With Lonnie Chisenhall comes hope, but also a word of warning for Tribe fans.
Can Cord Phelps pull off the rare feat of making it to the Majors for the first time, and staying there?
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- It's great news that the Indians have promoted Lonnie Chisenhall to take over third base.
But here's the warning: Most young players don't just hit a bump in the road to the majors, they often drive right into a ditch. Consider that the last significant Tribe prospect to come to Cleveland and stay without a return to the minors is C.C. Sabathia. That's all the way back to 2001.
"Going to the majors is never a walk in the park for any young player," said Tribe minor league director Ross Atkins. "The same will be true for Lonnie."
So the odds are against Chisenhall avoiding a refresher course at Columbus at some point. The good news is Josh Tomlin and Vinnie Pestano are in their first exposure to Wahoo baseball, and they look like keepers.
In 2007, the Indians had Josh Barfield sinking at second base when they recalled Asdrubal Cabrera. Over the final seven weeks of the season, Cabrera hit .283 and was sensational at second. The next spring, Cabrera showed up heavy and spent part of 2008 in the minors, before starting the real path to the mature All-Star we see today.
The Tribe's last playoff appearance was 2007. Cabrera wasn't the only impact player to come from the minors. So did Raffy Perez (1-2, 1.78 ERA), Jensen Lewis (1-1, 2.15 ERA) and Franklin Gutierrez (.266, 13 HR, 36 RBI in 100 games).
Perez had a refresher course in Columbus in 2009. Lewis went up and down and then was cut last week by the Clippers. Gutierrez was traded to Seattle.
But the point is they all helped that 2007 team win the Central Division.
Immediate help
So there is reason for at least short-term optimism with Chisenhall and Cord Phelps -- tempered with a healthy respect for how hard it is for players to stay in the majors.
"Lonnie got off to a slow start this year because he faced a lot of lefties early and he was a 22-year-old adjusting to Class AAA," said Atkins. "But he has made a lot of progress, especially on defense. He has a short, simple swing that should serve him well. I think he's ready for the challenge."
Most 22-year-olds are in Class AA Akron or below, so Chisenhall is already on the interstate to Cleveland. He batted .247 in April, .278 in May and then had a very strange June. He started the month 2-for-21. He then missed 11 days with a concussion, and came back sizzling -- 9-of-21 with 14 RBI in six games.
At Columbus, Chisenhall batted .265 (.779 OPS) with seven homers, 44 RBI. He was 27-of-75 (.360) with runners in scoring position.
"We didn't bring Lonnie up just because he had a good week," said General Manager Chris Antonetti. "He's made real strides since the start of the season."
Chisenhall slumps when he tries to pull most pitches, very tempting in Columbus where the right-field wall is short and inviting from home plate.
Antonetti admitted that the Indians' lack of hitting is an issue. Jack Hannahan opened the season at third, batting .273 in April. Since then, he's a .181 hitter.
If the Indians weren't contending for a playoff spot, they might have left Chisenhall in the minors longer, especially as he batted only .200 against left-handed pitching. The Indians may rest him against some tough lefties, but as Antonetti said, "Lonnie is here to play."
In addition to two hits Monday night in Arizona, Chisenhall had several nice plays at third -- and displayed a flamethrower for an arm. Atkins said Chisenhall has really improved on making that long, accurate throw on the backhand near the third-base line, which he did Monday.
Settling in
Antonetti said the plan also is for Phelps "to play quite a bit." The 24-year-old second baseman was 1-for-16 after his promotion, and is 8-for-25 (.320) since, heading into Tuesday night's game. But he has made five errors in 10 games at second base.
"That's just not Cord," said Atkins. "He always has been a solid second baseman. I think he'll work through this."
Since 2009, Phelps has only 20 errors in 240 games at second base. This season, he had no errors in 13 games at second, four in 23 games at shortstop -- a position he hadn't played since high school.
Atkins is convinced the switch-hitting Phelps will play well. He also has 521 Class AAA at-bats, hitting .308 (.886 OPS). So he should be prepared for the majors.
The key is for Manny Acta to make sure that Phelps and Chisenhall play at least five times a week. Orlando Cabrera can play second and third to relieve the two rookies. The 36-year-old infielder also is more productive with some rest, as has been evident lately.
Chisenhall is the Tribe's first-round pick in 2008; Phelps went in the third round (2008). Injured pitcher Alex White (first round, 2009) was impressive in his brief Cleveland trial. Jason Kipnis (second round, 2009) could be the next player promoted as he is "showing power, speed and really improving at second base," said Atkins.
Kipnis is batting .292 (.877 OPS) with nine homers, 44 RBI and nine triples for the Clippers. He also is 10-of-10 in steals.
Finally, the next wave of Tribe prospects is appearing, and that will be fun to watch.