Fausto Carmona's troubles continue as he can't hold 4-1 lead, with Colorado mounting a six-run fifth inning.
Chuck Crow, The Plain DealerCord Phelps can't believe second-base umpire Sam Holbrook's call as he's out at second base to end the eighth inning Monday at Progressive Field. Phelps' single scored Carlos Santana to close the Indians to an 8-7 deficit against Colorado before Phelps was called out trying to stretch the play to second. CLEVELAND, Ohio -- The Colorado Rockies, one day after being handled at home by Tigers right-hander Justin Verlander, faced Indians righty Fausto Carmona on Monday night at Progressive Field.
These days, that is akin to going from the coal mine to the beach. The Rockies roughed up Carmona for seven runs in 4 2/3 innings en route to a 8-7 victory. The Tribe (39-32) had a three-game winning streak snapped and lost for the first time in seven interleague decisions.
Colorado is 36-36 -- 19-19 at home and 17-17 on the road.
Carmona gave up nine hits, walked two and struck out none. He threw 38 of his 81 pitches in Colorado's six-run fifth.
"Usually when we score this many runs we win the ballgame, but that fifth inning killed us," Indians manager Manny Acta said. "Too bad, because Fausto was throwing so well."
The Rockies scored all six runs in the fifth after two were out.
"Fausto dug his own grave, basically," Acta said. "He lost his focus. I can't say anything but that."
Carmona, the Tribe's Opening day starter, is in a deep funk. He has allowed at least four earned runs in each of his last eight starts. In that span, he is 1-6 with an 8.87 ERA (44 2/3 innings, 44 earned).
Acta said there are no plans to do anything drastic with Carmona, who is 4-9 with a 6.17 ERA in 16 starts overall.
Overall, Carmona is 4-9 with a 6.17 ERA.
"He's pitching in five days," Acta said. "That's the solution we have here. You can't just get rid of him and bring somebody else in here.
Two years ago, Carmona struggled so badly that he was banished to the Arizona Rookie League in early June. He ended up 5-12 with a 6.32 ERA in 24 starts. Carmona rebounded last season, going 13-14 with a 3.77 ERA in 33 starts.
"The stuff's there. We know it's not the same as two years ago, because he put together seven good starts at the beginning of the year."
Big innings continue to dog Carmona. Of the 66 earned runs he has allowed in 96 1/3 innings, 38 have come in just 10 innings. The Indians trailed, 7-4, when Carmona exited. Down, 8-6, in the eighth, they almost unhooked him.
Trailing, 8-6, in the eighth, Cord Phelps hit a two-out single off former Indian Rafael Betancourt to drive in Carlos Santana. As Rockies third baseman Ty Wigginton cut the throw from left field, Phelps dashed for second. Phelps appeared to make it with a head-first slide, but umpire Sam Holbrook saw it differently.
Acta argued briefly.
"[Holbrook] said he got him in the arm, that he was on top of the play," Acta said. "He obviously got it wrong. He missed the call."
With every close call that goes against his club, Acta inches farther away from his old-school view that human error is part of the deal.
“Before I retire, I guess the game is going to turn into a flag-throwing, video-type of game,” he said.
The Tribe went 1-2-3 against closer Huston Street in the ninth, with Grady Sizemore flying to the warning track in right for the second out.
“Tough loss, but we battled the entire game,” said Orlando Cabrera, who went 1-for-3 with a walk in his first career start at third base.
Colorado took a 1-0 lead in the first on Troy Tulowitzki’s RBI single. The Tribe answered in its half with a three-run homer by Travis Hafner off righty Juan Nicasio. Hafner is hitting .341 with six homers in 35 games.
Santana homered in the fourth to make it 4-1. He has three homers in his last four games and 10 overall. He became the second Indian to reach double-digits in long balls, joining Asdrubal Cabrera (12).
Based on the way Carmona pitched in innings two through four, a three-run lead in the fifth seemed safe -- at least for a while. But things went south in a blink.
With two outs, Carmona walked No. 9 batter Iannetta. Gonzalez and Chris Nelson singled to load the bases for Helton. After the count went to 2-2, Carmona threw two balls to force in a run.
Tulowitzki swung at the next pitch and sent a two-hopper off the third-base bag, the ball kicking away from Orlando Cabrera toward the tarp. What might have gotten Carmona out of the inning with no further damage ended up being a two-run double that tied the score, 4-4.
Carmona fell behind 40-year-old Jason Giambi, 3-1. Giambi geared up for fastball and launched it an estimated 440 feet into the Tribe bullpen in center. Giambi has seven homers and six singles in 30 games this season.
After Smith doubled, Acta hooked Carmona for Chad Durbin. Boos ushered Carmona to the dugout. Durbin fanned Ty Wigginton for the third out.
“Fausto has the ability to make pitches when it counts, it just hasn’t been there,” Acta said.
The Indians responded with two in their half of the fifth. Shin-Soo Choo dumped a two-out, bases-loaded single into left-center to drive in Grady Sizemore and Michael Brantley. Choo was the first batter lefty Rex Brothers faced in relief of Nicasio.
Brantley narrowly missed a homer to right leading off the seventh. He eventually struck out looking.
The Rockies made it 8-6 in the eighth. Catcher Lou Marson air-mailed an attempted pickoff throw to first, allowing Charlie Blackmon to score from second. It was the first run given up by the bullpen in eight games. The run, charged to Rafael Perez, ended up being unearned.
On Twitter: @dmansworldpd