the media to ask Philly why he is not here! Very strange and looks like some assumptions rather than fact. -- Randy Russell, Pepper Pike
Hey, Randy: GMs have their own verbal agreements. In this case, Bunkley flunked his Cleveland physical, but Heckert agreed not to disclose that fact so as to protect Philadelphia's Plan B trade to Denver. The Broncos agreed to their trade without the stipulation that Bunkley pass a physical. My take on this incident is this: Always tell the truth. It shall set you free.
Hey, Tony: Earth to Browns: There's a FA frenzy going on and you have more needs than a pretzel factory! -- Michael Loeffler, Portland, Ore.
Hey, Michael: I didn't know pretzel factories had needs.
Hey, Tony: I just read online that the Bunkley deal was nixed because of medical concerns. I saw last night on the NFL channel that he refused to report to the Browns. What version is correct? -- Bill Tulino, Leesburg, Va.
Hey, Bill: Trust The Plain Dealer's report. The Browns had medical concerns with Bunkley.
Hey, Tony: Just wondering how Jim Donovan is doing. Living in Omaha, I don't get to see many games, so I listen to the games via the Internet. He's the voice of Sunday for me, so I wish him well and hope he can make it back to 100 percent soon! -- Gabe Knuth, Omaha, Neb.
Hey, Gabe: I've spoken to Jim on a few occasions since his bone marrow transplant surgery. Everything went well with the surgery and the donor match. He has experienced a few complications, which were not unexpected, but the overall prognosis for a full recovery is good. That doesn't mean he doesn't face some challenges, however. Jim has been very appreciative of the warm wishes extended to him during this time.
Hey, Tony: With some of the WR being held out of practice, has 6-5 Chris Matthews merited any attention from the coaching staff? -- Steve Landram, Saint Cloud, Fla.
Hey, Steve: His stature alone merits attention. I would say that nobody makes a team during the first two weeks of camp. The preseason games will separate the receivers.
Hey, Tony: Given the Browns' many needs, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity that this year's free agency offered (having to spend money to get to the floor), and the front office constant bumbling since the end of the lockout (uninspired draft, free agency MIA, Bunkley trade joke, not being able to sign the 22nd pick in the draft with a rookie salary cap, etc), would you consider this off-season an unmitigated disaster or just another display of ineptitude? -- Stu Kambury, Dallas
Hey, Stu: Neither. First, the Bunkley trade was not a fiasco, merely the case of player flunking his physical and the other team (Philadelphia) jumping the gun on the transaction. All that said, it's been a bewildering time to be a Browns fan, to be sure.
Hey, Tony: Has Jason Trusnik been traded to Miami? -- Ken Wright, Strongsville
Hey, Ken: Trusnik was an unrestricted free agent and the Browns did not desire him back.
Hey, Tony: Why aren't the Browns interested in Brian Finneran, formerly of the Falcons? I know him personally and he is a great guy, has great hands, is a super special teams player and would love to catch passes from Colt McCoy in the West Coast offense (I asked him). He has a good three or four years left in him and I believe would be a good addition. -- Jeff Babka, Suwanee, Ga.
Hey, Jeff: Everyone seems to want a new receiver in here except the men making those decisions. Let's see how it plays out.
Hey, Tony: Mike Sando of ESPN reported that Lofa Tatupu has been released and Marcus Trufant might be next. Do you know if Mike Holmgren has talked to Tatupu? Also, do you know if they have talked to the Eagles about trading for Asante Samuel? -- Andrew DiNovo, Columbus, Ohio
Hey, Andrew: There's no apparent interest in Tatupu. The PD has reported for sure there is no interest in trading for Samuel.
Hey, Tony: Why have the Browns been so lame in free agency? -- David Jensen, Naples, Fla.
Hey, David: Their position is clear. Build through the draft. Use free agency sparingly.
Hey, Tony: Do you see the Browns going after a DL like Jamall Anderson or Tony Brown or a wideout like Malcolm Floyd or Johnny Lee Higgins? -- Nick Anderson, Sevierville, Tenn.
Hey, Nick: No, no, no and no.
Hey, Tony: There was talk that the Browns may try to sign a CB. Now that many of them are signed, the Browns fans in Huntsville hope that our hometown favorite, Ramzee Robinson, looks like a player that could fill the void. What do you think? -- Ben Faulds, Huntsville, Ala.
Hey, Ben: Since you sent your question, the Browns signed ex-Eagles CB Dimitri Patterson. Robinson is still on the roster competing for a spot.
Hey, Tony: Last spring you answered a question that the Browns' record should be better this year. Do you still feel the same way? It is obvious to me that H and H are positioning themselves for a top 5 draft position (and possibly the Andrew Luck sweepstakes) in 2012. Their lack of signing any quality free agents seems to confirm that. Your thoughts? -- Bill Reinke, Keene, Texas
Hey, Bill: I'm not prepared to give a prediction on number of wins yet. Believe me, I'll stick my neck out at the appropriate time. I really do not believe the Browns are "tanking" to position themselves for a better chance at Luck. I just think they have confidence in their player acquisitions and are going about methodically building their team the way they want.
Hey, Tony: With the Browns not being active at all in free agency, have they hit the required cap floor yet? -- Stan, Solon
Hey, Stan: The so-called salary floor has been misunderstood by us in the media and, thus, by our readers. The team-by-team floor does not take effect until 2013. Until then, the league as a whole has to spend up to 99 percent of the cap on player salaries. These complex computations take place during the season -- not at the start -- so that teams will be informed how much room is left and can be spent on reinvesting in veterans on the team.
Hey, Tony: Do my beloved Browns have a realistic shot at making to the playoffs? -- T.W. (Bill) Morrison, Presque Isle, Maine
Hey, T.W.: Define "realistic."
Hey, Tony: How satisfied are you with the Browns' FA work and do you see any moves you believe they will make? Given Braylon Edwards' court case and his history of drops, are you surprised the charges themselves weren't dropped? -- Jim Plunkett, Tamarac, Fla.
Hey, Jim: First, my question to you is what do you do with your Super Bowl rings? Seriously, I don't foresee any headline acquisitions coming through free agency. As for Braylon, it's good he is far away as possible from Cleveland, don't you think?
Hey, Tony: With the short preseason and no OTA, do you think we will see more of the starters in the preseason? -- Ralph Reis, Ft. Mitchell, Ky.
Hey, Ralph: Let's hope that is the case. Maybe the exhibition games will be a little more compelling that way.
Hey, Tony: I was looking at the roster on the Browns' Web site. They are listing Owen Marecic as a running back, not a fullback. Do you think that that is just a mistake on the part of the person inputting the information or, is there a chance the Browns will be fielding two Hillis-style backs this season? -- Chris Ramey, Toledo
Hey, Chris: No, Marecic is a fullback.
Hey, Tony: What day and time is Training Camp Daily going to be on this year? -- Ken Yablonosky, Uniontown, Pa.
Hey, Ken: When the Indians are playing, Training Camp Daily on STO follows the Indians post-game show. When the Indians are not playing, TCD is on at 10 p.m.
-- Tony